Skip to content

hungry i

Enrico Banducci's North Beach cellar club, where Mort Sahl, the Kingston Trio, Tom Lehrer and a young Barbra Streisand played in front of a bare brick wall.

Where
599 Jackson Street at Kearny Street, in the basement of the International Hotel, North Beach, San Francisco
Open
1950–1970
Known for
Cellar nightclub where stand-up comics and folk groups played against a brick wall
Reading time
4 minutes
The hungry i sign, redrawn
The hungry i sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Eric Nord's basement club at Columbus and Kearny

The hungry i began in the basement of the Sentinel Building, the green flatiron at Columbus Avenue and Kearny Street in North Beach. Eric Nord, later known around the neighbourhood as Big Daddy, opened it there in 1949 or 1950 as a room with 83 seats.

Several stories are told about the lower-case name. The artist Mark Adams, who designed the first interior, said in a 1983 oral history that he came up with it for a place where actors could unwind after rehearsals, and that it referred to the hungers of the first person singular. Nord told interviewers he had meant to call it the Hungry Intellectual and ran out of paint. Enrico Banducci, the next owner, said the i was Freudian and stood for the id.

Banducci had been born Harry Banducci in Bakersfield and had come to San Francisco at 13 to study violin. He took the club over from Nord, and the sources do not agree on when: the Associated Press obituary says 1948, the Coast News says 1950 and other accounts say 1951. The Coast News put the price at $800, with $11,000 of Nord's debts attached. The first acts under Banducci were the jazz singer Stella Brooks and the folk singer Stan Wilson.

A narrow green copper-clad flatiron building with a domed corner tower, a red cafe awning at street level and taller modern buildings behind
The Sentinel Building at Columbus Avenue and Kearny Street, where the hungry i started in the basement, photographed in 2016.Photo: Dllu, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Mort Sahl and the move to 599 Jackson Street

In 1953 Banducci hired a young comic named Mort Sahl. By the Coast News account Sahl started on a two-week trial at $75 a week and stayed four years. Lines for his shows ran around the block, and the fire department threatened to shut the basement for lack of exits.

In 1954 Banducci moved the club a short distance to the basement of the International Hotel, with its entrance at 599 Jackson Street near Kearny. The new room held about 300 people around a three-sided stage. Performers stood in front of a bare red brick wall, a backdrop that comedy clubs across the country later copied.

Banducci ran the room more like a theatre than a bar. No drinks were served while an act was on, and hecklers were put out. Brad Rosenstein, quoted in the Associated Press obituary of Banducci, said performers told him no other club owner treated them as well. The announcer who introduced the acts was Alvah Bessie, a screenwriter who had been blacklisted in Hollywood.

“I can't say whether I discovered them or not. It was a time when everything just fell in.”

The comedians, folk groups and live albums

Lenny Bruce, Jonathan Winters, Shelley Berman, Dick Gregory, Bob Newhart, Bill Cosby and Woody Allen all worked the hungry i early in their careers. Maya Angelou sang Caribbean songs there before she was known as a writer. The pianist Vince Guaraldi, who lived in the neighbourhood, played the club too.

Record labels came for the folk acts. The Kingston Trio recorded ...from the "Hungry i" at the club on August 15 and 16, 1958. Capitol released it in January 1959 and it reached number two on the Billboard album chart. The group later bought the Sentinel Building, where the club had started, and used it as their headquarters. The Limeliters recorded Our Men in San Francisco at the club, Phyllis Diller taped a comedy album there in September 1962, and Tom Lehrer recorded That Was the Year That Was at the club in July 1965.

Barbra Streisand played the room from March 27 to April 20, 1963, two shows a night, just after her first Columbia album came out. Woody Allen was on the bill for four of those nights.

Ghirardelli Square and the 1970 closing

By the mid-1960s the audience for folk music and nightclub comedy was shrinking. On October 12, 1967, Banducci closed the Jackson Street room and reopened the hungry i at Ghirardelli Square, where it ran mostly as a rock venue. It closed in 1970. The Associated Press later put the failure down to changing tastes and to Banducci's habit of spending faster than he earned.

As the club wound down, Banducci sold its name and logo to a group of Broadway club owners. Pierre's, at 546 Broadway, was renamed the Hungry I Club and ran as a strip club under various owners until 2019. Banducci kept his sidewalk cafe, Enrico's, on Broadway for about 18 more years.

What became of the Jackson Street site

Many of the old performers, including Sahl, Winters, Irwin Corey and Jackie Vernon, came back for a one-night reunion in 1981 that was filmed for television. In March 2007 an exhibition on the club opened at the San Francisco Performing Arts Library and Museum, with Banducci at the opening. He died on October 9 that year in South San Francisco, aged 85.

The International Hotel became the centre of a long housing fight. Its remaining tenants were evicted on August 4, 1977, and the building was demolished in 1981. The lot sat empty for years. A Coast News writer who visited with Banducci reported that the brick wall from the back of the stage could still be seen in the excavation. A new International Hotel with 105 apartments for seniors was completed on the site in August 2005. The Sentinel Building still stands at Columbus and Kearny and is owned by Francis Ford Coppola.

Black and white street view of boarded storefronts behind scaffolding, one with an International Hotel Tenants Association sign, and the Transamerica Pyramid rising behind
The Kearny Street side of the International Hotel around 1979, after its tenants were evicted. The hungry i had been in the basement on the Jackson Street side.Photo: Nancy Wong, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Sources

  1. Hungry I, Wikipedia
  2. Hungry i club owner dies at 85, Associated Press, Tahoe Daily Tribune
  3. San Fran Nightclub Owner Banducci Dead, CBS News
  4. The hungry i, Coast News
  5. hungry i, San Francisco 1963, Barbra Archives
  6. Bohemia by the Bay: Looking Back on the Beat Generation, Eichler Network
  7. Columbus Tower (San Francisco), Wikipedia
  8. International Hotel (San Francisco), Wikipedia
  9. ...from the "Hungry i", Wikipedia
  10. That Was the Year That Was, Wikipedia
  11. hungry i, S.F. Heart

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of hungry i.

Share a memory of hungry i

The gift shop

The hungry i sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All hungry i pieces