Annabell's Bar & Lounge
Annabell's opened as One-Eyed Jack's in 1970 on West Market Street in Akron's Highland Square, and its basement stage hosted local and touring bands until 2023.
- Where
- 784 W. Market Street, Highland Square, Akron, Ohio
- Open
- 1970–2023
- Known for
- Highland Square bar with a basement music room under the street
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

One-Eyed Jack's in a former carpet store, 1970
In 1970 the Akron car dealer Jack Cavileer opened a bar called One-Eyed Jack's in a former carpet store at 784 W. Market Street, in the Highland Square neighbourhood on the city's west side. The comedian Bobby Monahan was his business partner, ran the bar and acted as emcee. Its advertisements promised a quaint Olde English atmosphere and hot sandwiches daily, and the weekend entertainment ran to lounge acts: the Danny Mazzocco quartet, the Nuff Rey Combo, an organist billed as Geno and the singer Carol Welch.
Ann Pflueger renames it Annabell's
The bar publicist Ann K. Pflueger took the place over and by 1979 had renamed it Annabell's. She sold it to Freddie Salem shortly before she died in 1991, at 88.
Salem opened up the basement and put on live music there three or four nights a week, mostly roots and bluegrass. In 1997 he sold the club to Anthony Polito, who made the basement bigger, added more music nights and started a Monday steak dinner for $2.99. Polito sold the bar a few years later to the owner who ran it to the end.
“Annabell's gave so many opportunities for musicians to hone their craft on stage, and honestly it's just sad to see it go.”
The basement and Akron's music scene
Upstairs Annabell's was a neighbourhood bar with cheap beer; the music happened below street level. Akron Life described it as a gritty old watering hole where live music had always survived a revolving door of operators and ideas, and called the catacomb-like basement the musical heart of the place. When Cleveland Scene sent readers to Highland Square in October 2007, the basement had just been redone in a bid to become the newest room in Akron's music scene, with the horror-punk band L.O.B.D. on the bill and $1 pints at the bar.
Band stickers covered the walls. Musicians who played there described a room where a touring act and a band on its first gig got the same treatment. Caitie O'Shea, a bass and baritone guitar player and longtime regular, told News 5 Cleveland that everyone was given the same shot, and the Akron musician Miles Moore, who had played and drunk there for more than a decade, said it gave local bands a place to hone their craft on stage.
Freddie Salem, talking to the Akron Beacon Journal in 2015, said some of his old customers were now doctors and lawyers who had met their spouses at Annabell's.
Closing in May 2023
In early 2023 the bar and the owner of the building fell out over the rent. Months of talks did not settle it, and Annabell's closed in May 2023, after more than 50 years of a bar at 784 W. Market Street. Regulars and musicians who spoke to reporters that month described it as a safe and welcoming place, and said its loss would make it harder for young Akron bands to find a stage.
Sources
- Annabell's, a Highland Square and Akron music landmark, faces eviction, closure (Anthony Thompson and Mark J. Price), Akron Beacon Journal via Yahoo News, May 19, 2023
- Annabell's, a fixture in Akron's music scene, News 5 Cleveland, May 2023
- Akron's live music scene, Akron Life
- Party tonight on Akron's Highland Square (Denise Grollmus), Cleveland Scene, October 2007
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Annabell's Bar & Lounge.
Share a memory of Annabell's Bar & Lounge
The gift shop
The Annabell's Bar & Lounge sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All Annabell's Bar & Lounge pieces

