Talbott Street
Talbott Street ran drag shows and a Studio 54-style dance floor inside a 1920s silent-movie house in Herron-Morton until it closed on June 25, 2016.
- Where
- 2143 N. Talbott Street near 22nd Street, Herron-Morton Place, Indianapolis, Indiana
- Open
- Closed 2016
- Known for
- Drag shows and dancing in a converted silent-movie theatre
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

A silent-movie house on Talbott Street
The building at 2143 N. Talbott Street, near 22nd Street in the Herron-Morton Place neighbourhood, was designed by the architect George V. Bedell as the Talbott Theater, a silent-movie house with 1,042 seats squeezed onto a narrow lot between two houses. Wikipedia and the Indianapolis Business Journal give its opening as 1920; Historic Indianapolis dates it to the mid-1920s.
As wealthier families moved out to the suburbs, the theatre changed hands and names. According to Historic Indianapolis, citing the Cinema Treasures database, it became the Coronet in 1956 and the Encore in 1962. In the late 1960s it reopened as the Black Curtain Dinner Theatre, the city's first professional dinner theatre, which Randy and Karen Galvin ran through the 1970s.
Gay clubs on Talbott from the early 1980s
By the 1970s Herron-Morton had a name as a refuge for people outside the mainstream, and by 1981 the street had two popular gay clubs, Talbott Street Disco and the 21st Club. The old theatre housed a gay bar and nightclub under one name or another since the early 1980s, and the Talbott became one of the best-known gay clubs in the city during that decade.
Not everyone on the street welcomed it. In the early 1980s the neighbourhood association complained about parking, litter and prostitution and tried, without success, to challenge the bar's liquor licence.
Strapulos, Massey and the 2002 redesign
The last version of the club, Talbott Street, opened in 2002, according to the IBJ. Its owner, Michael Strapulos, a dentist who had bought the theatre, worked with the designer Scott Massey to rebuild the interior. They took ideas from nightclubs in Miami and New York and divided the old auditorium into three areas, each with its own atmosphere. In 2003 the pair won an Indy Interiors award for the best commercial interior.
The club had a Studio 54-style dance floor and put on three drag shows every Saturday night. Readers of the alt-weekly NUVO voted it the best place in town to see a drag show, the best place to dance, and the best place to pick up someone of the same sex. By the end it opened only on Friday and Saturday nights. The club listed IndyPride, the Bag Ladies, the Damien Center and Lambda Legal among the causes it supported.
Why Talbott Street closed in 2016
On Tuesday, June 14, 2016, days after the shooting at the Pulse nightclub in Orlando, Talbott Street announced in a press release that it would close on June 25. The release said the idea of a safe haven was being challenged in the time we live in, and that the club was proud to have been a safe place for more than a decade. It gave no reason for closing. Wikipedia notes, citing the Indianapolis Star, that the owner's cousin said the closing was not a reaction to the violence and had been in the works. The club shut for good on June 25, 2016.
Baby's in the old theatre
The building later reopened as Baby's, a restaurant that kept some of the original details, added bright decor and neon signs, and runs a drag brunch on Sundays.
Sources
- Talbott Street Theater, Wikipedia
- Indianapolis Then and Now: Talbott Theatre, 2143 N. Talbott Street, Historic Indianapolis
- Longtime nightclub known for drag shows closing, Indianapolis Business Journal
The gift shop
The Talbott Street sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Talbott Street pieces





