The Chapter House
The Chappie, the Stewart Avenue pub in Collegetown that Cornell grad students knew for its beer list, ceiling mugs and popcorn, until an April 2015 fire.
- Where
- 400 Stewart Avenue at Osmun Place, Collegetown, Ithaca, New York
- Open
- 1965–2015
- Known for
- Cornell grad students' pub with mugs hanging from the ceiling
- Reading time
- 3 minutes

From Jim's Place to the Chapter House
The Chapter House occupied the ground floor of 400-404 Stewart Avenue, a three-storey brick building with a mansard roof at the corner of Osmun Place in Collegetown, near the Cornell campus. The building went up around 1898 to serve the growing university, with shops for a tailor, a tobacconist, a pool hall and a confectioner. It stands inside the city's East Hill Historic District.
The bar grew out of Jim's Place, which Cornell Alumni Magazine says opened in the mid-1920s serving 50-cent dinners and began selling alcohol about ten years later. Through the 1950s and 1960s it was a fraternity hangout. By 1965 it had been renamed the Chapter House, and in 1968 the Cornell Daily Sun listed it among the traditional spots for freshman drinking. Carl Anderson, class of 1968, told Cornellians he spent part of most evenings there as a freshman in 1964 and 1965. According to Cornellians, it ran briefly as an ice cream parlour in the 1980s before returning as a bar.
The Chappie: beer, popcorn and initials in the tables
Over the following decades the Chappie, as regulars called it, settled into being a graduate students' bar, though undergraduates and townspeople came too. Its reputation rested on beer, and in later years it offered 49 beers on tap. An Ithaca community wiki described it as having the best selection of beers on tap in town, with pints from $3.50 to $5.50, a happy hour, free self-serve popcorn and mixed drinks that were an afterthought. The Sun later noted that the pub brewed a beer of its own, Clement's, which earned a listing in the guidebook Beer Lover's New York.
The room itself was part of the draw. Patrons came through old wooden doors into a pub where beer mugs hung from the ceiling and the wooden tables were carved with generations of initials. A Cornell Alumni Magazine writer who drank there remembered reggae on the sound system, arguments about Nietzsche, and live music and dancing, and called it the one Collegetown bar where you might leave smarter than you came in. The owner in its last years was John Hoey.
“Even to old alumni, it seems as if the Chapter House was always there.”
The fire of April 14, 2015
At 4.30 in the morning on Tuesday, April 14, 2015, a 911 call reported fire on the 400 block of Stewart Avenue. Crews found the Chapter House and the four-storey apartment building next door at 406 Stewart both burning. Assistant Fire Chief Mike Schnurle pulled firefighters out of the buildings because of the heavy fire and structural instability, and both were declared total losses. No one was hurt, but 44 Cornell students and two staff members lost their homes. Stewart Avenue was closed until the afternoon, and state and city investigators looked into the cause.
Within days David Garlough, a Cornell graduate who had tended bar at the Chapter House about 15 years earlier, started an online fund to help rebuild it, and more than $5,500 was pledged in the first few days. The alumni magazine Cornellians later reported corn sprouting on the empty lot from the bar's spilled popcorn kernels.
Rebuilding 400 Stewart Avenue without the pub
Plans to save parts of the old building were dropped after engineers found that months of exposure to the weather had left the walls saturated and the floors buckling. In the autumn of 2015 the architects Jason Demarest and Andy Sprague presented the Ithaca Landmarks Preservation Commission with a replacement modelled on a photograph of the building from about 1909, keeping brick and stone, storefront windows and a mansard roof. The management company said it hoped to reopen the pub by August 2016.
That did not happen. The lot was sold to James Goldman, owner of 406 Stewart, and the new building was finished around 2018 with apartments above about 3,000 square feet of ground-floor commercial space marketed as ideal for a restaurant or bar. In 2017 Hoey wrote online that the Chapter House planned to return, ideally to its old address and otherwise to another Collegetown pub, but no reopening followed. In December 2019 the Sun reported that the retail space was still empty, and a later Cornell study of the building found no plans to revive the Chapter House name.
Sources
- Cornelliana: The Chapter House, Cornell Alumni Magazine, July/August 2015
- Ithaca fire displaces students, destroys Chapter House pub, Cornell Chronicle, April 14, 2015
- 400 Stewart, Just Places Lab, Cornell College of Architecture, Art and Planning
- Design for New, Rebuilt Chapter House Unveiled, The Cornell Daily Sun, October 2015
- Fund started to rebuild popular Ithaca pub, WXXI News, April 2015
- Chapter House / 406 Stewart Avenue Construction Update, 8/2017, Ithacating in Cornell Heights
- A Foodie Farewell to the Top 10 Collegetown Establishments That Have Closed in the Past Decade, The Cornell Daily Sun, December 2019
- Collegetown eateries: a celebration, Cornellians (Cornell Alumni Association)
- The Chapter House, Ithaca LocalWiki
The gift shop
The The Chapter House sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Chapter House pieces





