Skip to content
The Bar Museum

Wonder Bar

Noah Eisendrath's Wonder Bar took over the old Bunratty's room at 186 Harvard Avenue in 2005, moved from jazz to DJ nights, and closed for good in 2020.

Where
186 Harvard Avenue, Allston, Boston, Massachusetts
Open
2005–2020
Known for
Allston bar that went from jazz combos to DJ nights
Reading time
2 minutes
The Wonder Bar sign, redrawn
The Wonder Bar sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

186 Harvard Avenue before the Wonder Bar

The brick building at 186 Harvard Avenue in Allston went up in 1920 as a vaudeville house, later showed films, and only then became a bar, according to a 2017 history of the room by A.J. Wachtel on the Boston music site mmone.org. Its best-known tenant was Bunratty's, which Dennis Mullins opened in September 1969. Through the 1970s and 1980s Bunratty's put two to four bands on its stage every night of the week, and its managers Mickey O'Halloran and Dave Gee also published The Beat, a fanzine on the Boston scene.

Mullins sold the club in 1988 to Lorraine Curtis. In the early 1990s George and Doug Mellen ran it as the Melody Lounge, and in 1993 Patrick Lyons of the Lyons Group bought it and renamed it Local 186, after the street number.

Noah Eisendrath opens the Wonder Bar in 2005

Noah Eisendrath took over the room on September 9, 2005 and gave it a new name, the Wonder Bar. The early Wonder Bar aimed higher than the rock club before it: Time Out Boston described votive candles, slowly turning ceiling fans and jazz with a short dinner menu on Friday and Saturday nights, and Gayot noted a modern room with exposed brick and jazz combos playing nightly.

The jazz did not hold the crowd. The bar stood near Boston University and Boston College, and Time Out described the change of shift: once a DJ took over after 10 p.m., the college crowd arrived and the beer started flowing. Gayot's reviewer remarked that the earnest combos rarely had an audience that was listening.

Eisendrath eventually stopped booking bands altogether. According to Wachtel, he switched to DJs because of the digital age, a changing neighbourhood, rising costs and stricter alcohol laws.

“As everyone probably knows, Wonder Bar will not re-open due to the coronavirus and the resulting government shutdown.”

DJ nights, Ceremony and a kitchen upgrade

In its later years the Wonder Bar ran on DJs and dance nights. Vanyaland listed underground electronic music, hip-hop, beats, drum and bass, techno and EDM nights, DJ battles and comedy, and a long-running weekly goth and industrial night called Ceremony.

In June 2015 the bar shut for about a week while the space was largely gutted and refitted. The work brought in a kitchen for DooWee and Rice, the Asian food of chef Duy Tran, whose restaurant had been in Somerville until 2013. Gayot's later listing described a menu of rice bowls, udon and bao, and singled out a platter of warm chocolate chip cookies.

Why the Wonder Bar closed in 2020

Boston Restaurant Talk reported in the autumn of 2020 that it had closed for good, and on November 23, 2020 Eisendrath confirmed it in a Facebook post, blaming the coronavirus and the shutdown that followed, and asking regulars to remember the good nights rather than the ending. He had run the bar for 15 years.

The space did not stay empty long. In July 2022 HAN, an Asian bistro and lounge with DJs and dancing, opened at 186 Harvard Avenue in the former Wonder Bar room.

Sources

  1. Wonder Bar in Allston will not re-open after the pandemic, Vanyaland
  2. Bunratty's/Melody Lounge/Local 186/The Wonder Bar, mmone.org
  3. Wonder Bar (closed), Time Out Boston
  4. Wonder Bar, Gayot
  5. Wonder Bar in Allston temporarily closed, Boston Restaurant Talk
  6. HAN opens in Allston, moving into old Wonder Bar space, Boston Restaurant Talk

The gift shop

The Wonder Bar sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Wonder Bar pieces