Skip to content

Second Chance

Opened in 1974 as Chances Are at 516 East Liberty, the Second Chance was Ann Arbor's rock club for the Ramones, Iggy Pop and Bob Seger until it closed in 1984.

Where
516 East Liberty Street, downtown Ann Arbor, Michigan
Open
1974–1984
Known for
Ann Arbor rock club where the Ramones headlined seven times
Reading time
2 minutes
The Second Chance sign, redrawn
The Second Chance sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Chances Are opens on East Liberty in 1974

The club opened in August 1974 at 516 East Liberty Street in downtown Ann Arbor, under the name Chances Are. Its retrospective website says it was busy from the start. House bands played through the week, among them Dr. Bop and the Headliners, Cheap Trick, Masquerade, Radio King, Chopper, Head East and Starcastle. Stephen Stills played in October 1974, and Bob Seger and the Silver Bullet Band followed on October 30, shortly before Seger broke nationally.

In 1976 a dispute with a Chicago business over the name forced a change, and the club became the Second Chance, known to regulars as the Chance. LocalWiki Ann Arbor names John Carver and Dave Rogers as its owners. The building also held a restaurant, the Conservatory, and a 1982 advertisement invited people to dine and dance at the Second Chance.

The Ramones headline seven times

Between 1977 and 1983 the Ramones played Ann Arbor seven times, and every one of those shows was a headlining night at the Second Chance, as Christopher Porter's history for the Ann Arbor District Library's Pulp details. The first, on March 28, 1977, had Sonic's Rendezvous Band opening. WCBN-FM broadcast and recorded the February 26, 1979 show, which has circulated as a bootleg ever since. Nikki and the Corvettes shared the bill on December 4, 1979, and a full 68-minute set from October 5, 1981 survives on audio and video. Their last Ann Arbor show was in June 1983.

Margaret Clare, a waitress at the club, remembered the band spending the afternoon before one show playing pinball across the street with their girlfriends.

James Brown, Chuck Berry and the Stray Cats

The club's own list of dates shows how wide the bookings ran. James Brown played on July 1, 1980. In 1981 alone came Chuck Berry on January 12, Jerry Lee Lewis on February 2, Junior Walker and the All-Stars, John Kay and Steppenwolf, Iggy Pop on September 24, the Ramones, Cheap Trick on October 6, the Commander Cody Band, George Thorogood and the Destroyers and, on November 18, the Stray Cats. The Kingbees and the Four Tops followed in 1982.

Local bands had the stage too. The Detroit Punk Archive notes that Destroy All Monsters and Sonic's Rendezvous Band played there often, its flyers show Flirt and the Denizens on Second Chance bills between 1978 and 1982, and it names the Sillies among the club's headliners. People who went have recalled Billy Idol and Duran Duran shows, and Frank Zappa getting up to jam after a concert.

From the Second Chance to the Nectarine Ballroom

Some of the last bookings under the old name were David Crosby on April 3, 1984 and The Band a week later. The underground paper Not Bored reported that spring that the rock club would close for good on April 30, and that a month later it would reopen as the Nectarine Ballroom, a fashionable dance club with disc jockeys, video screens and a new floor and sound system. The club's history site says it closed for remodelling that spring and reopened in July under the same management.

Live bands carried on at the Nectarine for several more years: Divine in 1985, Cab Calloway in 1987, Soul Asylum in 1988. The live era ended with Happy Trails on April 6, 1991, a night with Fred Smith, Patti Smith, Lenny Kaye, Jay Dee Daugherty and Scott Morgan. The remaining original owners sold the Nectarine in 1996, and the room was remodelled into a smaller dance club, the Necto, which still trades at 516 East Liberty.

Tan brick front with a tall arched window over a doorway, an orange Necto sign above the glass doors and snow along the curb
The entrance at 516 East Liberty Street in December 2010, when the former Second Chance building housed the Necto.Photo: Dwight Burdette, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Sources

  1. Second Chance, LocalWiki Ann Arbor
  2. Chances Are / Second Chance / Nectarine Ballroom history, secondchanceannarbor.com
  3. Gabba gabba, we accept you, one of us: A history of The Ramones in Ann Arbor (Christopher Porter), Pulp, Ann Arbor District Library
  4. Second Chance, Detroit Punk Archive

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Second Chance.

Share a memory of Second Chance

The gift shop

The Second Chance sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All Second Chance pieces