Rodeo Bar
Rodeo Bar put on free country, rockabilly and Americana shows at Third Avenue and East 27th Street from 1987 until rising rent closed it in July 2014.
- Where
- 375 Third Avenue at East 27th Street, Kips Bay, New York
- Open
- 1987–2014
- Known for
- Free honky-tonk shows under a stuffed buffalo
- Reading time
- 4 minutes

A Texas roadhouse on Third Avenue at 27th Street
Rodeo Bar & Grill stood at 375 Third Avenue, on the corner of East 27th Street in Kips Bay, and billed itself as New York City's longest running honky-tonk. It was a two-storey room done up as a Texas roadhouse, with a central bar, an upstairs lounge that Time Out described as a quieter place to sit, barbecue and burgers on the menu, and a band on stage every night of the week.
The opening year depends on who is counting. When the bar announced its closing in July 2014 it said it had been in business for 27 years, and Pollstar and the Vanishing New York blog both gave 1987. DNAinfo's report of the closing, and the music blog Will You Miss Me When I'm Gone?, put the opening in 1985. The man who owned it at the end told The New York Times that he had bought the bar in 1996, so it had at least one earlier owner.
The stuffed buffalo, the horse trailer bar and peanut shells on the floor
A writer for the Midtown Lunch blog who went for happy hour in August 2009 set down what the room looked like. A taxidermy buffalo stood on a ledge above the bar. The bar top was covered with Texas licence plates from the 1940s to the 1970s. Vintage tin signs and rock and roll memorabilia hung on the walls, and the light came from antler chandeliers. In the back, a horse trailer had been converted into a second bar. Baskets of roasted peanuts sat on the tables, and the shells piled up on the floor.
Time Out's listing noted the same antler chandeliers and the stuffed bison above the crowd, along with eight kinds of margarita, pomegranate and prickly pear among them.
The buffalo and the trailer were part of how the bar talked about itself. Its farewell letter spoke of the horse trailer "we call home" and was signed "Until the Buffalo Sings". For many years, according to Will You Miss Me When I'm Gone?, it was practically the only place in Manhattan that poured Shiner Bock, the Texas beer, and the bar claimed to have been the first in the city to offer it.
“It's ironic that just as this music has become bigger than it ever was, Rodeo had to close.”
Country, rockabilly and Americana bands with no cover charge
The music was free. The bar's closing letter said there had never been a cover charge, that thousands of bands had played the room, and that the place had helped define the country, Americana and rockabilly scene in New York City. Midtown Lunch found country and rock and roll bands on stage seven nights a week, usually starting around 10 p.m.
Pollstar named Dale Watson, Wayne Hancock and Charlie Louvin among the acts the bar brought in. The writer of Will You Miss Me When I'm Gone? listed Big Sandy and His Fly-Rite Boys, Ronnie Dawson, Rosie Flores, Simon & the Bar Sinisters, the Susquehanna Industrial Tool & Die Co. and the M Shanghai String Band among those it booked regularly, and wrote that Joan Osborne got noticed with a Monday-night residency there. A photograph from May 2007 shows the Texas fiddler Elana James and her trio on the small brick-walled stage, in front of a framed picture of Elvis Presley and an old tin sign.

The neon Rodeo sign
Outside, a vertical neon sign hung from the brick wall of the building. A photograph taken in October 2012 shows it lit at night: the letters of RODEO stacked one above another in red, a yellow line running around them, three small cocktail glasses in blue-green tubing up the outer edge, and at the foot a rounded box reading BAR & GRILL.

Why Rodeo Bar closed in July 2014
On July 10, 2014 the bar announced on Facebook that it would close at the end of the month. The letter said it had stayed open through Hurricane Sandy, the 2003 blackout and September 11, but that recent rent increases, "combined with a changing landscape", had made it impossible to go on. Word had already got around among musicians, because regular performers had been told they would not be booked again.
The owner gave The New York Times the figures. Rent and insurance had averaged $10,000 a month when he bought the bar in 1996, and had reached almost $50,000. He told the paper that the neighbourhood had changed while the bar had not, that younger customers were going to sports bars, and that chain stores had made the block feel sterile. He told Will You Miss Me When I'm Gone? that he had been losing money for a long time, and that he was not sure free live music in Manhattan could still work if the bands were to be paid.
The bar promised free music every night until the end. The Eugene Chrysler Band was booked for Saturday, July 26, and a last show hosted by the Dirty Water Dogs was announced for the Sunday. By that Sunday, EV Grieve reported, the bar's Facebook page said the previous night had been the last. Pollstar, citing the Times, wrote that people at the final night were buying the knickknacks off the walls.
What is at 375 Third Avenue now
The storefront was listed at an asking rent of $58,333 a month, and a year after the closing EV Grieve found it still empty. In January 2016 the owners of two East Village bars, Phebe's and Penny Farthing, were reported to be taking the space, and in June 2016 the Commercial Observer reported a 15-year lease on 7,150 square feet across the cellar and three floors, for a place to be called the Gem Saloon.
DNAinfo visited that October and found contractors putting in new woodwork and a new front, with the layout kept much as it had been: a central bar with a mezzanine above. The manager described a pub in the manner of Penny Farthing, with food and sports on television. By December 1, 2016 the neon sign had been taken off the building. EV Grieve wrote that its fate was unknown, and that the Gem Saloon was expected to open on January 4.
Sources
- Rodeo Bar is closing; last show set for July 26, EV Grieve
- [Updated] The Rodeo Bar closes for good after Sunday, EV Grieve
- Rodeo Bar Will Close by End of July After Nearly 30 Years, Owner Says, DNAinfo New York
- Update: Rodeo Bar announces shutdown, Will You Miss Me When I'm Gone?
- Rodeo Bar Closes, Pollstar
- Rodeo Bar, Jeremiah's Vanishing New York
- Midtown Happy Hour: Rodeo Bar is Proof We Will Go Anywhere for Free Nachos, Midtown Lunch
- Rodeo Bar & Grill (closed), Time Out New York
- 1 year after closing, the Rodeo Bar space remains vacant on 3rd Avenue, EV Grieve
- Report: Owners of Phebe's and Penny Farthing are reopening the Rodeo Bar on 3rd Avenue, EV Grieve
- Old Rodeo Bar Space Gets a New Restaurant, Commercial Observer
- Saloon Taking Over Rodeo Bar Will Open Before Holidays, Manager Says, DNAinfo New York
- A look at the former Rodeo Bar, currrently being transformed into the Gem Saloon, EV Grieve
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Rodeo Bar.
Share a memory of Rodeo Bar
The gift shop
The Rodeo Bar sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Rodeo Bar pieces

