Sutter's Mill & Mining Co.
Sutter's Mill & Mining Co. was a Syracuse University student bar and dance club in the alley off South Crouse Avenue, where The Marshall apartments now stand.
- Where
- South Crouse Avenue alley behind Marshall Street, University Hill, Syracuse, New York
- Known for
- Syracuse University bar and dance club above Hungry Charlie's
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

A student bar off South Crouse Avenue by the late 1970s
Sutter's Mill & Mining Co. was a bar on Syracuse University's hill, in the narrow alley off South Crouse Avenue behind Marshall Street. It sat upstairs from Hungry Charlie's, a basement bar, and the Daily Orange later described Sutter's as the dance club above Charlie's.
No source found for this article gives an opening date. Jerk Magazine's 2018 history of the Marshall Street bars places it there when Faegan's opened in 1978, naming The Orange, Hungry Charley's and Sutter's Mill as the other bars around Crouse and Marshall at the time.
Bands and the drinking age
Local bands were part of the place. The Post-Standard file photograph that syracuse.com chose for Sutter's in 2016 shows the Homel-Alaniz Band posing outside the bar.
Like the other bars near campus, it depended on undergraduates, and the law moved against that trade. New York raised its drinking age from 18 to 19 in 1982 and to 21 in 1985, changes that Jerk Magazine described as cutting the campus bars' customer base in half.
When Sutter's Mill closed, and what is there now
The closing year is not documented in the sources found. The Daily Orange's September 2002 report establishes only that Sutter's Mill and Hungry Charlie's were both gone by then.
In 2017 the four side-by-side buildings from 721 to 729 South Crouse Avenue were bought and demolished for The Marshall, an eight-story, 287-unit student apartment building. Reporting in 2024 on the closing of Shirt World on Marshall Street, CNY Central noted that high-rises like The Marshall had gone up on real estate once known for student bars such as Hungry Charlie's and Sutter's Mill.

Sources
- We asked, you answered: Syracuse bars we wish we had back, syracuse.com (The Post-Standard), May 6, 2016, via the Wayback Machine
- 'Chuck's' owners to open new restaurant on South Crouse, The Daily Orange, September 2002
- A (Bar) Hop Through History: Syracuse Edition, Jerk Magazine, April 2018
- How the construction of The Marshall 'sanitized' one of Syracuse's favorite alleyways, The NewsHouse, May 17, 2019
- Marshall Street retail fixture closing after 48 years of selling Syracuse Orange, CNY Central, October 18, 2024
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Sutter's Mill & Mining Co..
Share a memory of Sutter's Mill & Mining Co.
The gift shop
The Sutter's Mill & Mining Co. sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Sutter's Mill & Mining Co. pieces



