Skip to content
The Bar Museum

Royal Palm Tavern

The Leonardo family's beer-and-a-shot bar at 209 Dryden Road, where Cornell students painted the ceiling tiles for decades before it closed in February 2012.

Where
209 Dryden Road, Collegetown, Ithaca, New York
Open
1941–2012
Known for
Collegetown dive with painted ceiling tiles
Reading time
2 minutes
The Royal Palm Tavern sign, redrawn
The Royal Palm Tavern sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

A Leonardo family bar on Dryden Road from 1941

The Royal Palm Tavern, always called the Palms, sat at 209 Dryden Road in Collegetown, the student neighbourhood next to Cornell University. The Cornell Daily Sun dated it to 1941, though a local blog noted that other accounts put the opening anywhere from the late 1930s to 1944, and Cornell's alumni magazine wrote in 2011 that it had been serving students since the Thirties. The building itself dated from around the early 1920s.

It stayed in one family for its whole life. The Sun reported in January 2012 that Joe Leonardo's father and uncle opened it; a later Sun story credited the uncle with founding it and said the father ran it from the 1950s into the 1980s. In the early 1980s the brothers Joe and Lenny Leonardo took over.

Dryden Road in Collegetown at sunset with the Royal Palm Tavern sign, a palm tree logo, hanging over the street beside Johnny's Big Red Grill
Looking up Dryden Road from College Avenue in September 1985, with the Royal Palm Tavern's sign on the right.Photo: Upsilon Andromedae, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Painted ceiling tiles and Palms o'clock

The Palms never tried to be anything but a dive. Lenny Leonardo described it to the Sun as a beer-and-a-shot place where nobody would be served a daiquiri or a frozen margarita, and a 1978 Sun review called it the most run-down place around. An alumnus from the class of 1957 remembered mainly how dark it was inside.

Its best-known feature was overhead. From the early 1990s customers painted the ceiling tiles, and blank tiles became so sought after that they were rationed, usually to regulars. Ithaca's mayor Svante Myrick worked the door for two years while he was a Cornell student. Generations of alumni made it their first stop when they came back to town.

“Every time you come back, you go to the Palms. But where do we go now?”

Why the Palms closed in 2012

In December 2010 the Leonardos sold the Palms and two neighbouring Dryden Road properties to the Collegetown developer John Novarr for $3.75 million, more than three times their assessed value of about $800,000. In January 2012 Joe Leonardo announced that the bar would close at the end of February. He blamed students' changing habits: they spent far less time in Collegetown bars than a decade earlier, used text messages to arrange where to meet, and turned up only in the last rush before closing, which he called Palms o'clock. When the 2011 homecoming game moved to an evening kickoff, he said, the bar did about a tenth of the previous year's business that weekend. The Palms was the third Collegetown bar to close in less than a year, after Dino's and Johnny O's.

Alumni groups organised trips back to Ithaca for the last weeks, and on the final Saturday two former employees, Justine Haimi and Cullen Mealey, got engaged at the bar. Lenny Leonardo said he hoped to keep the painted ceiling tiles together and show them somewhere once the building was gone. The Palms served its last drinks in the early hours of Thursday, March 1, 2012, after 71 years, and the brothers planned to move to Florida.

What's there now

The building that held the Palms was one of several on the block torn down in 2017 to make room for Cornell's Breazzano Family Center for Business Education.

Sources

  1. The last call: Royal Palm closes after 71 years, The Cornell Daily Sun
  2. The Palms, a Collegetown fixture since 1941, will close next month, The Cornell Daily Sun
  3. Where have all the drinkers gone?, Ithacating in Cornell Heights
  4. A celebration of Collegetown eateries, Cornellians (Cornell Alumni Association)

The gift shop

The Royal Palm Tavern sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Royal Palm Tavern pieces