The Caliph
The Moorish-themed piano bar at 3100 Fifth Avenue that opened in 1960 and spent its last decades as a gay piano and karaoke bar until New Year's Eve 2018.
- Where
- 3100 Fifth Avenue, on the edge of Hillcrest and Bankers Hill, San Diego
- Open
- 1960–2018
- Known for
- Gay piano and karaoke bar on upper Fifth Avenue
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

Opening on Fifth Avenue in 1960
The Caliph opened in 1960 at 3100 Fifth Avenue, a corner that some writers place in Hillcrest and others in Bankers Hill. According to Martin Lindsay's Classic San Diego, it was opened by four brothers, Al, Frank, Nick and Vincent Desanti, who also ran the Lamplighter and Big Al's, and they reportedly spent $35,000 on a plush bar with a Moorish theme. Charley Cannon played the piano. The columnist Frank Rhoades described it as the upper Fifth Avenue bar where so many professional men hung out. Classic San Diego gives 1959 as its first year in one listing and 1960 in another; SanDiegoVille and the San Diego Reader both put the opening in 1960.
The room and the piano
It was a small place. Chad Deal of the San Diego Reader, who wrote about it in 2017, described a hole-in-the-wall piano lounge with Moorish windows, a curved bar, a disco ball, rope lights and a tiny tiled dance floor, with room for about 90 people.
Kenny Ard, a pianist from New Orleans, first played there in the late 1980s, when Hillcrest was growing into the centre of gay life in San Diego, and back then, he told Deal, there was a real piano behind the bar. By 2017 the piano parts came from a MIDI backing track, but live players still worked the room most nights: Carol Curtis on Mondays, Ard on Wednesdays, Kevin McCulley and Ria Carey on Fridays, Don LeMaster on Saturdays. Karaoke filled other afternoons and nights, Sunday brought DJs, and the popcorn was free.
Frank Slay, who wrote the song Silhouettes, lived in the penthouse next door and drank at the bar. Regulars also remembered a dalmatian named Bonnie who sat in a corner booth in a handkerchief with a cocktail in front of her.
“I always wanted it to be all-inclusive — gay, straight, transgender, young, old, men, women.”
A gay bar for an older crowd
Warren Phillips bought the Caliph in the 1980s, and Sherman Mendoza took it over in 2003. In its later decades it was known as a laid-back gay bar with an older male crowd. Classic San Diego describes a secret room called Her Closet, where cross-dressing men, drag queens and transgender women could change into clothes and make-up before heading out to other bars. Mendoza said he always wanted the bar to be open to everyone, gay or straight, transgender, young or old.
PBS SoCal's EXPLORE San Diego series later made a short film about the bar, describing it as a place where everyone could come as they were and be accepted.
Why the Caliph closed
In December 2018 the bar announced it would close for good after business on New Year's Eve. The building's owners were selling, and Mendoza's 15-year lease was not renewed. SanDiegoVille reported that a developer had taken over 3100 Fifth Avenue with plans to build housing. The last call came on December 31, 2018, after nearly 60 years.
Sources
- The Caliph Karaoke Bar Announces Impending Closure, SanDiegoVille
- There's always a full moon over the Caliph, San Diego Reader
- Classic San Diego Gay Bars and Restaurants, Classic San Diego
- In Remembrance: Classic San Diego Restaurant Closures in 2018, Classic San Diego
- The Caliph, PBS SoCal, KPBS Presents
The gift shop
The The Caliph sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Caliph pieces



