Skip to content

Madhatter

The UW-Madison student bar known for Friday After Class: two decades in University Square, two years without a home, then 328 W. Gorham Street until May 2017.

Where
328 W. Gorham Street, Madison, Wisconsin (originally 3 University Square, University Avenue at Lake Street)
Open
1986–2017
Known for
UW-Madison student bar known for its Friday After Class pitchers
Reading time
3 minutes
The Madhatter sign, redrawn
The Madhatter sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

The Madhatter in University Square

University Square was a single-storey shopping centre of about 60,000 square feet on the south side of the 700 block of University Avenue, at the edge of the University of Wisconsin campus. Its four-screen cinema, the University Square Four, opened in May 1975. Over the years the centre also held the Discount Den, a B. Dalton bookstore and the longest-running location of Paisan's Italian restaurant. The Madhatter's address there was 3 University Square.

Nobody has pinned down the opening date. The Wisconsin Alumni Association, answering a reader's question about the name, said the year was hard to establish and that the bar turns up in the UW yearbook by 1990. The Daily Cardinal reported in 2016 that it had been in business since 1986. Ted Gervasi, the owner, was described in 2007 and 2008 as having run it for 20 years. Student papers called it Madhatters or Madhatter's as often as Madhatter.

Friday After Class and the student crowd

The bar's best-known custom was Friday After Class, or FAC, a drink special that started in the afternoon. When the Badger Herald reviewed the reopened bar in 2008, FAC ran from 4 to 9 p.m. with $3 pitchers and $4 double Captain Morgan mixers, and Wednesday was service industry night, with half-price drinks for people who worked in bars and restaurants. The crowd was undergraduates of drinking age and recent graduates, and the lines from Thursday through Saturday were long.

“Madhatter had a good run.”

Losing the lease and two years without a bar

In 2001 the owners of University Square announced that the centre would be replaced by a multistorey building. Sources give different dates for the Madhatter's last night there. The Daily Cardinal twice wrote that it left in 2005. A June 2008 report carried by the university's news clipsheet said it closed in June 2006, and Isthmus and On Wisconsin magazine also date the end of the lease and the centre to 2006. The plan for the site included an apartment building, the Lucky, and university offices, and a May 2009 photograph shows the Lucky standing there.

Gervasi spent two years looking for a room. In September 2007 the city's Alcohol License Review Committee recommended moving his licence to 651 State Street, a former Fuddruckers, with a capacity of 150 and a requirement to serve food. The Capitol Neighborhood Association opposed it, and Gervasi withdrew the application days before the City Council was due to vote, saying he did not feel welcome on State Street.

A tall brick and glass apartment building with a red letter U near the roofline, seen through bare trees across a plaza with globe lamps
The Lucky apartments in the rebuilt University Square, on the site of the shopping centre where the Madhatter began, in May 2009.Photo: James Steakley, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Reopening at 328 W. Gorham Street in 2008

The committee approved a licence for 328 W. Gorham Street in May 2008 and the council adopted it in early June. The Madhatter reopened there in September, across the street from Quinton's Bar and Deli, next door to Silver Mine Subs and directly below the offices of the Badger Herald.

The new bar had two floors. Upstairs was an island bar in the middle of the room with tables and chairs along the walls and nine flat-screen televisions. The lower level had four more. The Daily Cardinal's reviewers noted exposed high ceilings, ironwork, large windows and a moose head near the front door, and warned that the sign was small and easy to walk past. There was no kitchen. Bartenders handed out the Silver Mine menu, and the sandwiches came from next door.

The licence carried over the old room's limit of 200 people, although the building was much larger. In 2014 Gervasi asked the city to raise the limit to 320 and proposed adding a kitchen in the former sub shop, which had closed by then.

The 2017 sale and Danny's Pub

In January 2016 the city suspended the bar's alcohol licence for 15 days, and the following month the committee approved the transfer of the licence to the bar's general manager. In 2017 the business was sold. Isthmus reported on April 20, 2017, that the Madhatter would close in May after about 30 years and that Brano Kruger, general manager of the Red Rock Saloon, was buying it.

Kruger remodelled the space, joined it to the old Silver Mine storefront, put in a kitchen and opened Danny's Pub, an Irish bar, in September 2017.

Sources

  1. Irish pub to replace Madhatter, Isthmus
  2. Which came first: the MadHatters a cappella group, or the Madhatter bar?, Wisconsin Alumni Association
  3. University Square Shopping Center, On Wisconsin
  4. These 15 Madison bars are gone, but not forgotten, Madison Magazine
  5. Students go 'Mad' for reopened bar, The Daily Cardinal
  6. Madhatter, The Badger Herald
  7. Madhatters finds a new home on Gorham Street, UW-Madison Clipsheet
  8. Old bar won't get new location, The Badger Herald
  9. Madhatters owner withdraws from moving bar onto State St., The Daily Cardinal
  10. City's alcohol licensing committee discusses plans for Madhatter's bar renovations, The Daily Cardinal
  11. New Madhatter Bar owner excited to reopen, The Daily Cardinal
  12. Alcohol License Review Committee approves new Madhatter Bar owner, The Daily Cardinal
  13. Skip the airport lines: Irish pubs in Madison that will save you a plane ticket, The Badger Herald

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Madhatter.

Share a memory of Madhatter

The gift shop

The Madhatter sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Madhatter pieces