Skip to content

Beefsteak Mining Co.

Beefsteak Mining Co. was the steak and seafood restaurant inside Penn-Can Mall north of Syracuse, with the Whiskey Flats Drinking Emporium as its bar.

Where
Penn-Can Mall, 5775 South Bay Road, Cicero, New York
Known for
Mall steakhouse with the Whiskey Flats Drinking Emporium for a bar
Reading time
2 minutes
The Beefsteak Mining Co. sign, redrawn
The Beefsteak Mining Co. sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

A steakhouse inside Penn-Can Mall

Penn-Can Mall opened in 1976 on South Bay Road in Cicero, the first enclosed mall on the north side of Syracuse. The Beefsteak Mining Company was its sit-down restaurant. The earliest mention found is from June 1977, when a Fulton club planned a mall tour followed by lunch there, and no report of its opening day turned up, so the opening year is left open here.

The restaurant quickly became a landmark inside the mall. When a shop selling Mexican furnishings opened in the summer of 1977, the Baldwinsville Messenger located it as opposite the Beefsteak Mining Co. A bridal shop was still giving the same direction in its ads in April 1986. In January 1981, when the mall's merchants took out an ad to mark the start of their fifth year, Beefsteak Mining Co. was on the list. That ad gave the mall's address as 5775 South Bay Road with a Clay post office.

Steaks, unlimited shrimp and the Whiskey Flats Drinking Emporium

A December 1982 advertisement in the Messenger promised the finest steaks and seafood, with unlimited shrimp at the salad bar at lunch or dinner. The bar had its own name, the Whiskey Flats Drinking Emporium. The same ad offered banquet facilities, gift certificates and a discount on movie tickets with any meal, and suggested reservations at 458-3635.

The advertising kept to the mining camp theme. In late 1983 an ad written in a prospector's drawl announced Sunday brunch from 11 to 2, with Canadian bacon, lasagna, roast beef, Belgian waffles with strawberries, baked ham, bagels, cheesecake, croissants and champagne. It called the place one of Syracuse's finest eating establishments.

The Baldwinsville Messenger's social columns show how people used it between 1978 and 1980: Saturday lunches at the mall, an Easter Sunday dinner, a 40th wedding anniversary, a club's installation banquet. The author of the Syracuse Nostalgia site, who grew up going to the mall, wrote that he never ate there because it seemed too fancy and expensive for a kid.

The Rochester restaurants at Ridge Hudson Plaza and Pittsford Plaza

The restaurant's matchbox listed Syracuse alongside two Rochester-area addresses, Ridge Hudson Plaza and Pittsford Plaza. The Irondequoit location at Ridge Hudson Plaza advertised in the Greece Post in January 1989 with a hot and cold salad buffet of more than 100 items, $5.95 before 6 p.m. and $7.95 after, in copy written as a card game. It was still booking banquets in June 1996 and hosted a Monroe County Supervisors' Association luncheon in October 1998.

What happened to Beefsteak Mining Co. and Penn-Can Mall

The April 1986 bridal shop ad is the last trace of the Penn-Can restaurant found in the newspapers searched. No closing report was located, so the year it shut is not given here. The mall itself closed in 1996. The auto dealer Roger Burdick bought the building in early 2000 and turned it into Driver's Village, a row of car showrooms under the old roof. The mall's street clock was still standing in the center court when it was photographed in 2006.

Readers named Beefsteak Mining Co. in syracuse.com's May 2016 poll of Syracuse bars they wished they had back.

The center court of the former Penn-Can Mall seen from the upper level, with a street clock ringed by Christmas trees and cars parked on the showroom floor.
The center court of the former Penn-Can Mall in Cicero, by then Driver's Village, in December 2006.Photo: Kai Brinker (Newkai), CC BY-SA 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons

Sources

  1. Driver's Village (formerly Penn-Can Mall), Wikipedia
  2. Penn Can Mall opens 40 years ago, billed as 'great new shopping experience', syracuse.com (The Post-Standard), April 1, 2016, via the Wayback Machine
  3. Club notice: mall tour and luncheon at Beefsteak Mining Company, June 1977, Oswego Palladium-Times, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  4. Item on The Aztec Idol shop at Penn Can Mall, June 29, 1977, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  5. Penn Can Mall "Five years of progress" merchants' advertisement, January 28, 1981, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  6. Beefsteak Mining Company Restaurant advertisement, December 8, 1982, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  7. Beefsteak Mining Restaurant Sunday brunch advertisement, late 1983, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  8. Jacqueline's Bridal Fashions advertisement ("Opposite Beefsteak Mining"), April 1986, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  9. Social column: Saturday lunch at the Beefsteak Mining restaurant, Penn Can Mall, 1978, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  10. Social column: Easter Sunday dinner at the Beefsteak Mining Co., 1979, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  11. Social column: 40th wedding anniversary dinner at Beefsteak Mining Co., 1980, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  12. Club notice: installation banquet at the Beefsteak Mining restaurant, May 1980, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  13. Penn Can Mall classic photos, page 4, Syracuse Nostalgia, via the Wayback Machine
  14. Beefsteak Mining Company hot and cold salad buffet advertisement, Ridge Hudson Plaza, January 1989, Greece Post, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  15. Fire auxiliary banquet notice, Beefsteak Mining Company, Ridge and Culver roads, June 1996, Webster Herald, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  16. Nozzolio featured speaker at county supervisors' luncheon, October 21, 1998, Webster Herald, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  17. We asked, you answered: Syracuse bars we wish we had back, syracuse.com (The Post-Standard), May 6, 2016, via the Wayback Machine

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Beefsteak Mining Co..

Share a memory of Beefsteak Mining Co.

The gift shop

The Beefsteak Mining Co. sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Beefsteak Mining Co. pieces