Skip to content

Pufferbellies

John Morgan opened Pufferbellies on May 8, 1981 in a brick railroad roundhouse off Route 28 in Hyannis. It held 1,500 and was sold for ferry parking in 2015.

Where
183 Iyannough Road (Route 28), Hyannis, Massachusetts
Open
Opened 1981
Known for
Cape Cod dance club in a railroad roundhouse
Reading time
2 minutes
The Pufferbellies sign, redrawn
The Pufferbellies sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

A New Haven railroad roundhouse in Hyannis

The building was an eight-stall brick roundhouse built for the New York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad, with an 80-foot turntable in front of it, just north of the Hyannis depot. Its age depends on the source: the National Railway Historical Society's roundhouse survey gives 1901, CapeCod.com says about 1900, and the Cape historian Christopher Setterlund gives 1895. Setterlund writes that its walls were laid double-thick to deaden the noise of the engines, which later suited a nightclub.

The line passed to Penn Central, which went bankrupt in 1970, and its land around Hyannis sat in limbo for years. In late 1980 John Morgan, a Cape entertainer known for his happy hours, bought the roundhouse from the Eldredge and Bourne Moving Company for $100,000.

Long curved brick roundhouse with blue-boarded windows and doors, a red awning over the entrance at left and an empty parking lot in front
The Pufferbellies roundhouse in Hyannis on June 15, 2013, with the club's red awning over the entrance.Photo: Ktr101, derivative work by Pi.1415926535, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Opening night, May 8, 1981

Morgan proposed a 700-seat restaurant and club in early 1981 and named it Pufferbellies, an old name for a steam engine. It opened on May 8, 1981. The room held 1,500 people, with a stage, three bars and an outdoor volleyball court, and an outdoor dining permit followed in 1983.

Morgan bought a thousand radio ads on WCOD and WKPE, put together by the DJ Gary Titus, so that listeners heard about Pufferbellies twice an hour. His staff of about a hundred wore Oxford shirts with the club's name stitched on them. He stocked only Budweiser and bought it by the tractor-trailer, 2,300 cases at a time, and on busy days the club filled with 1,500 people for the afternoon, emptied, and filled again at night. The drinking age was 18 when it opened. The Boston band the Freeze and 'Weird Al' Yankovic played there early on; later bills included Blue Oyster Cult, Sevendust and Powerman 5000.

“We knew it would be a home run, but it turned out to be a Grand Slam.”

Selling up, buying back and two nights a week

After five seasons Morgan was worn out, and in 1986 he sold Pufferbellies to Peter and Jeanne White, owners of the Boston Fish House, for $3.1 million. Within a few years he had bought it back. By then tougher liquor-liability laws and drunk-driving penalties were thinning the crowds, and for most of the 1990s the club opened only two nights a week. In 2001 Morgan put business at a twentieth of what it had been in the 1980s. His ideas for using the roundhouse for weddings and conventions never came to pass.

Ferry parking and the last summers

At the end of May 2015 Morgan sold the 2.36-acre property to Hy-Line Cruises, which runs ferries from Hyannis to Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard, for $1.9 million by CapeCod.com's figure ($1.96 million in Setterlund's account). Hy-Line wanted the lot for 150 to 200 parking spaces for its passengers. The club had two years left on its lease and was to run that summer, with the option of one more. No source found for this article records its last night.

In 2019 Hy-Line applied to demolish the roundhouse, which is on the Massachusetts State Register of Historic Places, then withdrew the application to look at ways of saving it. By then the lot around it was off-site ferry parking. The railroad society's survey, last checked in June 2024, listed the building as abandoned, with a damaged roof and the outline of the turntable pit still visible in the paving.

John Morgan died on August 27, 2024, at 80. A memorial bench in his name was dedicated in April 2025 at the Hyannis Transportation Center on Iyannough Road, a short walk from the roundhouse.

Sources

  1. John Morgan and Pufferbellies: In Their Footsteps - Cape Cod History, Christopher Setterlund, March 29, 2025
  2. Hy-Line Purchases Pufferbellies for Additional Ferry Parking, CapeCod.com, June 9, 2015
  3. News Elsewhere: Pufferbellies Nightclub in Hyannis to Be Replaced by a Ferry Parking Lot, Boston Restaurant Talk, June 12, 2015
  4. Historic Hyannis Building Spared From Demolition, Patch, September 19, 2019
  5. Extant Roundhouse Listing HRSS MA-06 RH (Hyannis), National Railway Historical Society

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Pufferbellies.

Share a memory of Pufferbellies

The gift shop

The Pufferbellies sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All Pufferbellies pieces