Skip to content
The Bar Museum

The Rathskeller

The Rat, the basement club at 528 Commonwealth Avenue in Kenmore Square that housed Boston punk and hosted the Cars, Talking Heads and R.E.M., 1974 to 1997.

Where
528 Commonwealth Avenue, Kenmore Square, Boston
Open
1974–1997
Known for
Basement punk and rock club in Kenmore Square, 'Boston's CBGB'
Reading time
4 minutes
The The Rathskeller sign, redrawn
The The Rathskeller sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

A college bar in Kenmore Square in the 1960s

The Rathskeller stood at 528 Commonwealth Avenue in Kenmore Square, across the street from Boston University. Its official name was always the Rathskeller, the German word for a cellar bar, but almost everyone called it the Rat. A sign in black-letter type reading 'Rathskeller', with 'Food Drinks Music' beneath it, ran across the brick front.

In the 1960s it was a restaurant and bar for college students, operating as TJ's, with live music in a back room. The Remains, four BU students led by Barry Tashian, carried their gear across the street to play there, and in 1965 they drew such crowds that the owner opened the basement for 'Remains Nights'. Tashian later described that basement as a room with a jukebox, picnic tables and a stage made of boards laid on crates. Other local bands, including the Lost with Willie 'Loco' Alexander and the Mods, played the room before live music was phased out in the late 1960s.

Snowy sidewalk in front of a brick building with a black-letter 'Rathskeller' sign above a 'Food Drinks Music' banner; a woman stands by the door at number 528.
Musician Linda S. Viens outside the Rathskeller at 528 Commonwealth Avenue, Kenmore Square, in February 1984.Photo: Wayne Valdez, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Jim Harold and the punk years

Jim Harold, a former offensive lineman at UMass Amherst, had started out working the door at the Kenmore Club and then at TJ's, where he ran the downstairs room. He took over the business from TJ's owner and reopened the basement to bands. The Music Museum of New England dates his ownership from 1974; WBUR gave 1973. When he started, the bookings were mostly cover bands. Asked years later why he had taken it on, he said it was to make money.

Within a couple of years the Rat was the centre of Boston's new punk and new wave scene. DMZ, Third Rail, the Atlantics, the Nervous Eaters, Unnatural Axe, the Real Kids, the Neighborhoods and Willie Alexander and the Boom Boom Band all used it as a home base. Harold put the scene on record with Live at the Rat, a double album on his own Rat Records label. The press took to calling the club Boston's CBGB, and Chris Frantz of Talking Heads called it a dive that was proud of it.

“The Rat was really the punk-rock Camelot -- it fell from grace, but you kept hoping for a resurrection.”

Black-and-white photo of a band on a low stage in a basement club, a drummer in the foreground and a bassist with short blond hair, a crowd pressing in under exposed pipes.
The Young Snakes, with Aimee Mann on bass, playing the Rat's basement in 1981.Photo: David Henry, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The bands that played the Rat

The list of acts that played the basement before they were famous runs long: the Cars, the Police, Talking Heads, the Ramones, R.E.M., the Pixies, Metallica, the Dead Kennedys, Dinosaur Jr. and the Replacements among them. English bands such as the Jam, the Damned, the Stranglers, the Fall and Gang of Four used it as a staging ground on their American tours. In March 1984 Hüsker Dü opened for R.E.M. there. Later Boston bands that came up through the room included 'Til Tuesday, the Del Fuegos, the Mighty Mighty Bosstones, Gang Green and the Dropkick Murphys, whose Ken Casey said the band started touring from the Rat.

Cars guitarist Elliot Easton credited Harold with giving the band the chance to prove itself. The house soundman was Granny Weidman, and a doorman known as Mitch kept the door at the top of the stairs to the basement showroom. Bookers over the years included Alan Rotberg in the early days and Kathei Logue in the 1980s.

Black-and-white photo of a singer in a T-shirt and leather trousers holding a microphone, one arm raised to the low ceiling of stage lights.
Jim Thirlwell of Foetus on stage at the Rathskeller on August 20, 1985.Photo: Davidphenry, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Hoodoo Barbecue and the Rock 'n' Roll Rumble

Upstairs, at street level, was a bar and restaurant. From 1980 to 1987 the chef James Ryan ran the Hoodoo Barbecue there, feeding musicians for free, and Esquire named it one of the hundred best restaurants in America. The radio station WBCN held its annual battle of the bands, the Rock 'n' Roll Rumble, at the Rat for its first three years, starting in 1979, when it was billed as the Rumble at the Rat.

Two red matchbooks printed 'The Rat' with a cartoon rat draped over the R, beside a matchbook from the Model Cafe.
Matchbooks from the Rat, with one from the Model Cafe in Allston.Photo: Ethan Long, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Why the Rat closed in 1997

By the mid-1990s the club was fading. Writing in the Boston Phoenix after it closed, Brett Milano listed the reasons people gave: bookers leaving, Harold running the club without a full-time booker, a drift toward suburban metal bands, the decline of the upstairs food after Hoodoo, the death of the doorman Mitch, and a Kenmore Square that was becoming more expensive. BU Today added that a subway flood in October 1996 left the building smelling foul for a year. Head bartender Brian Stoker tried to buy the club in early 1997 and was turned down.

The last night was Saturday, November 15, 1997. Gang Green played the final set, and their song 'Alcohol' was the last one heard in the room. Dennis McCarthy, formerly the Prime Movers' drummer, remembered Harold at the back, smiling and telling everyone to clear out as he always did.

Hotel Commonwealth on the site

Boston University and the developer Terence Guiney bought the buildings on the south side of Kenmore Square, and Guiney said the Rat was for sale the first time they approached its owner. Sources differ on when the block came down: the Music Museum of New England says October 2000, BU Today says demolition began in November 2001. The Hotel Commonwealth opened on the site in January 2003, and it later set aside a Rathskeller Suite decorated with memorabilia from the club. Jim Harold died on July 31, 2022, at the age of 79.

Sources

  1. The Rathskeller, Wikipedia
  2. Remembering punk rock club The Rathskeller and owner Jim Harold, WBUR (Jim Sullivan), August 2022
  3. Paradise Lost: Remembering the Rat, The Boston Phoenix (Brett Milano), November 1997
  4. The Rat, Music Museum of New England
  5. Jimmy Harold, Music Museum of New England
  6. Tracing the Changing Face of Kenmore Square, BU Today, 2013
  7. The Rat Remembered: 8 True (and Terrifying) Stories from Boston's Legendary Rock Club, Rockerzine, 2016

The gift shop

The The Rathskeller sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Rathskeller pieces