Skip to content
The Bar Museum

Bernie's Distillery

A bagel counter and basement bar at High Street and 16th Avenue near Ohio State, where touring indie bands and Columbus locals played a tiny stage for 40 years.

Where
North High Street at 16th Avenue, University District, Columbus, Ohio
Open
1975–2015
Known for
Basement bar and indie stage under a bagel shop
Reading time
2 minutes
The Bernie's Distillery sign, redrawn
The Bernie's Distillery sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Opening on High Street in 1975

Bernie's opened in 1975 at 16th Avenue and North High Street, across from the Ohio State campus. The Lantern, the university's student paper, named its founders as Bernie Kaplin and Art Shack. Upstairs it sold soups, sandwiches and bagels; the bar sat in the basement, down a stairway from the High Street sidewalk.

Paul Neikirk, who later tended bar there, told the Lantern in 2009 that he first came down those stairs in the summer of 1976, when his father took him to split a pitcher of Stroh's Dark that cost $2.50. He was hired behind the bar in 1984 and was still there 25 years later.

The basement room and its regulars

The room changed over the years. In the 1980s a recording studio and a library were taken out to make space for a new bar and a larger stage, and the early decor of kegs and lanterns gave way to art on the walls and overhead lights. In 1982 the bar started its Passport: drinkers who worked their way through beers from more than 50 countries earned an engraved mug or a place on the wall.

Fraternities and sororities booked parties there, and the Lantern reported that Bill Clinton's Secret Service once looked the place over as a possible stop during a campus visit, then ruled it out because the basement had only two exits. Regular Merlin Curtis told the paper that people there knew your name.

“This place is like the isle of misfit toys – in the sea of corporate bars, we are like that. We are still here.”

The bands that played the tiny stage

Bernie's booked underground and local bands through the week, and it became a first stop in Columbus for touring indie acts. Chip Midnight, who wrote about the club for the Columbus Calling blog and booked shows there himself, listed Jimmy Eat World, Death Cab for Cutie, Beck and Rilo Kiley among the bands that played Bernie's before moving up to bigger Columbus rooms. The Dismemberment Plan, Pedro the Lion, Mary Lou Lord, Helicopter Helicopter, The Sheila Divine, Ultimate Fakebook and The Dollyrots also played the small stage.

Midnight's own bookings included The Puller, Made to Fade, Our Flesh Party, Sunday's Best, Onelinedrawing and Didi Mao, and he interviewed Hayden, Damien Jurado, The Promise Ring and Death Cab for Cutie at tables on the restaurant side. He was frank about the place: the club was grimy and the bathrooms were awful, but many local bands got their start there, and he noted that some people called it the CBGB of Columbus.

How Bernie's closed

Bernie's closed at the end of 2015. Columbus Calling published its farewell, titled RIP Bernie's, on New Year's Day 2016. Midnight chose not to go into the dispute behind the closing and pointed readers to the Columbus Dispatch's reporting instead. By then the basement bar had been open on High Street for about 40 years.

Sources

  1. Bernie's showcases underground bands, deep-rooted history, The Lantern (Ohio State University)
  2. RIP – Bernie's, Columbus Calling

The gift shop

The Bernie's Distillery sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Bernie's Distillery pieces