The Pub
The Pub served students, townspeople and a young Natalie Cole at 15 East Pleasant Street in Amherst for 51 years until it closed in December 2019.
- Where
- 15 East Pleasant Street, downtown Amherst, Massachusetts
- Open
- 1968–2019
- Known for
- Downtown restaurant-bar where Natalie Cole sang as a UMass student
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

Opening on East Pleasant Street in 1968
The Pub opened in 1968 in a building put up that year at 15 East Pleasant Street, at the northern end of downtown Amherst and a short walk from the edge of the UMass Amherst campus. It shared the block with two older neighbors, the Summerlin Building at 11 East Pleasant, dating from 1921, and the Piper Building at 9 East Pleasant, from 1965.
The place was tied to one family for nearly its whole life. Gerald Jolly worked there from the day it opened, according to his son Aaron, and his wife Dolly joined about two years later. The couple bought the business in 2001, and Aaron, who started working there in 1996, went on to manage it. The Jollys also ran Rafters Sports Bar on Amity Street until that building was sold to a marijuana company.
Natalie Cole's weekly gig
The Pub's best-known performer was Natalie Cole. While she was a student at UMass in the early 1970s, Cole sang at the restaurant every week, the Amherst Bulletin reported. Local tradition, repeated by the Boston Globe when The Pub closed, holds that her first performances as a singer took place there in 1972.
For most of its customers The Pub was simply the place downtown where generations of college students ate, drank and worked shifts. Before Massachusetts banned happy-hour discounts in 1984, the bar sold more than 35,000 of its souvenir Pub mugs. A former Amherst resident, writing to the Bulletin after it closed, remembered lunches and dinners with friends and a summer patio crowded under bright umbrellas and flower boxes.
“Both of us are so moved by the fact that so many people came back.”
A gathering place for the town
Beyond the student trade, The Pub became one of the rooms where Amherst held its public life. The Daily Hampshire Gazette listed election-night parties there, along with charity events such as the Empty Bowls benefit for the Amherst Survival Center and the Daffodil Days fundraiser for Big Brothers Big Sisters of Hampshire County. When it closed, the head of the Amherst Area Chamber of Commerce, Claudia Pazmany, told the Gazette that everyone in town had memories of the place.
Why The Pub closed in 2019
The building did not belong to the Jollys. In May 2019 its owner, the Summerlin Trust, headed by Laird Summerlin of South Carolina, applied to demolish The Pub along with the Summerlin and Piper buildings. Amherst's Historical Commission found that none of the three was historically significant, which cleared the way for redevelopment, and the Jollys learned their lease would not be renewed.
The Pub closed after business on Saturday, December 21, 2019, with a last night of a DJ and dancing. Old customers came back in large numbers for the final weeks, and Dolly Jolly told the Globe that the turnout had moved her and her husband deeply. The family said it planned to open a new restaurant in town called Savannas.
What's on the site now
In 2021 the developer Archipelago Investments filed plans for a five-story apartment building called 11 East Pleasant on the land from 9 to 15 East Pleasant Street, with the old Pub building to be demolished for it. The finished building is a five-story, all-electric block of about 90 apartments aimed at students, now leased under the name 11 East Pleasant.
Sources
- The Pub, an Amherst landmark, shuts down after more than 50 years, Boston Globe, via Boston.com
- The Pub in Amherst, Daily Hampshire Gazette
- Three downtown Amherst buildings considered for demolition, Amherst Bulletin
- Downtown Amherst bar closes (Olde Towne Tavern), Amherst Bulletin
- Letter: Anne Blakeslee-Chunglo, Amherst Bulletin
- 11 East Pleasant redevelopment plans (2021), Amherst Bulletin
- 'That's our thing, staying involved with the community': The Pub to shut its doors after 52 years in Amherst (MassLive, reposted), MassLive
- 11 East Pleasant Apartments, PMA Consultants
The gift shop
The The Pub sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Pub pieces











