Little Brother's
Little Brother's carried Stache's into an old library on North High Street in 1997 and booked the White Stripes and Arcade Fire until July 2007.
- Where
- 1100 N. High Street, Short North, Columbus, Ohio
- Open
- 1997–2007
- Known for
- 400-capacity Short North rock club that carried on from Stache's
- Reading time
- 3 minutes

Stache's on North High Street
Little Brother's began as a move. Its parent club, Stache's, stood at 2404 North High Street, across from Dick's Den near the Ohio State campus. A bar called Stache and Little Brother's, earlier the Tree Lounge, had been there since around 1970, named for a mustachioed owner and his younger brother. It was mostly a blues room until the mid-1980s, when SchoolKids Records owner Curt Schieber began booking folk, rock and punk.
In 1988 the club changed hands, and its new owner booked grunge bands before they were famous: Nirvana and Soundgarden both played the carpeted room, along with the Replacements, the Meat Puppets, Guided by Voices and New Bomb Turks. The bartender Kat Agdinaoay remembered a hole at one end of the bar big enough to put a leg through, and a rotting floor that rose and fell during shows. Eventually the landlord said the city was pressing him to tear the building down, and in 1997 Stache's had to go. Its last show, in May 1997, was by the Fleshtones.
An old library at 1100 North High
Within weeks the club reopened a couple of miles south, at 1100 North High Street in the Short North, as Little Brother's, borrowing the second half of the old name. The building had been a Carnegie library and then Gene's Used Furniture, and it was zoned for retail. The boiler had to be brought back to life, a stage, dressing rooms and toilets built, and the change of use approved. Bartender Rebecca "Gretchen" Zimmer remembered staff sitting on the floor with pliers pulling tiny carpet nails.
The new room was decorated from Columbus history. Curtains from Ohio State's old Mershon Auditorium went on the walls to soak up sound, and the bar top came from the Jai Lai, the prime-rib restaurant where Woody Hayes and Ohio State fans ate before games. A mural from the Stache's men's room, showing Elvis dead on a bathroom floor among pills, made the move, as did a portrait of the Pittsburgh Pirates' Roberto Clemente, circus-art murals and the big Stache's sign.
“It wasn't as funky [as Stache's]. It was too big, to where it almost felt unfinished.”
The bands that played Little Brother's
Little Brother's held about 400 people. The stage was four feet high after the fire marshal made the club raise it, and the bar sat far from it; some regulars said it felt like an airport hangar after the cramped Stache's. Local acts such as Scrawl, Moviola, Greenhorn and Gaunt played there, and so did national bands on their way up: the White Stripes, Arcade Fire, Sleater-Kinney and the Black Keys. Mudhoney, Rocket from the Tombs, Gillian Welch, High on Fire and Papa Roach all came through, and the booking ran from indie rock to zydeco.
Talent buyer Ben Hamilton, who joined in 2004, said the hard part was finding local bands who could fill a 400-capacity room on a weekend. In May 2007 someone ran out of the side door with a guitar during an Electric Six show; guitarist Zach Shipps chased him down in the parking lot and got it back.
Why Little Brother's closed in 2007
In 2005 a sale fell through. Matt Gerding and Scott Leslie, who went on to run the Majestic Theatre in Madison, Wisconsin, negotiated for months to buy the club, but they wanted the building too, and the price the landlord asked did not work for them.
In the spring of 2007 the owner and the landlord shook hands on a 15 per cent rent increase. Then the landlord's lawyer came back with a 40 per cent rise, from $4,250 to $6,000 a month, and ten days to accept it. The owner chose to leave. Little Brother's held its final show on July 3, 2007.
What came after Little Brother's
The building at 1100 North High later housed a lounge called Liquid. In Columbus, musicians spent years looking for the next Little Brother's, a title Columbus Monthly gave in 2017 to Ace of Cups, a club run by Marcy Mays, who had played Stache's and Little Brother's with Scrawl.
Sources
- Little Brother's, big shoes (Andy Downing and Joel Oliphint, June 28, 2017), Columbus Monthly
- A veteran rocker remembers (Jim Hutter, September 2007), Out of the Blue
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Little Brother's.
Share a memory of Little Brother's
The gift shop
The Little Brother's sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All Little Brother's pieces

