Skip to content
The Bar Museum

Hawaii Kai

Hawaii Kai served luaus and a Polynesian revue above the Winter Garden Theatre at Broadway and 50th from 1962 until about 1989, and turned up in Goodfellas.

Where
1638 Broadway at West 50th Street, above the Winter Garden Theatre, Midtown Manhattan, New York
Open
1962–1989
Known for
Polynesian supper club with a Broadway designer's interiors
Reading time
2 minutes
The Hawaii Kai sign, redrawn
The Hawaii Kai sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

From the Beachcomber to Lanai to Hawaii Kai

The rooms above the Winter Garden Theatre, at Broadway and 50th Street, had housed South Seas restaurants before. In the early 1940s the impresario Monte Proser ran his Beachcomber there, an imitation of Don the Beachcomber. In 1961 Proser and the restaurateur Joe Kipness opened the space again as Lanai.

By November 1962 it had been renamed Hawaii Kai, according to the tiki history site Mytiki.life, with Kipness now in partnership with Art Schindler, who had owned the Luau 400, another Polynesian place nearby. The film-locations site Movie-Locations gives the address as 1638 Broadway.

Frederick Fox's bamboo and rattan rooms

The interiors were the work of Frederick Fox, a scenic designer for Broadway productions, and they were built like a stage set. At street level the entrance was planted thick with greenery, with waterfalls and capuchin monkeys. A rattan staircase led up to three rooms.

The Okole Maluna Bar had a large backlit diorama of Waikiki's Diamond Head that shifted from dusk to dawn. The Lounge of the Seven Pleasures had entertainment every night until 3 a.m. The main dining room put on a nightly luau and Polynesian revue, billed at different times as Hula Wei, Place of Meeting and The Island Huts of Oahu, with thatched booths set around the edge of the room like huts.

Writing in 2024, the author Michael Stutz called it the most elaborate tiki temple New York ever had.

Hawaii Kai in Goodfellas

Hawaii Kai appeared in a couple of Hollywood films. The best known is Martin Scorsese's Goodfellas (1990). In the film, the Bamboo Lounge is a Brooklyn hangout for Henry Hill's crew, but its interior was shot at Hawaii Kai. The scene where Henry's narration introduces the regulars, and Joe Pesci's Tommy turns on Henry with the 'You think I'm funny' monologue, was filmed in its rooms, with the camera moving through the lounge in one long pan, as it does in the film's better-known Copacabana shot. The exterior was shot elsewhere, at Collaro's, an Italian restaurant in Sheepshead Bay.

Stutz, who interviewed the actor Vincent Pastore about the scene, wrote that the filming took place in the restaurant's final days in 1989.

Decline, a fire and closing around 1989

Over the years Hawaii Kai's popularity faded. It held on through the 1980s and survived damage from a fire, though the sources consulted do not give the date. It closed during or shortly after 1989; Movie-Locations gives 1989.

The Hawaii Kai sign stayed on the building for a long time after the restaurant closed, but the South Seas decor is gone. The Winter Garden Theatre below is still running.

Sources

  1. Hawaii Kai (Above the Winter Garden Theatre), Mytiki.life
  2. Remembering New York's Hawaii Kai with Vincent Pastore, Michael Stutz, Stutzstack
  3. Goodfellas film locations, The Worldwide Guide to Movie Locations
  4. #MonthofScorsese: NYC Film Locations for Goodfellas, Untapped New York

The gift shop

The Hawaii Kai sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Hawaii Kai pieces