Skip to content

Scratch Daniel's

Scratch Daniel's, billed as An American Bar, poured drinks and served Sunday brunch at 163 East Onondaga Street in downtown Syracuse in the 1970s and 1980s.

Where
163 East Onondaga Street at South Warren Street, downtown Syracuse, New York
Known for
Downtown bar and restaurant across from the Hotel Syracuse
Reading time
2 minutes
The Scratch Daniel's sign, redrawn
The Scratch Daniel's sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

163 East Onondaga Street, across from the Hotel Syracuse

Scratch Daniel's stood at 163 East Onondaga Street, on the corner of South Warren Street in downtown Syracuse. The Hotel Syracuse was across the street. The bar's matchbooks and its newspaper advertisements carried the name with the line "An American Bar." In the ads the name ran on two curved banners above and below that line.

The address had been a bar before. Help-wanted notices in the Post-Standard in 1971 sought a barmaid for the Canterbury Inn at 163 East Onondaga, and in 1975 the paper reported that the State Liquor Authority had cancelled the license held at that address under the Canterbury name.

The earliest mention of Scratch Daniel's found is from 1977. A Baldwinsville Messenger business column about a Cicero awning company pointed readers to two recent jobs: one at a restaurant on Route 11 and one at Scratch Daniel's, across from the Hotel Syracuse. That puts the opening after the Canterbury's license was cancelled in 1975 and no later than 1977. No opening announcement was found.

Sunday brunch, 80 seats and a staff of about 40

It was a restaurant as much as a bar. An advertisement in the Cazenovia Republican on July 19, 1978 promised "The Best Brunch You Ever Ate," served every Sunday from 11:30 a.m. until 2:30 p.m., and gave the telephone number as 422-8888.

A profile of the restaurant's manager in the Olean Times Herald in December 1979 said the dining room seated 80 and that she supervised about 40 employees. A 1982 wedding notice gave the business name as Scratch Daniels, Ltd.

The bar's basketball and softball teams in DeWitt

Much of what survives in print is in the sports agate of the Fayetteville Bulletin. Scratch Daniel's teams appear in the DeWitt recreation league standings from 1979. Its softball team started the 1981 season badly, losing one game in May 17 to 1.

The basketball team did better. In 1981 the Bulletin reported that Scratch Daniel's had finished 7 and 0 and taken both the league and playoff titles in the DeWitt Adult Men's Basketball League, with Burger King the runner-up.

The mid-1980s, where the record runs out

From 1983 through January 1985 Scratch Daniel's appeared in newspaper advertisements listing the bars and restaurants in the I'm Smart program, which sent a professional driver to take a customer home in the customer's own car at a special rate of $18. The January 30, 1985 list is the latest dated reference to the bar that was found.

When and why Scratch Daniel's closed is not documented in the sources found, and neither is what took over the corner. When syracuse.com asked readers in May 2016 which former Syracuse bars they wished they had back, Scratch Daniel's was among those named. The caption on the Post-Standard file photograph that ran with the list places it at the corner of East Onondaga and South Warren streets.

Sources

  1. We asked, you answered: Syracuse bars we wish we had back, syracuse.com (The Post-Standard), May 6, 2016, via the Wayback Machine
  2. Scratch Daniel's advertisement: "The Best Brunch You Ever Ate," July 19, 1978, Cazenovia Republican, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  3. A touch of shade: The Awning Mart, 1977, Baldwinsville Messenger, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  4. Is Former Olean Resident Heading For The 'Big Time'?, December 26, 1979, Olean Times Herald, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  5. Classified advertising: Canterbury Inn, 163 E. Onondaga St., 1971, Syracuse Post-Standard, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  6. State Liquor Authority notice for 163 E. Onondaga St., 1975, Syracuse Post-Standard, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  7. DeWitt Adult Men's Basketball League champions, 1981, Fayetteville Bulletin, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  8. DeWitt softball standings and scores, May 1981, Fayetteville Bulletin, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  9. DeWitt recreation league standings, 1979, Fayetteville Bulletin, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  10. Wedding notice naming Scratch Daniels, Ltd., 1982, Chittenango-Bridgeport Times, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  11. "What makes these places so smart?" I'm Smart member establishments advertisement, 1983, Fayetteville Bulletin, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards
  12. I'm Smart member establishments advertisement, January 30, 1985, Fayetteville Bulletin, via Old Fulton NY Post Cards

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Scratch Daniel's.

Share a memory of Scratch Daniel's

The gift shop

The Scratch Daniel's sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Scratch Daniel's pieces