The Darkhorse Tavern
The Darkhorse Tavern was a basement bar at 127 East Calder Way in downtown State College, known for wings and a long L-shaped bar until it closed in July 2018.
- Where
- 127 East Calder Way, downtown State College, Pennsylvania
- Open
- Closed 2018
- Known for
- Basement pub with wings and a long L-shaped bar
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

A basement bar on Calder Way
The Darkhorse Tavern sat below street level at 127 East Calder Way, the narrow lane that runs behind College Avenue in downtown State College, a short walk from the Penn State campus. Local coverage at the time of its closing put its run at a little over twenty years, which places its opening in the late 1990s, though none of the reports gave an exact year. In 2018 the local news site StateCollege.com named Michael Caruso as its owner.
The room was dark and low, and the thing people remembered about it was the long L-shaped bar. Town & Gown, the State College magazine, later described the place as a downtown favorite even if it never had the age of the All-American Rathskeller, its better-known neighbor.
Wings, pints and graduate students
The Darkhorse was a food-and-drink pub more than a dance bar. Its own farewell note talked about people coming in for a pint, a laugh or a plate of wings, to watch a game or to hear music. The wings were what it was best known for: when the closing was announced, commenters on its Facebook page asked for the recipe, and a year later Penn State alumni interviewed by the student site Onward State were still naming its Pazzo's wing sauce as the thing they missed most.
Onward State also noted that the Darkhorse had been a favorite of graduate students, an older crowd than the one the downtown strip usually drew. One alumna remembered it as a place where everyone could fit in and get good drinks and food for a fair price.
“If you have to ask why, then you've never had their Pazzo's wing sauce.”
Why the Darkhorse closed in 2018
On April 10, 2018, the bar posted a statement on social media saying it would close for good, with its last day of business on July 15, 2018. The reason given was simple: after many years in the hospitality trade, the owner had decided to retire. The post thanked customers for more than twenty years of business, along with former staff and suppliers.
The timing made the loss feel larger in town. The All-American Rathskeller had closed earlier the same year, and Herwig's Austrian Bistro and Ye Olde College Diner were also on their way out. Town & Gown called the Darkhorse's closing a second shock to the State College bar trade in 2018.
Jax Bar & Kitchen in the old space
The basement did not stay empty long. Jax Bar & Kitchen opened in the refurbished room on September 21, 2018. The new owners extended the bar into the middle of the old dining area and added a second bar, with televisions overhead and a smaller bar with a jukebox on the College Avenue side. Onward State reported that Jax was aimed at a younger crowd than the Darkhorse's regulars.
Asked a year later which closed places they would bring back, alumni put the Darkhorse near the top of the list. One 2017 graduate told Onward State that Jax was fine, but no Darkhorse.
Sources
- Darkhorse to close after 20 years of business, Onward State
- Downtown State College Bar to Close, StateCollege.com
- Last Call: The Bars of Yesteryear, Town & Gown
- Darkhorse Tavern in State College closing in July, PhillyVoice
- Jax Bar & Kitchen Opens in Former Darkhorse Location, StateCollege.com
- Photo Story: Jax Bar & Kitchen Ready For Business, Onward State
- What Restaurants & Bars Would Alumni Bring Back To State College?, Onward State
The gift shop
The The Darkhorse Tavern sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All The Darkhorse Tavern pieces





