Skip to content
The Bar Museum

Rulloff's

The College Avenue bar named after a hanged 19th-century murderer, where Cornell students went for brunch, burgers and 21st birthdays from 1977 to 2020.

Where
411 College Avenue, Chacona Block, Collegetown, Ithaca, New York
Open
1977–2020
Known for
Collegetown saloon named after a hanged murderer
Reading time
2 minutes
The Rulloff's sign, redrawn
The Rulloff's sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

A saloon named after Edward Rulloff

Rulloff's opened in 1977 at 411 College Avenue, in the Chacona Block in Collegetown, with apartments on the floors above. Its name came from Edward Rulloff, the Ithaca-area murderer who in 1871 became the last man publicly hanged in New York State. His brain is held in Cornell's Wilder Brain Collection. The decor leaned into the story with artefacts recalling its namesake, and later regulars described the look as rustic and antique.

The building was owned by Student Agencies, Inc., the student-run corporation that owns 409 to 415 College Avenue. One former employee, who worked there when it opened, later recalled that one of the original owners was dating the singer Bonnie Raitt.

Date nights, brunch and 21st birthdays

Rulloff's was both a restaurant and a bar, with a bar upstairs and another downstairs. It served lunch burgers, weekend brunch, often with visiting parents, and late-night drinks. Matt Van Ryn, class of 1982, remembered it as his date restaurant and praised the quiche and French onion soup. Another alumna met her husband at a Monday karaoke night there in 2008, and said the couple had nearly given their son the middle name Rulloff.

For Cornell seniors it was where 21st birthdays were celebrated. When the bar shut without warning in 2014, a Sun columnist recorded one junior asking where those birthdays would happen now.

“Rulloff's was my date restaurant.”

The sudden closing of 2014

On Labor Day, September 1, 2014, staff arrived for what most of them thought was a routine start-of-semester meeting and were told the restaurant was closing that day. The Ithaca Voice reported that the owner had not renewed the lease by its August 31 deadline, and the business was listed for sale through Pyramid Brokerage at $395,000, including the furnished kitchen, the bar and a full liquor licence. The listing claimed consistently strong annual sales.

Rulloff's did come back. By 2019 it was owned by Gregar Brous, whose family also ran Collegetown Bagels and the Ithaca Bakery, and was trading again on the same corner. The sources found for this article do not say exactly when it reopened.

Demolition plans and the last closing in 2020

In June 2019 Student Agencies told Brous, a year ahead as his lease required, that it planned to knock down the Chacona Block. Its proposal was a six-storey building with shops on the ground floor and 56 apartments, with demolition to start on June 1, 2020. Student Agencies' chief executive Kyle Karnes told the Sun there were no guarantees about who would occupy the corner afterwards, and Brous said he would like to keep a presence there but that part of the decision would be financial. In January 2020 the Sun reported that the family had not decided Rulloff's future.

The pandemic settled it. After New York restricted restaurants and bars to takeout on March 16, 2020, a sign went up on the door saying Rulloff's was closed until further notice because of the coronavirus. A Sun reviewer, praising the Ghost of Rulloff's burger and the tater tots, wrote in April that staff did not know whether it would open elsewhere. It did not reopen, and the Sun later counted its run at 43 years. Collegetown Bagels moved across the street in June 2020, and Ithaca Beer Co. opened in its old space in the Student Agencies building in 2022.

Sources

  1. Sudden Closure of Rulloff's Bar Shocks Workers, Cornellians, The Cornell Daily Sun, September 2, 2014
  2. Rulloff's Restaurant and Bar Listed for Sale, The Cornell Daily Sun, September 1, 2014
  3. Berry Patch: Rulloff's Is Closed, What Now?, The Cornell Daily Sun, September 2014
  4. Are Collegetown Bagels and Rulloff's on the Chopping Block?, The Cornell Daily Sun, August 2019
  5. Collegetown Bagels to Reopen Across the Street After June Demolition, The Cornell Daily Sun, January 2020
  6. Rulloff's: A Premature Goodbye, The Cornell Daily Sun, April 2020
  7. IP-Yay: Ithaca Beer Co. Opens New Collegetown Location, The Cornell Daily Sun, February 2022
  8. Collegetown eateries: a celebration, Cornellians (Cornell Alumni Association)

The gift shop

The Rulloff's sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Rulloff's pieces