The Pirate Ship
The Pirate Ship, a ship-themed bar on North Fairchild Street, had Doc DeHaven's jazz combo in its loft and later became a gay bar, until 1982.
- Where
- 116 N. Fairchild Street, off Capitol Square, Madison, Wisconsin
- Kind
- LGBTQ bar
- Open
- 1957–1982
- Known for
- Nautical tavern with a jazz loft, later a gay bar
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

A nautical tavern on North Fairchild Street
The Pirate Ship opened in 1957 at 116 North Fairchild Street, a short walk off Capitol Square in downtown Madison. Inside it was dressed as a ship: dark wood panelling, rope rigging, fishing nets, portholes and lanterns, murals on the walls, and a balcony built to look like a ship's bridge. In 1973 it shared the block with Regis Beauty Salon and Webers Pastry Kitchen, with Miller's International Market and the Madison Community Center close by.
Doc DeHaven's combo in the loft
For most Madisonians the Pirate Ship meant Doc DeHaven. Doster DeHaven Jr., a trumpeter, had started his first band in 1951 while studying at the University of Wisconsin. After graduating he took a regular job at the Pirate Ship, and his traditional jazz combo held the room for years. The Capital Times gave his run as three nights a week from 1957 to 1970; Isthmus remembered it as three or four nights a week for 14 years in the 1960s and 1970s. The band played from the loft above the bar.
DeHaven later formed the band Third Generation with his children and taught at Monona Grove High School, where he was band director until 1989. He died in August 2016 at 85.
“He liked playing at the Pirate Ship because he was up in a loft and didn't have to be seen.”
Gay nights from around 1970
When DeHaven's long run ended, the Pirate Ship found a new crowd. According to the Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project, new owners at the Velvet Swing on West Gorham Street had turned against their gay customers, and a group went looking for a new home bar. The Pirate Ship agreed to give them a chance to prove the idea worthwhile, and the next weekend more than 200 gay men filled it. Sources date the change differently, from about 1969 to about 1972.
From then on it was a downtown workers' tavern by day and a gay bar by night, with an older clientele. A 1976 gay guide described it as a large downtown bar with rustic decor. Regulars remembered a bartender, Patty Rupp, who looked after her customers with a fierce temper. The bar closed early, around midnight, and those who had not paired off often gathered in the back parking lot before moving on to someone's house. It hosted fundraisers too: a euchre party on December 7, 1980 raised money for a volleyball team. It last appeared in a gay bar directory in mid-1982.
Lundeen's, Dotty Dumpling's Dowry and the Overture Center
The Pirate Ship closed in 1982. The space became Lundeen's, another bar, and then Dotty Dumpling's Dowry, the burger restaurant. When the city cleared the block for the Overture Center, it took Dotty's Fairchild Street location by eminent domain, and the restaurant left in 2001. The building was demolished for the arts centre, and Dotty's reopened on North Frances Street.
Sources
- Pirate Ship, Wisconsin LGBTQ History Project
- Pirate Ship (Bars and Clubs archive), History of Gay and Lesbian Life in Wisconsin
- Local jazz giant Doc DeHaven passed away, Isthmus, August 19, 2016
- Doster 'Doc' DeHaven, 85 (Capital Times obituary, reprinted), Jazz Promo Services, August 2016
- Regis Beauty Salon, The Pirate Ship, and Webers Pastry Kitchen (Bruce Garner, 1973), Wisconsin Historical Society
- Hamburger king Stanley opens new Dotty Dumpling's Dowry, The Daily Cardinal, October 2003
- Dotty Dumpling's Dowry reopens, The Badger Herald
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of The Pirate Ship.
Share a memory of The Pirate Ship
The gift shop
The The Pirate Ship sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All The Pirate Ship pieces



