Phil Smidt's
Phil and Marie Smidt missed their train at Roby in 1910 and opened a fish house. Their perch and frog legs drew the Calumet Region for 97 years, until 2007.
- Where
- 1205 N. Calumet Avenue, Roby, Hammond, Indiana
- Open
- 1910–2007
- Known for
- Fish house and bar for boned and buttered perch and frog legs
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

Missing the train at Roby in 1910
In 1910 Phil Smidt and his wife, Marie, were on their way to California. When the train stopped at Roby, on the Indiana shore of Lake Michigan, to take on water, they got off thinking they had reached Chicago, where they were to change trains. The train left without them. They stayed, borrowed $600 and opened a small fish house near Five Points, a resort area of the time. It seated twelve, with a bar and a boat livery, and a big lit-up fish sign with the name Smidt's stood on the roof of the wooden building.
Marie's pan-fried perch made the place. It was all you could eat: perch with vegetables and rye bread for 40 cents, and Utah Brau as the house beer.

Pete and Irene Smidt and the 1945 explosion
By the late 1920s the next generation, Pete and Irene Smidt, were running the business. Irene trained the waitresses, and Pete was known for his fishing and hunting stories. During the Second World War James Cagney held a war bond rally at the restaurant. Babe Ruth, Jack Dempsey, Gene Tunney, Mayor Richard J. Daley and Bob Hope were among the other famous diners remembered there.
In 1945 an underground gas pipe exploded and destroyed the restaurant, killing two customers and injuring nineteen. Pete and Irene reopened in the former Lundgren's Restaurant at Calumet Avenue and Railroad Street, at the far north end of Calumet Avenue, across from the tracks.
“I was delivering newspapers there the day it blew up. I was about 11 or 12 at the time.”
Black booths, pink roses and the Rose Room
The Calumet Avenue building was the one people remembered: big black booths, pink roses, waitresses in black uniforms, the sound of glasses in the bar and trains going by outside, with neon dancing frogs in the window and a dining room called the Rose Room. The menu stayed with lake fish. Perch, boned and buttered, was the biggest seller, along with frog legs, whitefish, walleye and fried smelt in season, and sides of cottage cheese, beets and potato salad, then pie or cake. The food writer Ari Weinzweig remembered his family driving about twenty minutes from Chicago's South Shore to eat there on special occasions.

Later owners and the last night in October 2007
After Irene died in 1969, Pete deeded the restaurant to Calumet College. Mike Probst, who had a restaurant management degree from a hotel school in Austria, managed it for the college for four years and bought it with his brothers in 1980. About twenty years later Dave and Barbara Welch took it over and ran it for seven years.
Phil Smidt's served its last dinners on Saturday, October 20, 2007, after 97 years. About 50 people lost their jobs. Regulars and the owner pointed to the Horseshoe casino nearby, which they said had cut into business. The head chef and manager, Joseph Perez, said he hoped it would reopen somewhere else.
The contents were auctioned on October 29, 2007. The Rose Room sign, a 1940s cash register, the neon frogs, dishes and letterhead were set aside for a future city museum, and a waitress's uniform went to the Whiting-Robertsdale Historical Society. The building was torn down in 2014.
Sources
- Phil Smidt's Now Just a Memory (Gayle Faulkner Kosalko, 2007), Whiting-Robertsdale Historical Society
- One Last Plate of Frog Legs (Adriene Hill), WBEZ Chicago Public Radio, October 19, 2007
- New Season Fried Smelt (Ari Weinzweig), Zingerman's Roadhouse, April 29, 2021
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Phil Smidt's.
Share a memory of Phil Smidt's
The gift shop
The Phil Smidt's sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All Phil Smidt's pieces

