The Nines
The deep-dish pizza bar and music room in Ithaca's old Fire Station No. 9 on College Avenue, run by two owners for nearly 40 years until October 2018.
- Where
- 311 College Avenue, Collegetown, Ithaca, New York
- Open
- 1980–2018
- Known for
- Pizza, music and trivia in Collegetown's old firehouse
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

A bar in Fire Station No. 9
The Nines took its name from its building. 311 College Avenue in Collegetown had been Ithaca's Fire Station No. 9, a firehouse that Christine O'Malley of Historic Ithaca described as a physical, social and residential link between the university and the East Hill neighbourhood. Early Cornell trustee William H. Sage played a large part in getting it built, and the designs are associated with three Ithaca architects, Clinton L. Vivian, Arthur N. Gibb and Ornan H. Waltz.
The fire company moved into a new station built next door in the 1960s. Cornell's alumni magazine dates the first bar in the old building to the early 1970s, when it opened as a bar, restaurant and music venue called Old No. 9. The Cornell Daily Sun dates the Nines itself to 1980. Its owners for the next nearly 40 years were Mark Kielmann, a 1972 Cornell graduate, and Harold Schultz, who took on a run-down building and made it a gathering place.
Deep-dish pizza, trivia and live music
The Nines was a bar and pizza place best known for its deep-dish pizza and its trivia nights. Its raised front setback, where customers ate pizza and appetisers looking out on College Avenue, was one of the most familiar spots in Collegetown. The kitchen was on the second floor, and a dumbwaiter carried the food down. The outdoor patio was one of the largest in Collegetown, and alumni remembered crowding in after hockey games at Lynah Rink. Inside it kept up a reputation as an arts room and evening hangout, with open mic nights, live bands and Latin dance nights.
It drew Collegetown residents and Cornell students for four decades. Svante Myrick, a 2009 Cornell graduate who became Ithaca's mayor, said publicly in 2018 that the Nines was still one of the three reasons he went to Collegetown.
“We are not Fire Station #9. We have not been [here] for 50 years.”
The fight over landmarking the Nines
By 2017 the owners wanted to retire and sell. Visum Development offered $3 million for the property with plans to build housing. In response, the Ithaca Landmarks Preservation Commission proposed making the old firehouse a local landmark, which would have required its approval for any change to the outside of the building. Kielmann objected that the business was not Fire Station No. 9 and the firefighters had been gone for 50 years, and the owners promised to fight the designation all the way. The Nines' Facebook page called it an all-out war.
The vote came to Ithaca's Common Council in June 2018. The meeting ran about five hours and drew 52 public speakers. A compromise to landmark only the front of the building, including the setback, was turned down. The council split 5 to 5, and Mayor Myrick broke the tie by voting against designation. The city's assessor had estimated that landmark status would cut the property's value from $3 million to $1.4 million.
Closing night and the $3 million sale
In early October 2018 the Nines announced that it would close. Its last music show, Hail and Farewell Nines, featured Pete Panek and the Blue Cats on October 6, and the restaurant planned to serve through Sunday, October 7, or, as one server put it, until it ran out of food. A line cook told the Cornell Daily Sun that closing was what the owners had wanted for a while.
On April 2, 2019, the property sold for $3 million to the Collegetown developers John Novarr and Phil Proujansky, the same figure Visum had offered before the landmark fight. The city's assessed value at the time was $850,000.
Sources
- Farewell to The Nines: Collegetown Restaurant Likely to Close on Sunday, The Cornell Daily Sun
- The Nines Recommended to be a Historical Landmark, Owners Promise to 'Fight All the Way' Against Designation, The Cornell Daily Sun
- Common Council Douses Nines Designation, Clearing Way for Development, The Cornell Daily Sun
- The Nines Property Sells in $3 Million Deal to Local Developers, The Cornell Daily Sun
- A celebration of Collegetown eateries, Cornellians (Cornell Alumni Magazine)
The gift shop
The The Nines sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Nines pieces





