Skip to content

James's Gate

James's Gate, the two-room Irish pub with a fireplace at 5-11 McBride Street in Jamaica Plain, ran from 1997 until it shut without warning in 2015.

Where
5-11 McBride Street at South Street, Jamaica Plain, Boston, Massachusetts
Open
1997–2015
Known for
Jamaica Plain Irish pub with a fireplace and a back dining room
Reading time
2 minutes
The James's Gate sign, redrawn
The James's Gate sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Opening on McBride Street in 1997

Paul Byrne and Christy Page opened James's Gate in 1997 at the corner of McBride and South streets, south of Jamaica Plain's main business district on the way toward Forest Hills and the Arnold Arboretum. From the street it was a plain building with a white sign, and it had its own parking lot. The pub got in just before the Boston Fire Department stopped allowing fireplaces in restaurants, and that timing gave it the feature regulars remembered most.

The fireplace, the pub and the back dining room

James's Gate was really two places with two bars. The front pub had dark wood, ceiling beams, old wooden tables and a large fireplace that was lit through the colder months. Behind it was a quieter, more formal dining room with earthy colours, spotlit paintings and a bar along one wall; it often hung rotating art shows. There was also a large outdoor patio.

Each side had its own menu, and customers could order from either. The pub side served curry chips, toasties, burgers, shepherd's pie, chicken curry, fish and chips and baked macaroni and cheese, with a long list of vegetarian dishes; the dining room added things like clam chowder, salmon and rack of lamb. Behind the bar it was Guinness, other draught beers and Irish whiskey. Boston Magazine named it the city's best Irish pub in 2013, pointing to its fire, and the Boston's Hidden Restaurants guide gave it the same title in 2014.

“James's Gate was part of JP's DNA and has been very badly missed”

Weddings, wakes and the Carpenter Poets

Most of the crowd was local. After it closed, the Jamaica Plain resident Melissa Hamel wrote in the Jamaica Plain Gazette that the Gate had been the neighbourhood's third place, the room between home and work, and she listed what she had seen there: weddings and wakes, baby showers and bachelor parties, softball teams after games, trivia nights, readings by the Carpenter Poets, art openings including her own first solo show, fundraisers, World Cup matches and a yearly Christmas night gathering. A Patch writer in 2011 mentioned a bartender from Galway named Rory.

The sudden closing in 2015

James's Gate closed without warning on a Monday evening at the end of August 2015, after about 18 years. Staff were not told in advance. A note taped to the front door thanked the pub's faithful customers for their support. No public reason was given, and the two owners went their separate ways afterwards.

In August 2016 a group calling itself the James's Gate Cooperative held meetings about reopening the place as a community-owned bar, with members paying an annual fee and sharing votes. It did not happen. Paul Byrne went on to open a smaller pub called The Gate at 3171 Washington Street in Egleston Square in May 2017; it closed in March 2018.

The sale, the demolition and the condo plan

In March 2016 the Jamaica Plain developers the Ballas Group bought the James's Gate property along with two neighbouring parcels, about 12,100 square feet in all, for $1.95 million. Stephen Ballas first proposed a five-storey building, also to be called The Gate, with ground-floor commercial space and 11 homes above. In January 2017 the city's Zoning Board of Appeals approved a four-storey mixed-use condo building for the site, and the old pub was razed later that year. In November 2017 the lot was a hole in the ground, and the James's Gate mural could still be seen on the side wall of the neighbouring building.

Sources

  1. Beloved Jamaica Plain Eatery Closes Unexpectedly, Jamaica Plain Patch
  2. James's Gate was a 'third place', Jamaica Plain Gazette
  3. James's Gate, Boston's Hidden Restaurants
  4. Gourmet Pub Grub at James's Gate, Jamaica Plain Patch
  5. Best Irish Pub 2013: James's Gate, Boston Magazine
  6. 'The Gate' Aims for New Year's Opening in Eggie, Jamaica Plain News
  7. James's Gate Cooperative Meeting After JPNDC Meeting on Thursday, Jamaica Plain News
  8. James's Gate Former Site Sold to Developer, Jamaica Plain Patch
  9. ICYMI: James's Gate Restaurant Razed, Jamaica Plain News
  10. The Gate Restaurant Closes After Less Than a Year in Egleston Square, Jamaica Plain News
  11. Co-Owner of James's Gate May Open The Gate in Egleston Square, Boston Restaurant Talk

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of James's Gate.

Share a memory of James's Gate

The gift shop

The James's Gate sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All James's Gate pieces