Yesterdays Restaurant & Tavern
Two brothers and a friend opened Yesterdays in a 1935 flatiron building in Five Points, serving meat-and-three up front and drinks in the back bar until 2020.
- Where
- 2030 Devine Street, where Devine, Harden and Santee streets meet, Five Points, Columbia, South Carolina
- Open
- 1977–2020
- Known for
- Five Points tavern with a cowboy in a bathtub over the door
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

From the Ocean City boardwalk to Five Points
Duncan and Scotty MacRae were brothers from Lancaster, Pennsylvania, who spent their summers working at Mack and Manco's pizza stand on the boardwalk in Ocean City, New Jersey. Duncan had worked there in the early 1960s, flew helicopters for the Marine Corps in Vietnam, and came back to the pizza ovens; Scotty waited tables, then tended bar at the Anchorage Tavern in Somers Point while Duncan cooked at the Crab Trap. With a friend, Darrell Barnes, they went looking for a restaurant of their own.
On a trip to Columbia in 1976 they spotted a flatiron-shaped building at the point where Devine, Harden and Santee streets meet in Five Points. It had been put up in 1935 to house Gibson's Drug Store and more recently held a restaurant called Lombardi's, which was up for sale. The district was going through a rough patch, but it sat close to the University of South Carolina and to state government offices. The three bought the building and opened Yesterdays.
Meat-and-three in front, the tavern in back
At a time when Columbia's restaurants mostly served Italian, French or Chinese food, Yesterdays cooked regional American dishes from scratch, with a prep kitchen on site and a daily specials sheet built on vegetables from the farmers' market. The dining room up front served meat-and-three plates; the bar was at the back. The decor leaned on nostalgic, small-town Americana, and the business grew fast: it was expanding by its first winter and within another year had taken over the rest of the block.
Over the entrance sat the restaurant's best-known decoration, a cowboy mannequin lounging in a bathtub, which became a landmark for Five Points and for Columbia as a whole.
St. Patrick's Day in the parking lot
The owners held the first Five Points St. Patrick's Day festival in the restaurant's parking lot, and Duncan MacRae started the parade that ended at the Yesterdays bar. The event grew into one of the largest and best-known festivals in South Carolina.
Hanging it up in April 2020
On April 21, 2020, in the first spring of the pandemic, the owners announced on Twitter that Yesterdays would not reopen. They wrote that 43 years had been a hell of a run, thanked the community for making work feel like home, and told their customers to be good to one another. Sources differ slightly on the first year: the owners' own count and later reporting point to 1977, while COLAtoday's report on their keys to the city dated the opening to 1976, the year the partners arrived.
On October 27, 2020, Mayor Steve Benjamin presented Barnes and the MacRae brothers with keys to the city at a socially distanced ceremony beside the building, recognising more than four decades of business and the festival they had started.
What's in the Yesterdays building now
The building passed to a new owner, Dominic Como. In October 2020 the city's Design and Development Review Commission looked at plans by Lambert Architecture to split it into several units and bring the outside back to its mid-century look. It sat empty for nearly two years, and by October 2022 the interior had been gutted for Ruby Sunshine, a New Orleans brunch chain from the Ruby Slipper Restaurant Group, which took the ground floor and planned to open in 2023, with offices for another tenant upstairs.
Sources
- Yesterdays granted keys to the City of Columbia, SC, COLAtoday (6AM City), October 28, 2020
- Yesterdays Restaurant & Tavern 'hang it up', ABC Columbia, April 21, 2020
- New Orleans-based brunch spot coming to iconic Five Points spot, Carolina News and Reporter (University of South Carolina)
- Scott and Duncan MacRae at Yesterdays, Ocean City Days (blog), July 15, 2011
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Yesterdays Restaurant & Tavern.
Share a memory of Yesterdays Restaurant & Tavern
The gift shop
The Yesterdays Restaurant & Tavern sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All Yesterdays Restaurant & Tavern pieces

