Skip to content
The Bar Museum

The Dugout Cafe

Jimmy O'Keefe's basement bar at 722 Commonwealth Avenue served ballplayers, Brink's robbers and BU hockey teams from 1934 until it closed in January 2026.

Where
722 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston University campus, Boston
Open
1934–2026
Known for
BU's basement dive and the hockey team's post-game bar
Reading time
2 minutes
The The Dugout Cafe sign, redrawn
The The Dugout Cafe sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original
Black-and-white night photo of a Dugout Cafe sign and a sidewalk menu board beside a railing on Commonwealth Avenue
The Dugout Cafe sign on Commonwealth Avenue at night, April 2012.Photo: Arnab Majumdar, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Jimmy O'Keefe opens the Dugout in 1934

The Dugout sat a few steps below street level at 722 Commonwealth Avenue. Legend says it was a speakeasy during Prohibition; what is on record is that its liquor licence was one of the first Boston issued after repeal in December 1933, and it opened officially in 1934. It stood roughly halfway between Fenway Park and Braves Field, and it filled with baseball fans, sportswriters, gamblers and Red Sox and Braves players.

Its owner for decades was Jimmy O'Keefe, born near Kenmore Square in 1903. He had run a pharmacy that sold "medicinal" liquor during Prohibition, then built up nightclubs in Boston and on Cape Cod, owned racehorses and managed prizefighters. He helped Maurice Tobin win the Boston mayoralty in 1937, and in 1945, when Governor Tobin would not find a job for one of O'Keefe's friends, the two came to blows. O'Keefe won.

Brink's robbers and a dean who wanted it shut

In 1946 William Sutcliffe, dean of BU's College of Business Administration, asked the Licensing Board to revoke the Dugout's permit because it was not conducive to academic work. The board renewed it. Four years later two regulars, Adolph "Jazz" Maffie and Joseph "Specs" O'Keefe, no relation to Jimmy, were among the eleven men who robbed the Brink's depot in the North End of more than $2.7 million. The long-time bartender Frank Kennedy used to point to the corner booth where, he said, the Brink's gang planned the job; Maffie and Specs O'Keefe certainly knew Jimmy O'Keefe, and a postal worker recalled seeing Maffie at the Dugout often.

In 1961 O'Keefe was arrested at his own bar by a vice detective who heard him placing bets by phone. His friends jammed the police switchboard, and within a month he was found not guilty.

“It's a no-bullshit kind of bar.”

BU hockey and the Blizzard of '78

With the drinking age at 18 for much of the 1970s, the Dugout became the bar of BU's championship hockey teams. Players took jobs there as bartenders and bouncers in their junior or senior year, the team gathered there after games, and the jukebox carried "O Canada" for the Canadians on the roster.

During the Blizzard of 1978, after BU beat Boston College in the Beanpot, the team bus crawled back up Commonwealth Avenue. Coach Jack Parker stopped at Marsh Chapel to give thanks, and the players went across the street to the Dugout instead. With cars banned from the roads the next day, O'Keefe reportedly had his beer delivered in a Boston Edison utility truck, and goalie Brian Durocher served it by candlelight. A 1980s regular remembered $1 bottles of Miller High Life, no draught beer and no Budweiser, after a supposed quarrel with the distributor.

The Crowleys and the last years

When O'Keefe died in 1987, Senator John Kerry told the Senate the Dugout had served as a counselling centre for BU students. The bar passed to O'Keefe's long-time employee, the father of Bill Crowley Jr., and then to Crowley Jr. himself. In 2015 it still took no credit cards, had no air conditioning, served free popcorn and kept wood panelling and wobbly stools. A weekly comedy show, The Mendoza Line, ran in the back room for 12 years.

Why the Dugout closed in 2026

The Dugout closed abruptly in early January 2026, while students were away on winter break, with no last night. The public found out on January 8, when the Boston Licensing Board approved the transfer of its all-alcohol licence to the Canadian chain Earls Kitchen + Bar for a new Seaport restaurant at 157 Seaport Boulevard. Earls's lawyer put the price at $550,000.

Sources

  1. The Little Dive with a Long History, Bostonia, Boston University
  2. After 90 Years Serving, the Dugout Says Good Night, Bostonia, Boston University
  3. Historic Dugout Cafe dive bar to sell its liquor license to chain restaurant, Boston.com
  4. Dugout Cafe in Boston Has Closed, Boston Restaurant Talk

The gift shop

The The Dugout Cafe sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Dugout Cafe pieces