R.J. O'Toole's
R.J. O'Toole's opened at Nottingham Plaza in 1977 and at Airport Plaza in North Syracuse in 1979: a family restaurant by day and a singles dance club at night.
- Where
- 333 Nottingham Road, Nottingham Plaza, Syracuse, and 3803 Brewerton Road, Airport Plaza, North Syracuse, New York
- Open
- Opened 1977
- Known for
- Plaza restaurant that turned into a DJ dance club after 10
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

Opening at Nottingham Plaza in 1977 and Airport Plaza in 1979
R.J. O'Toole's had two locations, and its matchbooks listed both: 333 Nottingham Road in Nottingham Plaza, on the east side of Syracuse, and 3803 Brewerton Road in Airport Plaza on Route 11 in North Syracuse. A profile in the Baldwinsville Messenger in early 1985 said owner Joseph J. Downs opened the Nottingham restaurant in 1977 and the North Syracuse one in 1979.
According to that profile, Downs had been in the restaurant business since graduating from Cornell University, starting with a small college bar in Ithaca that he ran with a partner. He opened McDuff's on Onondaga Hill in 1976, the year before the first O'Toole's, and sold McDuff's and Copperfield's shortly after the second O'Toole's opened. By 1985 he was the sole owner. When the Town of DeWitt set up fire lanes at two of its shopping centers in June 1983, the Fayetteville Bulletin described the Nottingham center, at Nottingham and Tecumseh roads, as home to R.J. O'Toole's and several smaller businesses.
Family restaurant by day, singles dance club after 10
The Messenger described a business that changed character through the day. Until early evening O'Toole's was a moderately priced family restaurant. A disc jockey worked seven nights a week, both locations had dance floors, and later in the night the rooms took on what the paper called a nightclub flair for young singles. Downs treated them as two separate services under one roof.
The profile reported that Empire magazine had voted O'Toole's the best burger in town and the best singles bar around three years running. Downs said he had gone to Buffalo himself to work out his recipe for Buffalo-style wings, and that the two restaurants together sold more than half a ton of them a week. In 1984 the Airport Plaza location added a salad bar with more than 70 items, two soups made in the kitchen each day and one hot entree.
The North Syracuse restaurant ran buses to every Syracuse University home football and basketball game. O'Toole's also sponsored basketball and volleyball teams, and a softball team playing as R.J. O'Toole's of Syracuse turned up in a tournament reported by the Medina Daily Register-Journal in May 1988. When the Nottingham location marked its seventh anniversary, both restaurants spent a week offering what the Messenger called old time items at old time prices.
“We do a lot of business with S.U. fans, both before and after the games.”
Where the record of R.J. O'Toole's runs out
In the 1985 profile Downs said a third site had already been chosen in the Fairmount area. No later report of a Fairmount opening was found. R.J. O'Toole's was listed among Greater North Syracuse Chamber of Commerce members in 1986 and 1987, and in July 1995 a Baldwinsville youth soccer program thanked R.J. O'Toole's among the businesses that had donated to its picnic. That is the latest mention found.
No report of either location closing was found, so the closing year is left open here. Readers named RJ O'Tooles in syracuse.com's May 2016 poll of Syracuse bars they wished they had back. In 2018 David Buono, who ran the Syracuse disco Orpheus, listed "both R.J. O'Toole's" for Table Hopping among the clubs that filled up around town in those years, and in 2024 syracuse.com named R.J. O'Toole's among the nightclubs Central New Yorkers crowded into in the 1980s.
Sources
- R.J. O'Toole's business profile (seventh anniversary, both locations), early 1985, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
- Report on Town of DeWitt fire lanes at the Skytop and Nottingham shopping centers, summer 1983, Fayetteville Bulletin, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
- Softball tournament report naming R.J. O'Toole's of Syracuse, May 1988, Medina Daily Register-Journal, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
- Greater North Syracuse Chamber of Commerce membership list, 1986, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
- Greater North Syracuse Chamber of Commerce membership list, 1987, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
- Youth soccer picnic report thanking donors, July 19, 1995, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
- We asked, you answered: Syracuse bars we wish we had back, syracuse.com (The Post-Standard), May 6, 2016, via the Wayback Machine
- David's Hideaway: Business of Interest, Table Hopping, August 3, 2018
- Were you part of Syracuse's nightclub scene in '80s and '90s? We want to hear your stories, syracuse.com, May 4, 2024, as republished by This is CNY
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of R.J. O'Toole's.
Share a memory of R.J. O'Toole's
The gift shop
The R.J. O'Toole's sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All R.J. O'Toole's pieces



