The Haunt
Ithaca's biggest live-music club drew Phish, Guided by Voices and a generation of touring bands to Willow Avenue before City Harbor tore it down in 2021.
- Where
- 702 Willow Avenue, West End, Ithaca, New York
- Open
- Closed 2021
- Known for
- Ithaca's largest live-music nightclub, by the Cayuga Inlet
- Reading time
- 3 minutes

Opening years and the move to Willow Avenue
The Haunt's start date depends on who is counting. NYS Music put its opening at 1960, at an earlier site on Green Street, while The Cornell Daily Sun gave 1969. A 2012 Ithaca Times profile, summarised in a Cornell planning study, described the club as marking four decades in business, and named J. Harman as the owner of the business at the time.
The club moved to 702 Willow Avenue in Ithaca's West End in 1997, according to that Cornell study. The new building sat on the lake side of the railroad tracks and Route 13, near the Cayuga Inlet and the mouth of Cascadilla Creek. A 2018 Ithaca Week piece described it as a medium-sized building out past the tracks and across the highway, with a full parking lot and a line at the door on show nights.

Phish at The Haunt, 1988 to 1990
The club's best-documented run belongs to Phish. The band first played The Haunt in May 1988, a three-night stand, and kept coming back until late 1990, at least eight shows in all by NYS Music's account. The promoter Dan Smalls later told NYS Music the band was booked at least once a semester in those years, and that a room with only a handful of people at the early shows was packed by 1990.
The January 29, 1990 show, recorded from a microphone set on the bar, has become a fan favourite: a blizzard and bad roads held the band up, and the crowd was 18 and over. After 1990 Phish moved on to the State Theatre of Ithaca in 1991 and to Cornell's Bailey Hall in November 1992.
“Our goal is to be the premier live entertainment venue in Central New York.”
Dan Smalls and the touring bands
Dan Smalls, a 1992 Cornell graduate, went from booking fraternity parties to booking The Haunt, according to Syracuse New Times, and built the business that became DSP Shows. By 2020 his company, Dan Smalls Presents, ran all the productions at the club, which billed itself as Ithaca's largest nightclub with live music.
The bookings ran from indie rock to underground hip-hop. The English band Gomez played to more than 500 people on April 1, 2009; Sammus played in February 2015; Xenia Rubinos in December 2017; and Guided by Voices in February 2018. Ithaca Week's reporter saw Milo, Elucid and JPEGMAFIA on one bill in 2018. Smalls said DSP did not tailor its bookings to Cornell and Ithaca College students or to the town, and that treating artists well was what persuaded them to choose Ithaca over other stops.
On ordinary nights the place worked as a bar and grill. A 2008 Ithaca LocalWiki entry listed Wednesday karaoke, half-price wings on Tuesdays and drinks at three to five dollars.

City Harbor and the demolition of The Haunt
The owners sold the Willow Avenue property in 2019. In February 2020 The Cornell Daily Sun reported that the site would become part of City Harbor, a waterfront project from four developers including Lambrou Real Estate, with 156 apartments, parks, a renovated marina and a promenade. Smalls said the club would carry on as usual for about 18 months and expected to be in a new downtown home by September 2021.
With live music halted by the pandemic, the building was demolished in February 2021, along with a body shop and four metal storage buildings on the site. NYS Music reported that the old Masonic Temple on North Cayuga Street had been floated as a new location, but Smalls said that offer was not yet on the table.
The Cornell study of the City Harbor project reports that the club was torn down to make room for the parking lot of the Guthrie medical office building, which has since been completed on the old waterfront parcel.
Sources
- The Haunt to relocate as waterfront development readies for ground breaking, The Cornell Daily Sun
- The Haunt in Ithaca is Demolished, but New Location Coming Soon, NYS Music
- City Harbor Project, Ithaca, New York, Just Places Lab, Cornell University College of Architecture, Art, and Planning
- Flashback: Phish performs at The Haunt in Ithaca, January 29, 1990, NYS Music
- A Positively Haunt-ing Experience, Ithaca Week
- Dan Smalls' Big Bookings, Syracuse New Times
- The Haunt Bar & Grill, Ithaca LocalWiki
The gift shop
The The Haunt sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Haunt pieces









