Tap & Mallet
Tap & Mallet poured 30 rotating drafts and a cask at 381 Gregory Street in Rochester's South Wedge from 2007 until last call on December 31, 2021.
- Where
- 381 Gregory Street, South Wedge, Rochester, New York
- Open
- 2007–2021
- Known for
- Craft-beer pub with 30 rotating drafts and a cask line
- Reading time
- 3 minutes
Opening on Gregory Street in 2007
Tap & Mallet opened in 2007 at 381 Gregory Street in the South Wedge, in a building that dated to 1890. From 1989 to 2006 the same building had housed the original MacGregor's Grill & Tap Room, so the new bar moved into a room that Rochester already knew as a place to drink beer.
It was owned by Joe McBane and Casey Walpert. McBane grew up in Sheffield, England, and moved to the United States in 2000 to work at The Old Toad on Alexander Street, which he managed for his first seven years in the country. Walpert had opened The Bug Jar on Monroe Avenue and went on to own Lanai on Alexander Street and Skylark on South Union Street.
When the pub opened, local brewing was thin. CITY Magazine counted two breweries inside the city, Rohrbach and Genesee, and the Democrat and Chronicle put the number for all of Monroe County at three. By the time Tap & Mallet closed, the city alone had twelve.
Thirty drafts and a cask ale
The owners deliberately capped the draft list at 30 lines plus one cask ale, on the reasoning that fewer taps meant every keg would be poured fresh. Most of the lines rotated, so regulars could come back a week later and find a different board. The list mixed Rochester brewers such as Three Heads, Young Lion and Fifth Frame with hard-to-find imports like Cantillon from Belgium and JW Lees Harvest Ale from England, alongside American names such as Other Half and Suarez Family Brewery.
Inside, the room was dim, with hardwood floors and furniture and a J-shaped bar. Stuffed raccoons and jackalopes looked down on the drinkers. The owners described it as a contemporary pub with soft lighting and music kept low, and said nobody should feel judged for what they ordered.
The kitchen counted as much as the taps. The menu borrowed flavours from around the world at pub prices, and the Democrat and Chronicle ranked the food among the best in the region, singling out the cauliflower wings.
“It's a bit like reading comments on your own obituary. It's bittersweet.”
First kegs, crowlers and Rochester Real Beer Week
Many Rochester breweries sent their first kegs to Tap & Mallet, and the pub brought outside breweries to the city for the first time, among them Prison City, Other Half and Suarez. CITY Magazine credited it with helping introduce New England IPAs to Rochester, backing the homebrewing scene and giving future brewery owners a place to talk shop. It was also the first bar in the region to sell crowlers, 32-ounce cans filled from the tap.
McBane co-founded Rochester Real Beer Week and curated its Rochester Real Beer Expo, which was cancelled in 2020 because of the pandemic. The pub ran weekly meetups for beer drinkers and special releases through the year, an annual Sour Fest, and an Oktoberfest that put up a white tent outside with accordion music and German styles such as Marzen and schwarzbier. McBane told CITY that during one Oktoberfest he was the most German Englishman in Rochester.
The partners tried a second place, Tap and Table at Corn Hill Landing, in 2012. It became the Rochester Taproom in 2014 and closed soon after. In September 2020 they opened The Sheffield at Twelve Corners in Brighton.
Why Tap & Mallet closed
The owners announced at the end of November 2021, in a Facebook post, that it was time to call last orders. They wrote that the pub had already been feeling changes in the craft beer business before the pandemic arrived. McBane told the Democrat and Chronicle that the crowd had shifted from drinkers to diners, and that brewery taprooms, which had multiplied after changes in state law, had taken away much of what made a specialist beer bar worth the trip. Paul Leone of the New York Brewers Association made the same point to CITY: a bar that had once been unique no longer stood out.
McBane said he held no grudge about it and that it was time to turn the page. Last call was on December 31, 2021, after about 14 years. At the time the owners had not decided what would become of the building, and McBane turned his attention to The Sheffield on Monroe Avenue.
Sources
- Last call at the Tap and Mallet, CITY Magazine (Rochester)
- Tap & Mallet in Rochester NY to close (Well-known pub in South Wedge to close after 14 years), Democrat and Chronicle, via Yahoo News
- Tap and Mallet co-owner Joe McBane on the pub's closing, WXXI News, Connections
- Tap & Mallet: About (archived), tapandmallet.com via the Wayback Machine
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Tap & Mallet.
Share a memory of Tap & Mallet
The gift shop
The Tap & Mallet sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Tap & Mallet pieces

