The Irish Lion
The McConnaughy family restored an 1880s tavern on West Kirkwood and opened the Irish Lion in 1982. It poured yards of ale for Bloomington until May 2024.
- Where
- 212 W. Kirkwood Avenue, just west of the Courthouse Square, Bloomington, Indiana
- Open
- 1982–2024
- Known for
- Irish pub in an 1880s tavern, with a Brunswick back bar and yards of ale
- Reading time
- 3 minutes

An 1880s tavern near the Monon depot
The two-storey building at 212 West Kirkwood Avenue went up around 1882. The restaurant's own history, as reported by Indiana Public Media, credits Zimri McCollough with building it as a pub and inn for passengers from the Monon railroad depot nearby. An 1892 map found by the Herald-Times shows it as Bundy's European Hotel, with a saloon on the ground floor. Through the early 1900s the main floor was a tavern with billiard tables and the upstairs held hotel rooms.
From the 1930s into the 1950s, taverns and pool halls came and went. The Hinkle Tavern changed hands in 1944 and became Hinkle's Lunch, which ran through the 1950s and 1960s. Then came the Kirkwood Bar, which the Herald-Times found under several owners from 1968 into the late 1970s; a 1977 writer called it a hard-knocks railroad-track bar with a mixed gay and straight crowd. An old photograph of the tavern later turned up in the opening credits of the television show Cheers.
The McConnaughy restoration and the 1982 opening
After a short spell empty, the building was bought in 1979 by Larry McConnaughy and his family. They restored it with fixtures salvaged from taverns around Indiana. The centrepiece was a mahogany Brunswick back bar dating from somewhere between the late 1860s and the 1880s; upstairs they put an oak back bar from around 1910. The pressed-metal ceilings, put in around 1900 partly as a fire barrier against the gas lights, stayed, as did the decorative double doors at the front. The old icehouse became a cooler and a courtyard became the kitchen.
The Irish Lion Restaurant and Pub opened in 1982, with two floors of dining rooms and, in summer, tables out on Kirkwood Avenue.
Coddle, Guinness and a three-foot glass of ale
Bloom Magazine reviewed the Lion in 2012, when it had been open 28 years. The kitchen served coddle, a stew of potatoes, bacon and sausage; Blarney Puffballs, fried potato nuggets with cheese and garlic; fish and chips, corned beef and cabbage, mutton pies, and a house Irish apple walnut cake. Seafood had long been a speciality, from the seafood salad to Oysters Rockefeller. Bartenders were trained to pour Guinness properly, and longtime manager Dennis Cheng had built a list of more than 160 bourbons, Irish whiskeys and Scotches.
The drink people remembered was the yard of ale, served in a glass three feet long, with a half-yard for the less ambitious. The pub occasionally brought in Irish folk musicians and bagpipers. Larry's son Sheaghan told Bloom that the building's ghosts left family members alone, and that he had bartenders leave a shot on the bar at closing time.
Retirement and the last day in May 2024
In 2022 the owner put the business up for sale and began looking for a successor. On May 7, 2024 the family announced on Facebook that the owner was retiring and that the dining room would close. The Irish Lion served its last sit-down meals on Friday, May 17, 2024, in its 42nd year, and moved to delivery only for the summer, promising that pub favourites would still be available.
What's there now
Hoosier Alley Entertainment, a Bloomington company, bought the building for $1,325,000 on September 27, 2024. Indiana Public Media reported that the Kirkwood Candle Bar, which teaches candle-making classes, would move in, sharing the space with Weirdough Cookie Co., and that the plans kept historic features such as the old bar counter while adding an elevator and turning the upstairs into room for large parties. In November 2024 the Indiana Daily Student reported that EllieMae's Boutique, home of the candle shop, expected to make the move during 2025.
Sources
- Irish Lion closing Bloomington restaurant (Madelyn Hanes, May 17, 2024), Indiana Daily Student
- Irish Lion's owner retires, closing indoor dining (Katy Szpak, May 8, 2024), Indiana Public Media (WFIU/WTIU)
- Local candle shop buys Irish Lion building (Katy Szpak, October 29, 2024), Indiana Public Media (WFIU/WTIU)
- Was Bloomington's first gay bar in the Irish Lion building? What we found about its history (Marissa Meador, June 2024), The Herald-Times, via Yahoo News
- The Irish Lion: A True Pub, and Restaurant to Boot (Christine Barbour, February 24, 2012), Bloom Magazine
- Irish Lion, Bloomingpedia
- EllieMae's Boutique to move into former Irish Lion building (Marty Blader, November 13, 2024), Indiana Daily Student
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of The Irish Lion.
Share a memory of The Irish Lion
The gift shop
The The Irish Lion sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All The Irish Lion pieces

