Skip to content

The Annex

A cellar restaurant and bar at Nassau and Tulane, run by the Carnevale family from 1948, where Princeton faculty lunched until it closed on February 19, 2006.

Where
128 Nassau Street at Tulane Street, downtown Princeton, New Jersey
Open
Closed 2006
Known for
Basement restaurant and bar with a stained-glass tiger, across from campus
Reading time
2 minutes
The The Annex sign, redrawn
The The Annex sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

A basement on the corner of Nassau and Tulane

The Annex was a restaurant and bar below street level at 128 Nassau Street, on the corner of Tulane Street, facing the Princeton University campus across the road. The Daily Princetonian traced it to the early 1930s, and the Princeton Alumni Weekly gave its run as the 1930s to 2006. Nobody in the sources read here names who opened it.

The Carnevale family took it over in 1948, when it was already established, and kept it for the rest of its life. From the 1980s it was run by Rich Carnevale and his brother Joe. Rich told a reporter he had been at the place almost every day since he was nine years old.

Dark wood, a stained-glass tiger and the lunch crowd

Customers went down a set of stairs, which the Daily Princetonian warned in 2004 were tricky, into a room of dark wood panelling hung with paintings of tigers. The Alumni Weekly remembered a stained-glass roaring tiger and old photographs of Princeton football teams. Thomas Hartmann, class of 1945, said that in the 1940s the cellar made you feel you were walking into a Prohibition speakeasy. He also remembered the cooking, bluefish in particular, and prices that were reasonable.

The Annex was more a faculty and town place than a student one. Hartmann often saw the university's president at lunch there, and John McPhee, class of 1953, the Pulitzer Prize-winning writer and university professor, was a regular. Eric Johnson, class of 1969, told the Princetonian it never became a student haunt, and Amy Baldwin, class of 1984, ate there once, on a blind date. Alumni and Princeton residents kept it going.

A 2004 Princetonian guide to local bars found a small bar, a dining room for groups, a kitchen open until midnight and a quiet crowd of graduate students and older customers. Rich Carnevale's pitch was simple: come for value.

“The thing that was appealing about The Annex was its complete informality.”

Closing on February 19, 2006, and Sotto

The Annex closed quietly on February 19, 2006, after more than 70 years, and the Princetonian found its doors draped in orange and black. The closing was the family's own plan. The Carnevale brothers teamed up with their cousins John and Tino Procaccini, who ran La Principessa in Kingston, put more than $250,000 into the cellar and reopened it as Sotto 128. Sotto means under in Italian.

The new room was lined in cut stone, built to feel like a grotto, with a bar, a wine cellar, a small stage and live music from Thursday to Saturday. Rich Carnevale and John Procaccini ran the front of the house and Joe Carnevale and Tino Procaccini the kitchen.

What is at 128 Nassau Street now

Sotto did not last as long as the Annex. The Princeton Alumni Weekly later recorded that the basement had passed from Sotto to the Princeton Sports Bar and Grill, a burger and nachos place.

Sources

  1. Last call at the Annex, The Daily Princetonian, March 2006
  2. Tigers on the town: local watering holes, The Daily Princetonian, September 2004
  3. From the Annex to Sotto 128, U.S. 1 (Princeton Info)
  4. Off-campus eateries: Here today, chain tomorrow?, Princeton Alumni Weekly

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of The Annex.

Share a memory of The Annex

The gift shop

The The Annex sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All The Annex pieces