Skip to content
The Bar Museum

Toots Shor's

Toots Shor's at 51 West 51st Street was the Manhattan saloon where Joe DiMaggio, Jackie Gleason and the city's sportswriters drank around a big circular bar.

Where
51 West 51st Street, Midtown Manhattan, New York; later 33 West 52nd Street
Open
1940–1971
Known for
Sportswriters' and ballplayers' saloon with a big round bar
Reading time
3 minutes
The Toots Shor's sign, redrawn
The Toots Shor's sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Bernard Shor, from Philadelphia to the speakeasies

Bernard Shor was born in Philadelphia in 1903 to Orthodox Jewish parents and grew up above the family's candy store in South Philadelphia. His mother was killed by a car when he was 15, and his father took his own life five years later. After some time at the Drexel Institute and the Wharton School, and a spell selling shirts and underwear on the road, he moved to New York in 1930.

There he worked the doors of Prohibition-era clubs: the Five O'Clock Club, Lahiff's Tavern on West 48th Street, the Napoleon Club and Leon & Eddie's on 52nd Street, among others. Everyone called him Toots. The jobs taught him the trade and introduced him to the newspapermen, ballplayers and show people who would follow him.

Opening on West 51st Street in 1940

Toots Shor's opened on April 30, 1940, at 51 West 51st Street, next to Radio City. It cost about $100,000. Shor raised roughly half himself, and a New Jersey theater owner, Leo Justin, put up the rest with four associates, who had their money back within two years. The restaurant later took over 53 and 55 West 51st as well, doubling in size and adding banquet rooms upstairs and a private screening room.

The food was plain: shrimp cocktail, steak, baked potatoes, pot roast. The drinks were strong, and the center of the room was an oversized circular bar. There was no band and no television: the customers were the show. Shor himself called the place nothing fancy, and he ran it more like a men's club than a restaurant. Women were allowed but not encouraged, and wives were referred to as the Missus.

“Nobody is pushed around except by me.”

DiMaggio, Gleason and the crum-bums

Shor courted baseball executives, writers and players, and after 1936 he set his sights on the young Yankee Joe DiMaggio. The two became close; after a bad game DiMaggio would send for Shor and they would walk along Fifth Avenue without talking baseball. The friendship ended, according to PBS's American Experience, when Shor brought up Marilyn Monroe, a subject DiMaggio would not discuss. Mickey Mantle, Yogi Berra and the boxer Jack Dempsey were regulars.

The show-business side was just as strong. Jackie Gleason ate there for free and once lost a drinking contest to Shor that ended with Gleason on the floor. Frank Sinatra was a fixture, and Earl Warren, the Chief Justice, counted Shor as a close friend. Shor called the people he liked his crum-bums and rewarded them with loyalty, privacy and a constant ribbing he called the needle. He was less patient with outsiders. He made Charlie Chaplin wait in line and told him to be funny for the people around him, and when the MGM boss Louis B. Mayer complained about a twenty-minute wait, Shor said the food would be better than some of Mayer's pictures.

Leaving 51st Street for 52nd

In September 1958 Shor sold his lease on 51st Street for $1.5 million to the developer William Zeckendorf and Mutual Life, who wanted the site for a new building. The original restaurant closed on June 30, 1959. Shor spent the gap travelling in Europe and drinking at other people's bars.

His new place, a nine-story building with a garage on the upper floors, went up a block north at 33 West 52nd Street, on the site of Leon & Eddie's, where he had once worked as a $50-a-week bouncer. TIME reported in January 1962 that it had opened the week before, without invitations, to a crowd that included Groucho Marx, Yogi Berra, Whitey Ford, Frank Gifford, Jack Dempsey and Rocky Marciano. Gleason sent flowers. Shor tried to copy the old room's look and feel.

Why Toots Shor's closed

The old crowd thinned out. Night baseball made it harder for writers and players to drink together after games, and the Dodgers and Giants had left New York. Shor was also generous to a fault, forgiving debts and picking up checks, and careless with money. In 1971 tax authorities padlocked the 52nd Street restaurant over $269,516 in unpaid federal, state and city taxes.

Shor promised to reopen within weeks. It took about eighteen months before he opened a smaller place at 5 East 54th Street, and accounts differ on how long that lasted. The famous regulars never came back in the same numbers. Shor died on January 23, 1977, at 73, with almost nothing left. The 52nd Street building became the New York, New York discotheque and was later torn down for an office tower.

Sources

  1. Toots Shor's Restaurant, Wikipedia
  2. Toots Shor, Wikipedia
  3. Bernard "Toots" Shor (Joe DiMaggio feature), PBS American Experience
  4. Restaurants: Forever Toots's, TIME, January 5, 1962
  5. Historic Nightlife of New York: Toots Shor's, Alcohol Professor
  6. Joe DiMaggio, Frank Sinatra, Jack Dempsey: America's Greatest Sports Bar, Toots Shor, The Daily Beast

The gift shop

The Toots Shor's sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Toots Shor's pieces