Skip to content
The Bar Museum

Neary's

Jimmy Neary opened his Irish pub on East 57th Street on St. Patrick's Day 1967. Mayors, cardinals and novelists ate there for 57 years until July 2024.

Where
358 East 57th Street near First Avenue, Sutton Place, Manhattan, New York
Open
1967–2024
Known for
Upscale Irish pub where politicians, cardinals and writers were regulars
Reading time
2 minutes
The Neary's sign, redrawn
The Neary's sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Jimmy Neary, from Tubbercurry to East 57th Street

James Neary was born in 1930 in Tubbercurry, County Sligo, one of six children, and left school after the sixth grade. In 1954 he sailed to New York, paying his way, Newsweek reported, with the money from selling 14 lambs. He drove a cab, worked at the New York Athletic Club, served in the U.S. Army in Germany, and then learned the restaurant trade working nights for P.J. Moriarty.

He married Eileen, a Dubliner, in 1966. The next year he and a fellow bartender, Brian Mulligan, opened Neary's on East 57th Street near First Avenue, on St. Patrick's Day 1967. In 1986 Neary bought the building, at 358 East 57th Street, for $1,375,000, with a loan arranged through Bill Burke, the New York president of the Bank of Ireland.

Red leather, lamb chops and a jacket for the men

Neary's was an upscale Irish pub rather than a dive. CNBC described a long wooden bar, a dark-wood dining room and red leather banquettes. The kitchen served steaks and seafood alongside Irish-American plates, and the lamb chops with mint jelly and the corned beef and cabbage were the most ordered dishes. Men were expected to wear a jacket.

Neary greeted customers at the door nearly every evening well into his eighties. The family worked the room too. His daughter Una started in the coat check at 12 and kept waiting tables and hosting at weekends even after she became a partner at Goldman Sachs in 2012. Regulars also joined in singing God Bless America.

“They're not customers. They're part of our extended family.”

Brick front of Neary's with a green awning lettered Neary's, dark panelled doors, a gridded window and potted shrubs
Neary's at 358 East 57th Street, ten days after it closed, July 29, 2024.Photo: Transpoman, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Mayors, cardinals and Mary Higgins Clark

Over 57 years the pub's regulars included the mayors Ed Koch and Michael Bloomberg, Governor Hugh Carey, the police commissioners Bill Bratton and Raymond Kelly, Cardinal Timothy Dolan, the astronaut and senator John Glenn, the columnist Jimmy Breslin, the writer Gay Talese, the actress Maureen O'Hara, and George Steinbrenner. Bill Clinton ate there, and so did both Presidents Bush. Bloomberg said he had come back for the boiled chicken for 40 years. Carey, by Neary's account, was partial to the smoked salmon.

The mystery novelist Mary Higgins Clark was a regular and put Neary into 25 of her books. When Elaine's on the Upper East Side closed, some of its regulars moved to Neary's, along with its bartender Kevin Duffy.

Jimmy Neary's death and the last years

Eileen Neary died of cancer years before her husband. Jimmy Neary died in his sleep on October 1, 2021, a few weeks after turning 91. Cardinal Dolan said the funeral Mass at St. Patrick's Cathedral, and the FDR Drive, the Harlem River Drive and the upper level of the George Washington Bridge were closed for the procession. In 2022 the city gave 57th Street the honorary name Jimmy Neary Way.

Una Neary, who had worked alongside her father for 41 years, ran the pub with her siblings after his death.

Why Neary's closed in 2024

In July 2024 the family announced that Neary's would close. Una Neary told Fox 5 it was a bittersweet decision: she, her brother and two sisters owned the building and had chosen to sell it. In the final days some customers waited two or three hours for a table. The last night was July 19, 2024, after 57 years.

The building was sold to Thomas and Anthony Martignetti, who leased the pub's space to the chef Ed Cotton and two partners. According to Wikipedia, citing the New York Post, they planned to open a tavern called the Derby Club in September 2025, keeping Neary's floor plan and the bar by the entrance.

Sources

  1. Neary's, Wikipedia
  2. Iconic East Side Irish Pub Neary's Closing Its Doors After 57 Years, West Side Spirit
  3. Neary's NYC Irish pub closing, Fox 5 New York
  4. Why Goldman's New Partner Waitresses at an Irish Pub, CNBC
  5. NYPD shut down city bridge for his funeral, named street after him, Newsweek

The gift shop

The Neary's sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Neary's pieces