City Gardens
The Trenton club on Calhoun Street where Randy Now booked the Ramones, R.E.M. and Ween, Jon Stewart tended bar, and 90-cent dance nights kept it going.
- Where
- 1701 Calhoun Street, Trenton, New Jersey
- Open
- 1979–1999
- Known for
- Punk, hardcore and new wave club with 90-cent dance nights
- Reading time
- 3 minutes

From car dealership to nightclub on Calhoun Street
The building at 1701 Calhoun Street in Trenton started out as a Giant Tiger grocery store and from the late 1940s to the late 1960s was a car dealership called U.S. Motors, according to Wikipedia's history of the site. It later held a Bible warehouse and a furniture store before it was turned into a music venue in the mid-1970s, first under the name Chocolate City. The Nalbone family owned the building, and Frank "Tut" Nalbone ran the club.
Accounts of the start differ. Wikipedia dates the City Gardens name to early 1978, while the Princeton weekly US 1 described the late-1970s place as a jazz club called King Tut's City Garden. Most histories agree that the club as people remember it began around 1979 and 1980, when large shows started and the room could hold about 1,000 people.
Randy Now and the bands that played City Gardens
The booker was Randy Ellis, known as Randy Now, a promoter from Burlington. TrentonDaily credited him with signing more than 2,000 bands. He worked on a thin budget and, according to US 1, sometimes drove to New York himself to collect the musicians.
The Ramones played the club 22 times, Wikipedia counts, once with Blondie's Clem Burke on drums. R.E.M. played on October 2, 1982. Danzig played their first show anywhere at City Gardens on April 9, 1988, and Ween treated it as a home base, playing their first club show there as teenagers opening for the Butthole Surfers. Joan Jett, Iggy Pop, Billy Idol, the Red Hot Chili Peppers, the Dead Kennedys and the Circle Jerks were among the other names US 1 listed, and Punknews reported that Nirvana and Soundgarden also played there. Live albums were recorded in the room by Discharge, the Rollins Band, the Dickies and the Replacements.
Local bands such as Vision and 24-7 Spyz opened for the touring acts. Shows were at first restricted to 18 and over or 21 and over, and became all-ages in 1984.
“It was one of the few places you could dance by yourself.”
Thursday dance night and the people behind the bar
The club's steadiest income was its Thursday dance night, which Nalbone thought up and Randy Now began spinning in 1979. Entry cost 90 cents, rising to 95 cents in 1983 when DJ Carlos Santos took over, and later to 99 cents. At its peak it drew 700 to 1,000 people a week. US 1 reported that the dance nights kept the club going: bands always got paid, but the place often ran at a loss.
Jon Stewart tended bar at City Gardens from 1984 to 1987, and James Murphy, later of LCD Soundsystem, worked the door as an underage bouncer in the 1980s. TrentonDaily described a room that was barely kept up, with graffiti over black walls, peeling stickers and missing ceiling tiles.
Why City Gardens closed
Randy Now booked his last show at the club in December 1994. Wikipedia attributes the end of the concert years to rising insurance costs after violence and lawsuits, worn-out morale for Now and Nalbone, and the growing demands of touring bands. The building carried on as a bar with dance nights and local bands. Dates for the final closing vary: Wikipedia gives 1999, with a new club, Club XL, opening in 2000 under a lease from Nalbone, while Punknews put the end at 2001.
Club XL closed after a police raid in 2004 and the building sat empty. The city of Trenton took possession in 2016, auctioned it off, and a car crashed through a side wall in 2022. Carroll Demolition was hired in 2026 to take the building down, and it was demolished in October 2026.
The book and the film
In 2014 Amy Yates Wuelfing and Steven DiLodovico published an oral history of the club, No Slam Dancing, No Stage Diving, No Spikes, funded through Kickstarter. The same year Steve Tozzi's documentary Riot on the Dance Floor, about Randy Now and the club, premiered in New Jersey, with interviews including Henry Rollins, Jello Biafra, Ian MacKaye, Dean Ween and Jon Stewart.
Sources
- City Gardens, Wikipedia
- No Slam Dancing — And Definitely No Selfies, US 1 / Princeton Info
- City Gardens, a Little-Known Trailblazer in Its Time, TrentonDaily
- Trenton City Gardens to be torn down, Punknews.org
The gift shop
The City Gardens sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All City Gardens pieces





