The Blue Tusk
The Blue Tusk poured craft beer at 165 Walton Street in Armory Square from 1995 until September 25, 2021, when a lease dispute ended its 26-year run.
- Where
- 165 Walton Street, Center Armory, Armory Square, Syracuse, New York
- Open
- 1995–2021
- Known for
- Pioneering Syracuse craft-beer bar with 69 taps
- Reading time
- 4 minutes

Opening in the Center Armory on Walton Street in 1995
The Blue Tusk opened in 1995 at 165 Walton Street, on the ground floor of the Center Armory, a building that was then new, with shops at street level and condominiums above. It was a family business. The father had run the Armory Deli, and by one account had a small sandwich shop across the street. The larger bar and deli opened when his son joined him. The two ran it together for the next 26 years, with other members of the family working alongside them.
By the bar's own account it started with three beers on tap, a large stock of bottled beers, wine and cigars. The food came from the deli side: sandwiches, cheese plates and, later, a longer menu that the son built up from his travels. Customers ordered at the bar and were handed a pager that buzzed when the food was ready. A local magazine described a room of wood and stone with booths on one side and a looser, more open area on the other, behind big windows onto Walton Street. In summer there were tables on the sidewalk.

From three taps to 69: the beer list
The Tusk was among the first bars in Central New York to pour what were then called microbrews, several years before "craft beer" was a common phrase. Together with the original Clark's Ale House nearby, it gave small brewers a place to sell. Middle Ages Brewing Co. opened in Syracuse the same year, and its co-founder Marc Rubenstein said the Tusk put his beer on tap straight away. When his son Isaac turned 21, Rubenstein took him there for his first beer. Brewery Ommegang of Cooperstown found an early outlet at the bar too.
The list grew through three expansions to 69 taps. It carried New York brewers such as Ithaca, Southern Tier and Ellicottville, West Coast names such as Sierra Nevada and Rogue, and Belgian imports including Chimay and Duvel. A yearly Duvel Day was held 26 times, the last on August 27, 2021. The bar was also known for cask-conditioned ales, which changed from week to week. John LaGraff, a retired Syracuse University engineering professor, recalled walking in with friends every Friday and asking what was on cask. The casks stopped when the pandemic arrived in 2020.
In 2008 the magazine All About Beer ranked the Blue Tusk 48th on its list of 125 places in the world to have a beer before you die. Clark's was 97th. In 2018 readers of Table Hopping voted it the best place in Central New York for draft beer.
“If the Tusk wasn’t here, I don’t know if we would be here.”
The Tuskafari, the Grateful Dead and the motto
The son had a name for the regulars: the Tuskafari, or Tuskafarians. The music was the Grateful Dead and other jam bands, with reggae and punk mixed in, and tie-dye was the house style. The bar's motto was "Reality is a hallucination caused by the lack of good beer and fine wine."
Paul Chwalek, a regular, told syracuse.com in the last week that he had known few people there when he first came in and had since kept some of them as friends for 20 years. Two New York breweries made beers in the bar's honour in 2021: Thin Man Brewery of Buffalo brewed Tuskafari, and Sloop Brewing of Poughkeepsie brewed Tusk Bomb, which was on tap in the final week.
The lease dispute and the last day, September 25, 2021
The Blue Tusk stayed in business through the Covid-19 pandemic. What ended it was the lease. About three years before the closing, the original developer of the Center Armory, Bob Doucette, sold the building's ground-floor retail spaces to a developer from Long Island, and from then on the bar rented month to month. The owners said that early in 2021 they agreed to a new three-year lease at the higher rent the landlord wanted, but that it was never signed. On June 7, they said, the property manager told them a new tenant was coming and the Tusk would have to leave, and that the newcomer had accepted a 25-year lease, a term they could not match. The property manager denied having lined up anyone on a 25-year lease and would not discuss the details. He called the bar an ideal tenant.
The news came out on June 23, 2021. In July the owner of a ramen restaurant a block away announced that he would open a beer bar called the Taphouse on Walton in the space. He said the landlord and the property manager had approached him and that he had no part in the dispute.
Regulars spent the summer saying goodbye, some of them travelling back to Syracuse to do it. The last day was Saturday, September 25, 2021.
What is at 165 Walton Street now
The new operator said in 2021 that the Tusk's interior would be gutted and rebuilt, with more seating for diners, and that a sourdough bakery would take the space next door. The Taphouse on Walton took over the address. Visit Syracuse lists it among Armory Square's places to eat, with flatbreads, sandwiches and salads to go with the beer.
Sources
- Blue Tusk, pioneering CNY craft beer bar, is closing. Here's what we know, syracuse.com
- New craft beer bar to take over soon-to-be-vacated Blue Tusk space in Armory Square, syracuse.com
- 'Where are we gonna go now?' Saying goodbye to The Blue Tusk after 26 years, syracuse.com
- Last call at The Blue Tusk: 'An anchor of connection and friendship for so many, for so long', syracuse.com
- The Blue Tusk, Table Hopping
- Our Story, The Blue Tusk, via the Wayback Machine
- COVID Didn't Kill this Iconic Syracuse Bar, but a Lease Disagreement May, Big Frog 104
- Discover Armory Square, Visit Syracuse
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of The Blue Tusk.
Share a memory of The Blue Tusk
The gift shop
The The Blue Tusk sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Blue Tusk pieces



