Dunbar's
Dave Pepin's Eddy Street dive served Cornell students for 36 years under marker-scrawled ceiling tiles and twice hosted the Stanley Cup before closing in 2015.
- Where
- 409 Eddy Street, Collegetown, Ithaca, New York
- Open
- 1979–2015
- Known for
- Marker-covered walls and Group Therapy Wednesdays
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

A Collegetown dive on Eddy Street from 1979
Dunbar's opened in 1979 at 409 Eddy Street in Collegetown, the student neighbourhood on the south edge of the Cornell campus. By early 2013 Dave Pepin had owned it for 33 and a half years. Pepin had gone to Ithaca College, as had Brian Rettger, who managed the bar in its later years. Rettger called it a divey sports bar, and that was about right.
The walls and ceiling tiles were covered in permanent-marker scribbles left by years of customers, and photographs of Cornell teams hung among them. In 2012 a Cornell Daily Sun columnist called it the dingiest bar in Collegetown, complained about the bathroom door, and admitted to ending up there more than anywhere else. The jukebox had its own fans.
Group Therapy and the Stanley Cup
Dunbar's specials were part of the Collegetown week. In 2012 Thursdays meant $3 Long Island iced teas and Wednesdays meant Group Therapy, which the Sun later described as a six-dollar special.
Pepin was a long-time supporter of Cornell wrestling and hockey, and the bar's best story came from that connection. Cornell alumni brought the Stanley Cup into Dunbar's, twice by Pepin's count, and customers drank from it. Hundreds of alumni came back through the door on Homecoming and Reunion weekends.
“We had the Stanley Cup in there twice. I don't think any other bar could say that.”
Why Dunbar's closed
In January 2013 Pepin put the bar up for sale. He wanted more time with his family and said he had seen enough, though he hoped a buyer would keep the graffiti and the team photos. By then the Royal Palm Tavern, Dino's and Johnny O's had already closed, and Pepin called Dunbar's the only hangout bar left in Collegetown. Three people had shown interest, but no sale was reported.
Pepin closed Dunbar's for good over the 2015 winter break, after 36 years. Rettger told the Sun he could not give a reason and that the timing was unfortunate. The Sun later counted it among the Collegetown places lost that decade, alongside Johnny O's and The Palms.
Hideaway at 409 Eddy Street
A new bar, Hideaway, opened in the Dunbar's building in 2016, ahead of the fall semester. Its sign spelled the name in Greek letters, which students read as a pitch to Cornell's fraternities and sororities.
Sources
- Dunbar's closes doors after 36 years in Collegetown, The Cornell Daily Sun
- After 33 years in Collegetown, owner plans to sell Dunbar's, The Cornell Daily Sun
- The State of the Bars 2012, The Cornell Daily Sun
- New bar Hideaway to replace Dunbar's in Collegetown, The Cornell Daily Sun
- A foodie farewell to the top 10 Collegetown establishments that have closed in the past decade, The Cornell Daily Sun
The gift shop
The Dunbar's sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Dunbar's pieces







