Hot Tin Roof
Carly Simon, Herb Putnam and George Brush opened the Hot Tin Roof at the Martha's Vineyard airport in 1979; SNL stars, Lou Reed and Peter Tosh played there.
- Where
- Off Airport Road, Martha's Vineyard Airport, Edgartown, Massachusetts
- Open
- 1979–2006
- Known for
- Island nightclub in a tin building by the airport
- Reading time
- 3 minutes

A tin building by the airport, 1979
The Hot Tin Roof opened in 1979 on a patch of land off Airport Road in Edgartown, beside the Martha's Vineyard airport. The partners were Herb Putnam and George Brush, who had earlier tried to get permits for a dance hall and music room on the site, and the singer Carly Simon, who was brought in to help run it. James Taylor, then her husband, came up with the name after the 1978 No Nukes concert in Chilmark, and the building really did have a tin roof, which gave the club its nickname, the Roof. Simon remembered holding her baby son, Ben Taylor, on opening night.
Simon hired Patti Rix to do the booking, and her brother Peter Simon played records between the live acts.
The Blues Brothers, Saturday Night Live and summer regulars
In its first years the Roof was a summer hangout for the Saturday Night Live cast. John Belushi and Dan Aykroyd worked on their Blues Brothers act there before it went public, and comedy nights drew Bill Murray and others from the show. The Taylor family were regulars, and visitors over the years included Keith Richards, Walter Cronkite, Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis and John Travolta.
The music bookings ran from Bonnie Raitt, Delbert McClinton, Ricky Nelson, Leon Russell, Jesse Colin Young and Martha Reeves to B.B. King, Pat Benatar and Taj Mahal. Cyndi Lauper played before she was famous. Peter Tosh sold the room out, and reggae became a fixture, with Jimmy Cliff and Toots and the Maytals among those who followed.
“Perfect, a tin building in the middle of the Island built for fun.”
Sold in 1986, revived in 1996
In 1986 Simon, Brush and Putnam agreed to sell the club to the island businessman Peter Martell, and it closed in 1987. In the mid-1990s Putnam and a group of ten investors, among them Steven Rattner, Richard Friedman, Dirk Ziff and Harvey Weinstein, with Simon also investing, bought it back. It reopened in 1996 after a renovation that added murals by Margot Datz, more capacity, an open-air section and a better sound system.
The second run brought Lou Reed, Buddy Guy, Dr. John, Dizzy Gillespie and Jerry Lee Lewis, plus younger acts such as Susan Tedeschi, Derek Trucks and Grace Potter. Shows could sell out at more than 550 people. Getting bands onto an island was its own job: staff once chartered planes and boats when the Neville Brothers' equipment failed to arrive, and Taj Mahal and Barrington Levy both needed speedboats or charter flights to make their sets.
How the Hot Tin Roof ended
Accounts of the ending differ. Martha's Vineyard Magazine says the Hot Tin Roof closed for good in September 2002. The Vineyard Gazette, however, reported in October 2005 that the club was under agreement to be sold to the Rosenthal brothers, and in January 2006 that the landmark nightclub's name was changing. Barry Rosenthal and his brother Arthur bought it in 2006 and, because the previous owners kept the rights to the Hot Tin Roof name, reopened it as Outerland, with the Roof's general manager and booker, Cory Cabral, staying on.
Outerland lasted three seasons, adding an upscale restaurant and booking Judy Collins, John Hiatt, the Avett Brothers and Hall and Oates, before it was put up for sale in September 2008.
Nectar's, Flatbread and the Tin Hangar
In 2009 the Burlington, Vermont, club Nectar's took over the building in partnership with Flatbread, the wood-fired pizza company. Nectar's left in 2012 and Flatbread stayed on, though by MMONE's account the music there had ended by 2014. Flatbread struggled to live on summer trade and closed in 2016. Flatbread's share of the building was sold to Brion McGroarty, whose MV Wine and Spirits shop occupies an addition to the same building, and he planned a smaller restaurant there called the Tin Hangar, which he said was a nod to the Hot Tin Roof. By 2024 the building held a gourmet food shop and a fish market.
Sources
- Hot Tin Roof, MMONE
- Last call, Martha's Vineyard Magazine
- Hot Tin Roof (Time Machine collection), Vineyard Gazette
- Flatbread bakes, no new restaurant planned, The Martha's Vineyard Times
The gift shop
The Hot Tin Roof sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Hot Tin Roof pieces











