Skip to content

Good Time Charley's

Merrill Zinder opened Good Time Charley's on Route 27 in Kingston in 1969. He ran it for 35 years, then sold it to the Charlie Brown's chain in 2004.

Where
40 Main Street (Route 27), Kingston, New Jersey
Open
Opened 1969
Known for
Steakhouse and bar on Route 27, two miles north of Princeton
Reading time
2 minutes
The Good Time Charley's sign, redrawn
The Good Time Charley's sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Merrill Zinder opens Good Time Charley's in Kingston in 1969

Good Time Charley's stood on Route 27 in Kingston, New Jersey, the village just up the road from Princeton. Merrill Zinder opened it in 1969, according to Town Topics, the Princeton weekly, and it was the first restaurant to carry the name.

It did not stay the only one for long. Zinder added three more restaurants in 1972, and by his own count he owned seven Good Time Charley's houses over the years. By 2004 only two were left: the Kingston original and Charley's Other Brother, on Route 537 in Eastampton Township.

Two miles north of Princeton: the bars, the dining rooms and the alumni trade

The restaurant sold itself to Princeton on distance. An advertisement in the Princeton Alumni Weekly's restaurant guide in October 1999, under the name Good-Time Charley's, promised fine food and drink "only 2 miles north of Princeton" at 40 Main Street, Kingston, with lunch, dinner and cocktails seven days a week.

By the end it was a large operation. Town Topics counted 75 employees in 2004. There were two bars: the original small one in the middle of the restaurant, and a grill bar that seated about 45. The house also booked private parties, and the buyer expected to run the biggest banquet facility in its chain there. A later report on the same site put the restaurant and catering space at 18,000 square feet, with five party rooms holding from 30 to 300 people, though that count was made after a later owner's time and may not match the rooms as Zinder ran them.

“I'm 75 years old; I'm tired.”

The 2004 sale to Charlie Brown's Steakhouse

In August 2004 Town Topics reported that Good Time Charley's would be turned over to Charlie Brown's Steakhouse, a chain with restaurants across New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania. Zinder expected the change of ownership within a few weeks. He was 75, planned to retire to Florida, and intended to keep Charley's Other Brother.

He told the paper that the staff would be kept, that parties already booked would be honoured at the menus and prices promised, and that the place would go on trading as Good Time Charley's until the remodelling was finished. The work was to be done by a crew coming in between midnight and 10 a.m. so the restaurant never had to shut. The grill bar was to stay as it was. The small original bar was to become a salad bar. The Kingston house, Zinder said, would be the largest Charlie Brown's of all.

No report found gives the day the Good Time Charley's name came down.

What is at the Good Time Charley's site now

Charlie Brown's did not last in Kingston either. By October 2012 the Princeton Echo was describing both steakhouses as closed, and a new restaurant called The Pind was being fitted out at the address, by then given as 4591 Route 27. Its plans called for a fusion dining room, a sports bar with its own entrance that turned into a late-night lounge, and the private party rooms.

Sources

  1. Good Time Charley's in Kingston To Join a Steakhouse Chain, Town Topics
  2. Bon Appétit: A Guide to Area Restaurants and Cafés (advertisement for Good-Time Charley's), October 6, 1999, Princeton Alumni Weekly
  3. The Pind hoping 3's a charm in Kingston, Princeton Echo / Community News

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Good Time Charley's.

Share a memory of Good Time Charley's

The gift shop

The Good Time Charley's sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Good Time Charley's pieces