Mars Bar
Hank Penza's graffiti-covered corner bar at Second Avenue and East 1st Street ran for 27 years before the Health Department shut it in July 2011.
- Where
- 25 East 1st Street at Second Avenue, East Village, New York
- Open
- 1984–2011
- Known for
- Graffiti-covered East Village dive with a red 'Dive In' awning
- Reading time
- 3 minutes

Hank Penza and the corner of Second Avenue and East 1st Street
Mars Bar sat on the corner of Second Avenue and East 1st Street, at 25 East 1st Street, on the border of the East Village and the Lower East Side. Most accounts date its opening to 1984, the year printed on the pins fans bought in its final weeks; EV Grieve's obituary of the owner noted that some sources give 1982.
The owner was Hank Penza, who had been running bars in the neighbourhood since 1957, when he bought a place at 12 Bowery and renamed it Henry's. Over the following decades his name was attached to Hank's Crystal Palace, Willie's, the Penthouse and Bowery East. amNY reported that before he owned bars he had worked as muscle, clearing troublemakers out of other people's saloons, and that his father had come to New York from Italy.
A neighbour quoted by EV Grieve, from a 2011 New York Times piece, recalled that when Mars Bar opened in 1984, he and his neighbours took it for yet another sushi bar.

Graffiti, plastic cups and the bathroom
The room was small, dark and narrow, with mismatched stools, an assortment of paintings of uncertain quality, and beer stacked in boxes behind the bar. Drinks were cheap and came in plastic cups. The walls, inside and out, were layered with graffiti, stickers and spray-painted pieces, and customers kept adding notes of their own. The bathroom was its most famous feature; one regular recalled years later that flushing always involved a plunger.
Outside, a red awning carried the words 'MARS BAR DIVE IN' painted in black, and the storefront below it was papered with tags and posters. One former customer remembered that 'Daycare for Drunks' had once been written across the front.
Accounts of the place from the 2000s describe a bar that was frightening to some and home to others. Afternoon drinkers read the paper and talked to the bartender; the late crowd came for the cheap drinks and the jukebox. The New York Post called it a saloon known for cheap beer, punk rock and a shortage of toilet paper. The filmmaker Jonas Mekas made an 87-minute documentary about the place, My Mars Bar Movie.
“I feel like there's a beginning and an end, and this is the end to another chapter in my life.”
The condo plan and the last summer
In late 2010 word spread that the corner was to be redeveloped. The developer BFC Partners planned a 12-story building with about 60 apartments on the site, and Penza agreed to the deal. Under the plan Mars Bar would close for at least two years during construction, with the option of reopening in a larger space in the new building.
By June 2011 the bar was packed every night with regulars and with newcomers who had come to see it before it went. June 30 was rumoured to be the last night, but the doors opened again on July 1, and from then on any night might have been the final one. Penza did not tell anyone when he meant to close.
Why Mars Bar closed in July 2011
The end came from the city rather than the developer. On Monday, July 18, 2011, the Department of Health shut the bar. Inspectors reported hundreds of fruit flies, standing water on water-logged wooden floors, a cracked wall, unsecured gas cylinders and no test kits for sanitising glassware; EV Grieve put the total at 54 violation points. Penza decided not to reopen. The following evening about a dozen people held a candlelight vigil on the sidewalk outside, drinking beer.
In the days before it closed the East Village filmmaker Jenny Woodward recorded interviews with Penza, released in 2016 as the short film Last Days of the Mars Bar. Penza died on October 29, 2015, at 82.
What's on the corner now
The corner storefronts were demolished in late 2011 and early 2012, and the 12-story Jupiter 21 apartment building went up in their place. Mars Bar never came back. A TD Bank took the corner space at street level, and EV Grieve reported that Penza was said to be a partner in the business that later opened in the building.
Sources
- Mars Bar Closes for Good, DNAinfo
- Thanks for the memories: Mars Bar closed 10 years ago today, EV Grieve
- RIP Hank Penza, EV Grieve
- Video: Last days at the Mars Bar, EV Grieve
- Hank Penza, owner of old-school dive Mars Bar, amNY
- Mars Bar was down and dirty, but it was real and it was ours, amNY
- One Last Round for Mars Bar, Untapped Cities
- Mars Bar NYC to close as East Village gentrifies, urban75
The gift shop
The Mars Bar sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Mars Bar pieces











