Jai Lai
The Jai Lai began as a High Street cafe in 1933 and moved to Olentangy River Road in 1955, where Ohio State fans ate prime rib until it closed in 1996.
- Where
- 1421 Olentangy River Road, near Ohio Stadium, Columbus, Ohio
- Open
- 1933–1996
- Known for
- Prime rib, salt rolls and Woody Hayes' table
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

A saloon on North High Street in 1933
The Jai Lai started small, at 581 North High Street on the corner of Poplar, a few days before Prohibition ended in December 1933. Jasper E. Wottring, known as Jap, opened it with $1,500 he had borrowed. He had earlier run a little saloon on West Spruce Street called the Old Vienna Cafe with Fritz Wentzel, a bare-knuckle fighter from Flytown. The new place sold whiskey and beer by the glass across a wooden bar that had been hauled up from an old South Side saloon, and it took its name from the Jai Lai Club in New Orleans.
The door on High Street was set back from the sidewalk, with a sign beside it promising genuine turtle soup, which the Columbus Bicentennial history of the place treats as more bait than menu. The city's boxing arena, Haft's Acre, stood right behind the building, so fighters drank there, and so did actors passing through town. A Columbus police inspector, Tom Scully, liked to say he could always find a detective in the afternoon at the back of the Jai Lai bar.

The move to Olentangy River Road in 1955
In 1955 the Jai Lai left High Street for a new 9,000-square-foot building at 1421 Olentangy River Road, on the stretch between Fifth and King Avenues south of Ohio Stadium. Columbus Restaurant History describes it as the biggest restaurant in the city when it opened. Its own postcards later advertised a main dining room for 620, private rooms for parties of 15 to 450, a total of 1,070 seats, a kitchen and bakery said to have cost half a million dollars, and a sixty-foot hand-carved oak bar.
Outside it was built like a Spanish mission, with a bell tower, red tile roofs and a tall neon sign spelling Jai Lai in script. Inside were stucco arches, black ironwork, gourds and shawls, moose heads and aquariums. The original High Street bar did not make the trip; it later went to a bar called Little Brothers.
“If I want a detective in the afternoon, all I have to do is dial that phone at the back end of the Jai Lai Bar.”

Prime rib, salt rolls and Woody Hayes
Lunch meant beef stew and dinner meant prime rib. People also remember the Cesta salad, the salt rolls and the herbed butter. City Scene Columbus, looking back at lost restaurants, said the room and the crowd were remembered more than the food, and that Ohio State football coach Woody Hayes counted it as his favourite place to eat. He had his own table on certain nights. So did Ben Hayes, though never on the same night.
The staff had characters of its own. Chappie Geygan, a Sacred Heart Parish boy who had played major league baseball, worked as a host. A career waiter named August Hefner gave talks on world politics in the parking lot.
Closing in 1996 and what came after
The Jai Lai closed in 1996. After a renovation the building reopened on October 13, 1997 as the Buckeye Hall of Fame Cafe, a restaurant filled with Ohio State memorabilia, with three kitchens, four bars and a main dining room for 160. The cafe went into receivership in 2009 and closed in January 2010, and the city approved a tax break for a 134-room hotel on the site. The old Jai Lai building was torn down, and a SpringHill Suites hotel now stands at 1421 Olentangy River Road.
Sources
- Jai Lai Restaurant, Columbus Bicentennial blog, May 31, 2012
- Jai Lai Prime Rib Restaurant, Columbus Restaurant History, 2021
- Repast from the past, CityScene Columbus
- Historic Columbus restaurants, WOSU Public Media
- Landmark Buckeye restaurant to be torn down, Associated Press via the Vindicator, October 27, 2009
- Buckeye Hall of Fame Cafe (photographs and description), Columbus Metropolitan Library via Wikimedia Commons
- Jai Lai Restaurant postcards, Columbus Metropolitan Library via Wikimedia Commons
- SpringHill Suites Columbus OSU, Marriott
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Jai Lai.
Share a memory of Jai Lai
The gift shop
The Jai Lai sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All Jai Lai pieces



