Castaways
Castaways put touring bands and Ithaca acts on a waterfront stage on Inlet Island until the lease ran out and the club played its last show in April 2012.
- Where
- 413 Taughannock Boulevard (Old Taughannock Boulevard), Inlet Island, West End, Ithaca, New York
- Open
- Closed 2012
- Known for
- Waterfront live-music club with a deck and boat docking on the Cayuga Inlet
- Reading time
- 4 minutes

A waterfront bar at 413 Taughannock Boulevard
Castaways stood on Inlet Island in Ithaca's West End, one block off Route 89 on the stub of road the club's own directions called Old Taughannock Boulevard. Its website told drivers from Cornell and Ithaca College to follow Buffalo Street across Route 13, turn right, and look for the club immediately on the right, just before the BoatYard Grill.
The site has been a music room for a long time. The Ithacan has reported that a bar called the Salty Dog started there in 1971, and that the place went through a series of ownership and name changes afterward. No source found for this article gives the year the Castaways name went up. The club's website carried a copyright line beginning in 1998, and in 2011 its banner read "waking up the west end for 30 years". Buzzsaw, the Ithaca College magazine, also wrote of a 30 year run when the club closed.
The deck, the docking and the room
By day Castaways sold itself as a place to eat and drink by the water. In 2001 its website advertised a private waterfront deck, 80 feet of free docking for customers arriving by boat, more than 75 bottled beers, a happy hour from 4 to 7 every day of the week, and a short menu on which nothing cost more than $6. A later community listing added pool tables, a big screen television and a Monday wing night with twelve flavors.
After dark it was a club. A 2005 venue guide put the capacity at 300. A Cornell Daily Sun reviewer in November 2002 called it a tiny bar and concert venue, and described a night when the staff set candlelit tables near the stage for the Asylum Street Spankers, who played two unamplified sets to more than 200 people.
“Most of us have been here a long time and the community loves us, the musicians, so we definitely want to reopen.”
Reggae nights and the bands that played Castaways
In 2001 the club ran live music Thursday through Saturday and filled the other nights with themes: reggae, classic rock and Latin dance. The reggae night lasted. The 2005 guide said the Tuesday series had a strong following and that Castaways had taken over from the Haunt as the area's main room for ska and reggae, with the Pietasters, the Toasters, Westbound Train and Dub Is A Weapon among its bookings. TJ Schaper, a local musician who later took over the building, told The Ithacan that his band played the weekly reggae nights and that he had been on that stage probably more than 100 times.
Touring acts came through steadily. Buzzsaw listed St. Vincent, Sufjan Stevens and Dar Williams among those who had played the room. A Cornell Daily Sun columnist remembered seeing Exit Clov there on a visit as a high school student, then the Meat Puppets and Titus Andronicus once he had enrolled, and wrote that Castaways was the best concert venue in town. One week of the calendar in February 2011 had Tribal Seeds on Wednesday, Alana Amram and the Rough Gems with Jennie Stearns on Friday, Giant Panda Guerilla Dub Squad on Saturday and a Bob Marley birthday tribute on Sunday, with can nights in between.
The room was also lent out for causes. In their farewell message the operators pointed to the money raised there for the Finger Lakes Cancer Resource Center, benefits held for local families, and Chamber of Commerce fundraisers for the Waterfront Trail.
Why Castaways closed in April 2012
In late March 2012 the club announced on Facebook that it was leaving the island. The message, reprinted by BrooklynVegan, said that after six years of battling and two years of negotiation the landlords were not renewing the lease. The Ithacan reported the same week that the bar had been open for seven years, a figure that appears to count the time under the operators of the day.
The operators wrote that every month of rent had been paid. Their complaint was the building: rotting pipes, a leaking roof, repairs that did not hold and mold in the ceiling, at what they said was the second highest rent in the West End. With new zoning for the West End on the way, they wrote, a long investment in an old and unmaintained building did not make sense.
The day manager, Elaina Rogers, told The Ithacan the staff were in shock and that the owners hoped to reopen somewhere else, though nothing was set. The first announcement gave May 1 as the closing date. April stayed busy, with Rasputina on April 5, and Buzzsaw reported that the finale on April 29 would be the Sim Redmond Band and John Brown's Body, two Ithaca groups. No new location had been announced by then.
What is at the Castaways site now: The Dock, then Deep Dive
The building did not stay dark for good. A new bar and music venue, The Dock, opened there on February 24 after about six months of work, according to an Ithacan report dated April 2014. The renovation brought a new PA system, new plumbing, a new ceiling, glass doors and a window from the bar onto the deck. The local band M-Eleven played opening night.
The Dock gave way to Deep Dive, which had its ribbon cutting on September 13, 2022, at what is now numbered 415 Old Taughannock Boulevard. It is run by Schaper, the musician from the Castaways reggae nights, and admits ages 18 and up.
Sources
- Castaways to close in May, The Ithacan
- Castaways Closes Its Doors, Buzzsaw Magazine
- Ithaca music venue Castaways closing, BrooklynVegan
- Looking Back on Castaways, The Cornell Daily Sun
- Crazy for You, The Cornell Daily Sun
- Refurbished concert venue replaces Castaways bar, The Ithacan
- Deep Dive offers intergenerational vibes for all, The Ithacan
- Ribbon Cutting for Deep Dive, Tompkins Chamber
- Castaways: About Us (archived June 2001), castawaysithaca.com via the Wayback Machine
- Directions to Castaways (archived December 2001), castawaysithaca.com via the Wayback Machine
- Castaways music schedule (archived February 2011), castawaysithaca.com via the Wayback Machine
- Venues: Castaways, Syracuse Ska
- Castaways, Ithaca LocalWiki
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Castaways.
Share a memory of Castaways
The gift shop
The Castaways sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Castaways pieces


