Skip to content

Acme Bar & Pizza

A Monroe Avenue bar in Rochester that sold thin-crust slices and cheap craft beer until 2 a.m. for 26 years, from 1998 until its last night in August 2024.

Where
495 Monroe Avenue, between Goodman and Meigs streets, Rochester, New York
Open
1998–2024
Known for
Late-night slices, Cajun tots and cheap craft beer on Monroe Avenue
Reading time
2 minutes
The Acme Bar & Pizza sign, redrawn
The Acme Bar & Pizza sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

A bar and pizzeria at 495 Monroe Avenue from 1998

Acme Bar & Pizza sat at 495 Monroe Avenue in Rochester, on the block between Goodman and Meigs streets. Its own logo, a navy oval with white serif capitals, carried the line "Est. 1998", and when it closed in 2024 CITY magazine counted 26 years on the avenue.

A Rochester pizza blogger wrote in 2009 that Acme had started out as a sister bar to Richmond's downtown and had changed hands since then. The bar shared the strip with Monroe Avenue's other late-night stops, places such as Mark's Texas Hots, Gitsis and JD Oxford's that CITY listed beside it as a rite of passage for Gen X and millennial Rochester.

Thin-crust slices, tots and a long beer list

The pizza was New York style: thin, floppy slices with heavy cheese and pepperoni that curled into cups and charred at the edges. The 2009 blogger gave it a B-minus. CITY's 2011 guide to Rochester pizzerias was kinder, calling Acme an ordinary saloon whose pie was no afterthought and whose slices folded neatly enough to hold in one hand with a drink in the other.

The kitchen stayed open until 2 a.m. every day, and the doors opened at 11 a.m. on weekdays and at noon at weekends. Tater tots, plain or Cajun, were the other fixture of the menu, alongside wings, subs and fried ravioli. By the early 2020s the bar's website advertised more than 150 beers, with nightly specials such as $2.50 Genesee on Saturdays and cheap microbrews on Sundays. Will Cleveland, who often went there after his shifts as a part-timer in the Democrat and Chronicle sports department, said Acme poured craft beer before it was fashionable.

It was also a dive, and nobody pretended otherwise. CITY's Best Of awards named it among the city's best dive bars in nearly every round, and its basement bathroom had a reputation of its own.

“You could be as weird as you wanted to be there and you'd be accepted.”

Big John and the Acme regulars

For more than 20 years the front door was watched by John Edwards, a bouncer known to everyone as Big John, whom Cleveland called the mayor of Monroe Ave. Cleveland met his wife through an Acme bartender, Morgan, who met her own husband there too. He remembered the night a man-sized banana with a mustache sat alone in a front booth for hours, and nobody bothered it.

Why Acme Bar & Pizza closed in 2024

Word that Acme was closing spread on Reddit on Thursday, August 29, 2024, and the bar manager, Chelsea Brown, confirmed it. The bar also confirmed it in a comment on Instagram. No reason was given in public. The last night was Saturday, August 31, 2024.

By then the business and the building at 495 Monroe Avenue had been listed for sale together on LoopNet for $450,000.

Sources

  1. Acme Bar and Pizza to close after 26 years, CITY (Rochester), Leah Stacy, August 29, 2024
  2. Monroe Ave. institution Acme Bar and Pizza closing? Probably. Maybe. We'll see., Cleveland Prost, Will Cleveland, August 30, 2024
  3. Annual Manual '11: Rochester's Pizzerias, CITY (Rochester), Dayna Papaleo
  4. Acme, Monroe Ave., Pizzabola (Rochester pizza blog), November 2009
  5. Acme Bar & Pizza homepage (archived January 2022), acmebarandpizza.com via the Wayback Machine
  6. Acme Bar & Pizza logo, Est. 1998 (archived October 2021), acmebarandpizza.com via the Wayback Machine

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Acme Bar & Pizza.

Share a memory of Acme Bar & Pizza

The gift shop

The Acme Bar & Pizza sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Acme Bar & Pizza pieces