Sundown Saloon
Sundown Saloon served margaritas, ribs and ballgames over a copper-topped bar at 403 Greenwich Avenue, Greenwich, until South Bay replaced it in 2019.
- Where
- 403 Greenwich Avenue, downtown Greenwich, Connecticut
- Open
- Closed 2019
- Known for
- Copper-topped saloon bar and softball sponsor on Greenwich Avenue
- Reading time
- 3 minutes

Taking over Casey's at 403 Greenwich Avenue
Sundown Saloon sat at 403 Greenwich Avenue, near the bottom of Greenwich Avenue, the town's main shopping street. The room had been a restaurant for years before it: Casey's, and before that Mickey's. Phil DiStefano opened Sundown in the old Casey's space. Teresa Bracchitta, who had worked with him at Tumbledown Dick's in Cos Cob, followed him there and became his business partner.
The pair added a sister restaurant a few doors down in 1989, Thataway Cafe at 409 Greenwich Avenue, and later the Beach House Cafe on Sound Beach Avenue in Old Greenwich. For years the three restaurants linked to one another from their websites. No source we found gives Sundown's opening year; in 2017 its own site said it had been on the Avenue for more than 25 years. By 2015 Bracchitta was running Sundown with her longtime partner Joe Ribeiro.
The copper bar, the booths and the white storefront
The front was a white-painted storefront with columns either side of the door and the name over both windows in black serif capitals, SUNDOWN and SALOON split by a red star. Inside, a long copper-topped bar ran down the middle of the room with dining tables around it, under exposed brick. The bar described its look as a western saloon that was fun without being hokey. A family dining room had custom leather booths, and the kitchen leaned on house-smoked baby back ribs, an El Paso chopped salad, mac and cheese, breakfast burritos at Sunday brunch and fresh-squeezed margaritas, which the bar claimed were the best in Connecticut.
Television screens carried the games, and in its last years the bar called itself Greenwich Avenue's only sports bar. Greenwich Patch, in 2011, summed it up as a family bar with rock, blues or alt-country bands about once a month.
Margarita nights, Mark and Artie, and the softball team
In the early 2000s the weekly calendar ran a $2 draught happy hour on weeknights, live music on Wednesdays from Mark and Artie playing songs from the 1960s to the 1980s, $4 margaritas on Thursdays, DJ Dale on Fridays with a late happy hour from midnight to closing, and a Saturday ladies' night. The bar ran a golf tournament for regulars in September 2002. Other years brought trivia on Sundays, Retro Mondays and, around 2012, acoustic Thursdays with Mike Milazzo and Broken Arrow.
The bar sponsored a softball team of local men, several of whom had played together as 11- and 12-year-olds on an undefeated 1981 youth baseball team, the Pizza Post Padres. Their own history on the bar's website said the team had been sponsored first by the Horseneck Tavern, then the Station House, and moved to Sundown when it took over Casey's. By 2007 the team was in its tenth season, and its trophies stood on display in the bar.
St. Patrick's Day and a television role
In March 2012 Greenwich Patch readers voted Sundown Saloon and the Two Door Restaurant joint winners as the best place in town for St. Patrick's Day, each with 37 percent of the vote. The same piece noted that the bar had been used as the setting for several scenes of the Showtime series The Big C, which starred Laura Linney.
Closing, and South Bay at 403 Greenwich Avenue
In 2017 the bar relaunched its website with a new orange half-sun logo and added oysters and mussels to the menu. The site was still listing Sundown's hours at the end of November 2018. By the end of January 2019 its web address had lapsed, and no announcement of the closing or reason for it has turned up in the local press.
By late May 2019 the space was being fitted out for South Bay, a Mediterranean seafood restaurant from the Siguenza family's JS Restaurant Group, which owned Harvest across the street. Greenwich Time called the departed Sundown a longtime staple on the Avenue. South Bay opened on June 4, 2019, with new banks of windows across the front and blue-painted woodwork, but kept Sundown's exposed brick. South Bay closed in January 2026, and the group announced that the space would reopen as Blu Olive.
Sources
- South Bay Opens on Greenwich Ave at Former Sundown Saloon, June 2, 2019, Greenwich Free Press
- Restaurant changes reshaping Greenwich Avenue, June 6, 2019, Greenwich Time
- From Tumbledown Dicks to Beach House Café: Greenwich's Teresa Bracchitta's Secrets of Success, June 5, 2015, Greenwich Free Press
- Readers' Choice Winners: Sundown Saloon, Two Door Restaurant, March 16, 2012, Greenwich Patch
- Patch Picks: Five Local Live Music Bars, September 27, 2011, Greenwich Patch
- South Bay Closed Permanently on Greenwich Ave; to Reopen as Blu Olive, January 14, 2026, Greenwich Free Press
- Sundown Saloon: home, events and past events pages, 2002 to 2005, sundownsaloon.com via Internet Archive
- Sundown Softball page, 2007, sundownsaloon.com via Internet Archive
- Sundown Saloon home and About Us pages, 2012 to 2018, sundownsaloon.com via Internet Archive
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Sundown Saloon.
Share a memory of Sundown Saloon
The gift shop
The Sundown Saloon sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All Sundown Saloon pieces

