Skip to content

Maxwell's Plum

Warner LeRoy's stained-glass restaurant and singles bar at First Avenue and 64th Street, which fed up to 1,500 people a day before he shut it in July 1988.

Where
1181 First Avenue at 64th Street, Upper East Side, New York
Open
1966–1988
Known for
Upper East Side singles bar and restaurant under a stained-glass ceiling
Reading time
4 minutes
The Maxwell's Plum sign, redrawn
The Maxwell's Plum sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Warner LeRoy opens a café beside the York Cinema

Warner LeRoy came to restaurants from show business. He was the son of the Hollywood producer Mervyn LeRoy, whose films included The Wizard of Oz, and he had worked as a film editor, a stage manager and a theatre producer and director. In 1959 he took over the York Theater on First Avenue and staged plays there. In 1964 he turned it into the York Cinema. Next door, on the corner of First Avenue and 64th Street, was a small luncheonette, and LeRoy bought a long lease on it.

Sources do not agree on the opening date. Jon Bradshaw, who profiled the restaurant for New York magazine in June 1975, wrote that it opened on the night of April 6, 1966. Wikipedia gives April 1, 1966. A 2020 InsideHook history by Aaron Goldfarb says it opened quietly on Tuesday, April 5, 1965, and the restaurant historian Jan Whitaker also gives 1965. LeRoy told Bradshaw he had considered calling the place The Shanghai Hippopotamus or The Silver Cherry before he settled on Maxwell's Plum, a name he said was not supposed to mean anything.

The first Plum was built to seat 80, with a kitchen ten feet by seven, three cooks and two dishwashers. LeRoy expected to sell 20 or 30 dinners a night. He told Bradshaw that First Avenue in 1965 was a bad area nobody came to, and that he had not known how many airline stewardesses, nurses and secretaries lived nearby. Hamburgers and a good wine list filled the room with single people. T.G.I. Friday's, opened the year before, was a block south at 63rd Street.

The 1969 expansion: Tiffany glass, ceramic animals and a back room

By 1969 the café was doing well enough that LeRoy closed the York Cinema and rebuilt it as a much larger Maxwell's Plum. The new restaurant could be used three ways: as a singles bar, as a sidewalk café, or as a formal dining room raised above the bar, with a view down onto the crowd. The New York Times, in a description quoted by Wikipedia, listed stained-glass ceilings and walls, Tiffany lamps, a menagerie of ceramic animals, etched glass and crystal. InsideHook adds a Lalique fountain, bronze bears, ceramic ocelots and potted ferns, and says LeRoy had bought 10,000 sheets of Tiffany glass cheaply.

The menu ran from chili and hamburgers to wild boar and caviar. Craig Claiborne and John Canaday of the Times each gave it four stars, and Canaday praised service that was first class whether or not the staff knew who you were. James Beard printed the Plum's chili recipe in a 1973 column.

“Running Maxwell's Plum is like running a goddamn hospital.”

1,500 meals on a Friday night

When Bradshaw visited in 1975 the Plum seated 240 and had been open nine years. He counted it among the four highest-volume restaurants in the city, with Mamma Leone's, Lüchow's and "21". Nearly 500,000 people a year came through, turnover the year before had been $4.1 million, and on the Friday he described the kitchen served 1,500 meals. The dinner rush began at six. A man on the front door locked it when the room was full. The kitchen closed at 1:40 a.m. and the bar at 3.

The back room held 26 tables and about 90 people, and was run by Van Ribblett, a former hairdresser who stood six feet six. The staff kept a list of about 450 favoured customers in three ranks. Warren Beatty, Bill Blass, Cary Grant, Richard Rodgers and Barbra Streisand were among those who came. LeRoy met his second wife, Kay, a TWA stewardess, in the original small Plum. By the mid-1970s the restaurant was taking in more than $5 million a year, over a third of it from alcohol.

San Francisco, Washington and the closing in July 1988

The Hardwicke Companies financed LeRoy's expansion, including his takeover of Tavern on the Green in Central Park. A second Maxwell's Plum opened in San Francisco in 1981 at a reported cost of $7 million and did not last, and neither did Potomac, a restaurant of 850 or 900 seats in Washington, D.C. LeRoy broke with Hardwicke in the 1980s and blamed the company for the San Francisco failure.

On First Avenue, LeRoy went through a run of chefs and cuisines in the last years: American, Californian, French, Pacific Northwestern. Reviews weakened. He closed the Plum abruptly in July 1988. Wikipedia gives the day as July 10, and the Times reported the closing the next morning. He also sold the building. InsideHook quotes him saying that keeping the place new was a great deal of work and that the fun had gone out of it.

The 1989 auction and the bar that went to Tribeca Grill

The furnishings were auctioned in January 1989. Whitaker writes that Donald Trump paid $28,000 for one of the Tiffany glass windows, and InsideHook that he bought a bronze elephant head for $4,250. The large island bar went to Tribeca Grill, which opened in 1990 with it as the centrepiece of the room. That restaurant's owners say the bar had come to the Plum from Jack Dempsey's.

Warner LeRoy went on to buy the Russian Tea Room. He died on February 22, 2001, aged 65. In 2020 InsideHook reported that the corner was occupied by a Duane Reade pharmacy.

Sources

  1. Maxwell's Plum, Wikipedia
  2. Before Studio 54, There Was Maxwell's Plum: An Excerpt from The Ocean Is Closed (Jon Bradshaw, New York magazine, June 16, 1975), ZE Books
  3. Revisiting TGI Fridays and the Revolutionary "Fern" Bars of Late-1960s New York, InsideHook
  4. Swingin' at Maxwell's Plum, Restaurant-ing through history
  5. The Former Maxwell's Plum, Right Here NYC
  6. The Historic Bar at Tribeca Grill, Myriad Restaurant Group
  7. Warner LeRoy, Wikipedia

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Maxwell's Plum.

Share a memory of Maxwell's Plum

The gift shop

The Maxwell's Plum sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Maxwell's Plum pieces