Skip to content

Empire Brewing Company

The basement brewpub at 120 Walton Street in Syracuse's Armory Square: Skinny Atlas, Black Magic Stout, elk burgers, and a farm brewery in Cazenovia.

Where
120 Walton Street (basement of the Bentley Settle Building), Armory Square, Syracuse, New York
Open
1994–2019
Known for
Armory Square basement brewpub that poured Skinny Atlas and Black Magic Stout
Reading time
3 minutes
The Empire Brewing Company sign, redrawn
The Empire Brewing Company sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Opening at 120 Walton Street in Armory Square, 1994

Empire Brewing Company opened in 1994 in the basement of 120 Walton Street, the tall red-brick Bentley Settle Building in Syracuse's Armory Square. Two partners started it, and the brewery's founding is dated to November 13 of that year. In a photograph from 2008 a vertical sign reading EMPIRE marks the stairs that led down from the sidewalk.

The company described the place as a contemporary downtown bar and grill with a brewery on the premises. The brewhouse, a seven-barrel system, sat behind glass so that drinkers could watch the copper and stainless steel vessels at work, and the kitchen was open to the room in the same way. The rest was left as the old warehouse had it: exposed brick walls, wood beams and columns. The Syracuse New Times put Empire in its Best Of awards every year from 1995 to 2004.

The tall red-brick Bentley Settle Building at 120 Walton Street in Syracuse, with a vertical Empire Brewing Company sign at the stairs down to the basement brewpub
The Bentley Settle Building at 120 Walton Street in Armory Square, Syracuse, in May 2008, with the Empire Brewing Company sign at the basement entrance.Photo: XeresNelro, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Skinny Atlas, Black Magic Stout and the medal-winning beers

The brewery kept six to eight beers on tap, built around four that were poured all year: Skinny Atlas Light, a Kolsch, Empire Amber Ale, a Hefe Weizen, and Black Magic Stout, a dry Irish stout served on nitrogen. Seasonals such as a spring bock, an Oktoberfest and a spiced winter ale filled the other lines.

The medals started early. The Hefe Weizen took bronze at the Great American Beer Festival in Denver in 1995 and gold in 1996, and the Kolsch won gold there in 1997. By 2002, when a Marzen and a Schwarzbier both won gold in Denver, the company listed eight festival medals and three from the World Beer Cup, including a gold for the stout.

Later tap lists ran much longer and leaned on New York produce. In 2014 they included Deep Purple, made with Concord grapes from the state, Critz Apple Ale, with cider from Critz Farm in Cazenovia, a Blueberry Ale served with berries floating in the glass, Downtown Brown and a nitrogen-poured Cream Ale. By 2016 five beers were going out to stores and bars across the state: Slo Mo' IPA, East Coast Amber Ale, White Aphro, Black Magic Stout and Skinny Atlas Kolsch.

The menu: gumbo, farmstead chili and elk burgers

The food got as much attention as the beer, and the company called it American fare with regional influences. The menu in 2014 opened with Big Easy gumbo, a farmstead chili made from local elk, kobe and Angus beef, pork and lamb, and a 15-vegetable Moroccan chili. There was blue corn bread with local maple butter, soft pretzels seasoned like an everything bagel, an elk burger with local mushrooms and Swiss cheese, and the Bentley burger, named for the building. Sunday brunch had its own menu.

The kitchen bought from farms nearby and used vegetables and herbs from the brewpub's own garden, and Slow Food of Central New York gave it a Snail of Approval in 2010. In 2013 the brewpub appeared on the television programme Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives.

Rochester's High Falls, Buffalo and the 2007 reopening

Three years after opening in Syracuse, Empire added a second brewpub in Rochester. It opened in 1997 in the former Button Factory building at State and Platt streets, where it helped launch the High Falls entertainment district, and Mayor William A. Johnson cut the ribbon at the opening. A third brewpub followed in Buffalo's theater district. It lasted about a year and closed early in 2001.

The Rochester brewpub closed abruptly in 2003, and the Walton Street original shut soon afterwards. The founder brought Empire back to the same Syracuse basement in 2007, and it ran there for another 12 years.

The Empire Farm Brewery in Cazenovia

In May 2015 Empire broke ground on a farm brewery on 22 acres along Route 13 in Cazenovia, in Madison County. The plan was to raise output from about 4,500 barrels a year to 17,000 in the first year, and to grow some of the beer's ingredients on the spot. It opened in June 2016.

The new plant brewed 60 barrels at a time and had a bottling line, and 12 of its acres were set aside for hops, barley, rye, wheat, herbs, fruit and vegetables. It had a 100-seat restaurant and tasting room laid out like a beer hall, with long shared tables and a patio lined with 30,000 bricks salvaged from the Haberle Brewing Company, the Syracuse brewery on Butternut Street that closed in 1962. With production moved to Cazenovia, the Walton Street brewhouse became the pilot plant for new and experimental beers, all of it kegged.

When Empire closed and what is at 120 Walton Street now

The Armory Square brewpub closed after business on Wednesday, October 16, 2019, and did not reopen. The farm brewery in Cazenovia ended the same year.

In 2024 The Whiskey Coop, a Nashville hot chicken and bourbon restaurant, opened in the basement. Its owner, Cheryl Chaif, also runs The Hops Spot next door. The brick walls and limestone of the old room are still there.

Sources

  1. About Empire Brewing Company (archived March 2008), empirebrew.com, via the Internet Archive
  2. Awards (archived March 2008), empirebrew.com, via the Internet Archive
  3. Our Brewpub (archived May 2014), empirebrew.com, via the Internet Archive
  4. Lunch & Dinner menu (archived May 2014), empirebrew.com, via the Internet Archive
  5. Our Beers (archived June 2014), empirebrew.com, via the Internet Archive
  6. The Empire Strikes Back, Syracuse New Times
  7. Building an Empire, Syracuse New Times
  8. Popular Syracuse brewery was going to help rebuild a Rochester neighborhood. Did it?, USA Today Network, via AOL
  9. Empire Brewing Co. of Syracuse, New York, Tavern Trove
  10. Empire Brewing Company, Wikipedia
  11. Empire Brewing Company closes, Spectrum News 1
  12. Two veteran restauranteurs bring new food to Armory Square, Spectrum News 1
  13. 10 New Restaurants That Opened in Syracuse, And the Ones Worth the Wait, CNY Signal

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Empire Brewing Company.

Share a memory of Empire Brewing Company

The gift shop

The Empire Brewing Company sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Empire Brewing Company pieces