Skip to content

Buggsy's

Buggsy's Back Alley Bar served Syracuse University students on South Crouse Avenue in the 1980s, in a room that was The Orange before it and Lucy's after.

Where
South Crouse Avenue off Marshall Street, University Hill, Syracuse, New York
Known for
1980s Syracuse University student bar with a dunk tank
Reading time
2 minutes
The Buggsy's sign, redrawn
The Buggsy's sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

How The Orange became Buggsy's Back Alley Bar

Buggsy's was one of a run of student bars that occupied the same room on South Crouse Avenue, off Marshall Street, the strip where generations of Syracuse University students have gone out. Before it, the bar there was called The Orange, which Jerk Magazine lists with Hungry Charley's and Sutter's Mill as the bars of the block in the late 1970s.

The change of name came from the Dellas family, who have run Varsity Pizza at the corner of Marshall Street and South Crouse Avenue for three generations. In 1978 the cousins Jerry and John Dellas got a liquor licence and opened Faegan's Cafe and Pub. Soon afterwards, by Jerk's account, they bought The Orange and turned it into Buggsy's. No source found gives the year. Jerry Dellas told the magazine that on opening night the line to get in stretched around the corner of the block.

The dunk tank and the drinking age in the 1980s

The newspaper record of what went on inside is thin. When syracuse.com gathered readers' memories of Marshall Street hangouts in 2017, it gave the bar's full name as Buggsy's Back Alley Bar, placed it in the 1980s and recorded one detail: it had a dunk tank.

Those were hard years for bars that lived on undergraduates. New York raised its drinking age from 18 to 19 in 1982 and to 21 in 1985. Jerk wrote that the second change cut the Marshall Street bars' student custom roughly in half and left them to deal with underage drinkers and police raids. Neither source says when Buggsy's closed or changed its name.

Lucy's, Orange Crate and the 2017 demolition

By the 2000s the room was Lucy's Retired Surfers Bar, known for 32-ounce fish bowls that friends shared. A later manager, Jason Muratore, worked there under that name from 2004 to 2006. It then became Orange Crate Brewing Co., though Jerk noted that students went on calling it Lucy's.

A developer then bought four adjoining buildings on South Crouse Avenue to make way for The Marshall, an eight-storey student apartment block. The NewsHouse reported that word came in early 2017 that demolition could begin as soon as that March. Orange Crate's building was torn down that year, as was the bar Hungry Chuck's. Orange Crate reopened in the autumn in a former Bruegger's Bagels, and The Marshall had gone up by 2019. Faegan's, the bar the Dellas cousins opened first, was still trading when those articles were written.

Sources

  1. 13 legendary Marshall Street hangouts, syracuse.com
  2. A (Bar) Hop Through History: Syracuse Edition, Jerk Magazine
  3. How the construction of The Marshall 'sanitized' one of Syracuse's favorite alleyways, The NewsHouse

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Buggsy's.

Share a memory of Buggsy's

The gift shop

The Buggsy's sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Buggsy's pieces