The Coffee Shop
Three former models turned a Greek diner on Union Square West into a Brazilian-American restaurant and bar that stayed open 23 hours a day for 28 years.
- Where
- 29 Union Square West at 16th Street, Union Square, New York
- Open
- 1990–2018
- Known for
- Brazilian-American diner and bar under a neon Coffee Shop sign, open 23 hours a day
- Reading time
- 4 minutes


Three models take over a Union Square diner in 1990
The Coffee Shop opened in 1990 at 29 Union Square West, on the corner of 16th Street. Its three owners, Charles Milite, Eric Petterson and Carolyn Benitez, had all been models with the Wilhelmina agency. The room they took had been an ordinary diner. Richard Brookhiser, who lived nearby, remembered it in City Journal as Nick's Coffee Shop, a Greek diner with a counter, and Grub Street named the earlier owner as Nick Sidorakis. Eater's Robert Sietsema gave the old place's name as Chase, so the sources do not agree on what it was called.
The new owners enlarged the space, put a lounge in the basement and set tables on the sidewalk in warm weather. According to Grub Street they added green vinyl booths and a long snaking bar, and kept the chrome trim and heavy mugs that came with the diner. Union Square was a rougher place then. Sietsema wrote that people were still wary of crossing the park at midnight when the restaurant arrived on what he called a lonely corner.

The neon Coffee Shop sign at 16th Street
The restaurant took its name from the sign it inherited. A tall neon blade sign reading COFFEE SHOP climbed the corner of the building, and the owners left it up rather than put up one of their own. Sietsema thought it was probably one of the first restaurants to borrow the identity of the business it replaced. The red letters and the building's blue enamel panels made the corner easy to pick out from across the square. A panel reading BAR, ringed with light bulbs, sat at the foot of the sign.
“The times have changed in our industry. The rents are very high and now the minimum wage is going up and we have a huge number of employees.”

Caipirinhas, shrimp Baiano and breakfast 23 hours a day
The menu read like a diner's, with hamburgers and egg breakfasts, and then turned Brazilian. Early menus offered caipirinhas, coconut shrimp and guava crepes. Sietsema's favourite dish was the shrimp Baiano, a red, garlicky stew served with an orange slice and sauteed kale, and he recalled feijoada and the cheese rolls called pao de queijo among the specials. The kitchen served breakfast at any hour, and the place was open 23 hours a day. Punch credited the bar with helping to make the mojito and the caipirinha popular in New York.
Later a yellow shed on the 16th Street side sold fresh juices. The restaurant appeared in several episodes of Sex and the City and in the film The Devil Wears Prada. In 2015 the owners announced a taco offshoot next door, and Petterson told Eater that he had nine years left on his lease.
The staff: models, actors and a future congresswoman
From the start the fashion trade adopted the place. Grub Street reported that it made the cover of Women's Wear Daily soon after opening, and that a New York magazine profile of its late nights named the designer Isaac Mizrahi and the actor Kevin Bacon among the crowd. In the odd hours the same room served beat cops and cab drivers.
The staff drew as much notice as the customers. Benitez did the hiring, and the waitresses in black were widely rumoured to be models between jobs. Punch's oral history of the restaurant lists Maya Rudolph, the singer Maxwell and the actor Boyd Holbrook among former employees. Laverne Cox wrote when the closing was announced that she had spent ten years waiting tables there. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez was a server until shortly before she won her congressional primary in 2018. Renee Rein was general manager from 1999 to 2015, and the head maitre d', Julie da Rocha, ran the seating system that decided who got which booth.
Why The Coffee Shop closed in October 2018
Staff were told on July 12, 2018 that the restaurant would close that autumn. Milite, the co-owner and president, pointed to rent and a coming rise in the minimum wage. amNewYork, citing Forbes, reported that the restaurant took in about $14.3 million in 2017, enough to rank among the 100 highest-grossing independent restaurants in the country, and still could not break even. Milite said rent took 27 percent of gross revenue and that the $2-an-hour wage rise would have added $46,000 a month to the payroll. A former co-chair of the Union Square Community Coalition told the same paper that one of the owners was also moving out of the city.
The last day was Sunday, October 14, 2018. Gothamist's photographer found a closing party with dancers that was meant to end at 6 p.m. and ran to about 7. Customers photographed the neon sign, the pay phones by the bathrooms and their usual booths, and some left with menus.
What is at 29 Union Square West now
Two chains divided the space. A Chase bank branch took part of it, and the vegan chain By Chloe opened in the former back dining room on December 12, 2019, with diner-style booths meant as a nod to the old tenant. The neon sign came down from the corner when the new tenants moved in. By Chloe's publicist told Gothamist that the company did not know what had become of it and assumed the restaurant's owners had dealt with it.
Sources
- A Farewell to Coffee Shop, a Union Square Icon Closing on Sunday, Eater NY
- Union Square's Iconic Coffee Shop Will Close, Grub Street
- End Of An Era: Photos From The Coffee Shop's Final Day, Gothamist
- Vegan Chain By CHLOE Opens In Former Coffee Shop Space In USQ, Gothamist
- Digesting the loss of The Coffee Shop, amNewYork
- Sex, Drugs and Mojitos: The Coffee Shop Story, Punch
- My Union Square, City Journal
- Coffee Shop Team to Open Next Door Spinoff, Taco Shop, Eater NY
- Union Square Coffee Shop closing, Spectrum News NY1
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of The Coffee Shop.
Share a memory of The Coffee Shop
The gift shop
The The Coffee Shop sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Coffee Shop pieces



