Skip to content
The Bar Museum

Edinburgh Castle Pub

The Scottish pub at 950 Geary Street hosted folk nights, punk shows, Irvine Welsh and Litquake before sheriff's deputies padlocked it in August 2025.

Where
950 Geary Street, Tenderloin, San Francisco
Open
1960–2025
Known for
Scottish pub with an upstairs room for folk, punk and readings
Reading time
3 minutes
The Edinburgh Castle Pub sign, redrawn
The Edinburgh Castle Pub sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

A Scottish pub on Geary Street from 1960

The Edinburgh Castle opened at 950 Geary Street in the Tenderloin on New Year's Day 1960, according to Mission Local; some later listings give 1959. It was a Scottish pub from the start, and it kept the theme for more than six decades: dark wooden booths, bartenders in vests, pewter mugs racked behind the bar, Scottish memorabilia on the walls and model airplanes hanging from the ceiling. There was a pool table and dartboards, and a front room with unsteady chairs and a piano past saving. Fish and chips came from a shop down the alley behind the building, and haggis was on the menu.

In the 1960s one of the regulars was S.I. Hayakawa, the linguist who later served as a United States senator. For a while the pub kept a pet parrot.

The Castle Folk Club upstairs, 1983 to 1992

The building had a large upstairs room that sat mostly unused until 1983. That year the singers Dick Holdstock and Allan Macleod asked the owner, Robert Johnson, whether they could run a folk club there. Johnson, who had once been married to the Scottish singer Jean Redpath, let them have the room free, on condition that they cleaned up and put the furniture back afterwards. The Castle Folk Club met for the first time on October 6, 1983, and after that on the first and third Thursdays of the month, nine months a year, with music from eight to eleven.

The room was cluttered when they found it and held chairs and old wooden church pews, which volunteers dragged into place for every meeting. Faith Petric, Ricky Rackin and Redmond O'Colonies were the first residents, with Louis Killen and later Peter and Gail Kessler joining. Guest performers were paid $200 or 80 percent of the door. Holdstock recalled that the pub changed hands around 1990, and the club moved to the Connecticut Yankee on Potrero Hill in January 1992.

“The last true dive bar in San Francisco.”

Writers, Burns nights and Trainspotting

In the early 1990s the Castle became a meeting place for San Francisco's writers and pranksters. The satirical magazine The Nose held its weekly editorial meetings there, and when it folded in 1995 its wake was held in the bar with a bagpiper. The Cacophony Society met upstairs. A Scottish Association formed around the pub in the mid-1990s and ran Burns nights and other Scottish events, and the Castle staged the world premiere of the stage version of Irvine Welsh's Trainspotting before the film came out.

Bartender Alan Black ran a reading series upstairs, and the list of writers who read there, as kept by the writer Jack Boulware, includes Michelle Tea, Beth Lisick, Mary Roach, Po Bronson, Kim Addonizio, Noah Hawley, James Kelman and Lawrence Ferlinghetti. When Welsh came back on a tour for his novel Glue, more than 300 people crowded in and the line ran to the end of the block. The Litstock festival, started in 1999, held its afterparty at the Castle, and its successor Litquake used the pub for meetings for years. Boulware also hosted a wake for Hunter S. Thompson there in 2005. Scenes for the 1993 film So I Married an Axe Murderer were shot inside, and the bar later appeared in Venom.

Punk shows and Tay Kim's years

Tay Kim took over the bar in 1999. Under him the Castle booked bands, readings, weddings and, by his account, the occasional bar mitzvah. In the early 2000s the upstairs stage was a regular stop for punk shows; Fred Schrunk of Thrillhouse Records told Mission Local it had been one of his favourite places to see a band. The shows stopped around 2010, though the pub quiz and the smoking room, one of the last still in use in a San Francisco bar, carried on. In the last two years before it closed, the promoters Nick Oka and Zack Yackel brought back punk and indie bills, raves, poetry nights and open mics under the name z+n presents.

Why the Edinburgh Castle closed in 2025

Kim put the business up for sale in 2019, but it never changed owners. On February 8, 2024, U.S. Bank filed a foreclosure motion against him for $706,000, and on June 27, 2025, a San Francisco Superior Court judge ordered the property repossessed. Kim said sheriff's deputies arrived on August 6, 2025, to close the pub. When Mission Local visited nine days later, the outer gate was chained and padlocked, the lights were still on and empty beer cases were stacked inside the door.

Sources

  1. S.F. sheriff's deputies evict Tenderloin dive bar with 'shields & batons', Mission Local
  2. Edinburgh Castle Literary Pub, Jack Boulware, What Jack Boulware Fails to Realize
  3. San Francisco's Castle Folk Club, Dick Holdstock, The Folknik
  4. Edinburgh Castle Pub, Wikipedia

The gift shop

The Edinburgh Castle Pub sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Edinburgh Castle Pub pieces