Skip to content

This Is It!

June Brehm opened This Is It! on East Wells Street in August 1968. It ran for nearly 57 years as Wisconsin's oldest gay bar before closing in March 2025.

Where
418 E. Wells Street, at Jefferson Street by Cathedral Square, East Town, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Open
1968–2025
Known for
Wisconsin's oldest gay bar, opened by a straight ally in 1968
Reading time
3 minutes
The This Is It! sign, redrawn
The This Is It! sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

June Brehm opens a gay bar on Wells Street in 1968

This Is It! opened on 1 August 1968 at 418 E. Wells Street, on the corner of Jefferson Street in downtown Milwaukee's East Town, close to Cathedral Square. That was almost a year before the Stonewall uprising in New York. The two-story brick building it occupied dates from 1914, according to city assessment records.

Its founder was Catherine "June" Brehm, born in 1917, a married, straight woman who had worked in the service industry and had seen how gay people were treated. The Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project describes her plan as simple: a bar where her gay friends could feel safe and welcome. She opened it with a partner, Michael Latona, and an early advertisement in the GPU News billed the place as the East Side's new food and fun bar. The two disagreed over June's idea of a home bar for gay men, and Latona left. Wikipedia's account puts her in full control by 1970.

Joe Brehm behind the bar for three decades

In the early years June poured drinks herself and listened to customers' troubles with work and boyfriends. After she had a stroke in 1981, her son Joe Brehm, born in 1942, became part owner and ran the bar day to day, though she kept a close hand on it. Even late in life she came in on weekday mornings to clean, count the cash drawers and talk. She owned the bar until she died in January 2010.

Under Joe, who managed it for about 30 years, the room barely changed. Travel guides from 1976 described a downtown lounge with a mixed crowd, from reserved gentlemen to customers who were not reserved at all. One regular remembered that Joe could answer any question about an old film or a song on the jukebox. The bar raised money for the Cream City Foundation, AIDS groups and other causes, and it was where people gathered to mark Milwaukee's 1980 nondiscrimination ordinance, Wisconsin's 1982 gay rights law, the city's first Pride march in 1989, Tammy Baldwin's election in 1998 and the arrival of marriage equality in 2014 and 2015.

“When the outside world believed gay men had no place in the world, my grandmother vowed to create one for them.”

The brick front of This Is It! at 418 E. Wells Street, with a white flag bearing the bar's rainbow logo and a wall painted with rainbow diamonds
The front of This Is It! at 418 E. Wells Street, Milwaukee, in 2012.Photo: Desagesse, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

George Schneider, the 2018 expansion and Trixie Mattel

George Schneider, who had worked at the bar and managed it, became part owner in 2012 and took full control after Joe Brehm died of complications of ALS on 3 April 2016. Mayor Tom Barrett proclaimed Joe Brehm Day that spring.

The bar turned 50 in August 2018. That year Louise's, the restaurant next door, closed, and This Is It! took about 1,200 square feet of its old private dining room. The addition opened in January 2019 and doubled the bar's size, with a second bar, a dance floor, dressing rooms and a removable stage. To get a city licence that let people 18 and over in on certain nights, the bar worked with the Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project to put up panels on Milwaukee's gay bar history. In November 2018 rainbow crosswalks were painted at Cathedral Square, a project Schneider had pushed for.

Drag, DJ nights and ballroom events filled the new space, and the bar ran alcohol-free nights for younger customers. During the pandemic it opened its doors to Milwaukee's House and Ballroom community. In February 2021 the drag performer Trixie Mattel, the Wisconsin-born Brian Firkus, who had performed there, bought a share and became co-owner with Schneider.

Why This Is It! closed in 2025

The bar was hit hard by the pandemic shutdown in 2020, when a GoFundMe raised more than $12,000. Then in 2024 the reconstruction of Wells Street closed the road and sidewalk out front for about eight months, and during Pride weekend customers could only get in through the alley.

This Is It! opened for the last time on Saturday 8 March 2025 and shut at 2 a.m. on Sunday 9 March. The owners announced the closing on Facebook that day, blaming the COVID years and the street work, and taped a farewell note in the front windows. There was no last party. People left candles, flowers and messages outside and gathered in Cathedral Square that afternoon. The bar would have turned 57 that summer.

The building and the state historic marker

The building at 418-432 E. Wells Street belongs to Van Buren Management, the firm of Joel Lee, who had been landlord to June and Joe Brehm for decades. In May 2025 a downtown resident asked the city's Historic Preservation Commission to designate the whole building, and the former restaurant space facing Cathedral Square was proposed for a steakhouse. The History Project reported the old bar space still empty.

On 4 March 2026 the Wisconsin Historical Society approved a State Historic Marker for the site, paid for by private donations and to be cared for by the Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project. It is the second LGBTQ landmark the state has recognised. The marker was due to go up on the sidewalk outside 418 E. Wells Street in the summer of 2026.

Sources

  1. This Is It!, Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project
  2. Catherine "June" Brehm, Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project
  3. This Is It! (bar), Wikipedia
  4. Historic Gay Bar This Is It! Has Closed, Urban Milwaukee
  5. This Is It!, Wisconsin's oldest gay bar, closes in Milwaukee, WPR
  6. Is This Is It! Building Worthy of Historic Designation?, Urban Milwaukee
  7. This Is It (1968-2025) Approved for State Historic Marker, Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project, via Urban Milwaukee

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of This Is It!.

Share a memory of This Is It!

The gift shop

The This Is It! sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All This Is It! pieces